In short
The historical school holds that law is not made by a sovereign at will but grows out of the history, customs and common consciousness of a people. Its founder, Friedrich Carl von Savigny (1779 to 1861), taught that law is an expression of the Volksgeist, the spirit of the people, and opposed hasty codification in Germany. Sir Henry Maine (1822 to 1888), in Ancient Law (1861), studied how legal systems develop and famously concluded that the movement of progressive societies has been “from status to contract”. The school is especially relevant in Tanzania, where customary law, the 1963 declarations of customary law, and debates about reforming custom raise the same questions.
On this page 8 sections
- What did Savigny teach?
- What are the criticisms of Savigny?
- What did Maine contribute?
- How does the historical school apply in Tanzania?
- How does the historical school compare with other schools?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on the historical school?
- Practice question: Assess the relevance of Savigny's Volksgeist theory to Tanzania.
- Key takeaways
What did Savigny teach?
- Law and the Volksgeist: like language, law is a product of a people’s shared life and grows organically. It is found, not made.
- Stages of development: law first lives in popular custom and belief; as society becomes complex, jurists take over its technical development, but they still express the people’s consciousness.
- Opposition to codification: in 1814 Thibaut proposed a single civil code for the German states, modelled on the French Code. Savigny replied in On the Vocation of Our Age for Legislation and Jurisprudence that Germany was not ready: a code made before the law had matured would freeze it and cut it off from the people’s life.
- Legislation has a limited role: the legislator should declare and refine law that already exists in the people’s consciousness.
His follower Puchta developed the idea of the people’s common conviction as the source of law.
What are the criticisms of Savigny?
- The Volksgeist is vague: which people, and whose spirit? Societies are divided by class, religion, ethnicity and gender.
- He underrated legislation: statutes can reform society deliberately; many reforms run against popular custom.
- Borrowed law: Savigny himself studied Roman law, which Germany had received from outside; much law, including English law in East Africa, is transplanted rather than home-grown.
- Conservatism and nationalism: the idea can be used to resist reform and was later misused by nationalist movements.
Key Statutes and Cases on The Historical School: Savigny and Maine
Statutes
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358Recognition of customary law; reception of English law (22 July 1920)
- Local Customary Law (Declaration) Orders, 1963 (GN 279 and GN 436 of 1963)Restated customary law of persons, inheritance and wills
Cases
- Ephrahim v Pastory (2001) AHRLR 236 (TzHC 1990)Discriminatory customary rule on clan land could not stand
Test yourself
The Historical School: Savigny and Maine Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
