In short
Marxist theory sees law as part of the superstructure of society, shaped by the economic base, the mode of production and the relations between classes. In class societies, law mainly serves the interests of the ruling class, protecting its property and its control over labour, while presenting itself as neutral. Marx and Engels predicted that, after the proletarian revolution and the end of classes, the state and law would “wither away”. Later Marxists, including Pashukanis, Renner, Gramsci and E.P. Thompson, refined the theory, and Tanzanian scholars such as Issa Shivji used it to analyse colonial and post-colonial law.
On this page 7 sections
- What are the basic ideas of Marxist legal theory?
- How did later Marxists develop the theory?
- How has Marxist theory been applied to Tanzania?
- What are the criticisms of Marxist theory of law?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on Marxist theory of law?
- Practice question: "Law is nothing but an instrument of the ruling class." Discuss with reference to Tanzania.
- Key takeaways
What are the basic ideas of Marxist legal theory?
- Historical materialism: the way a society produces its material life (its economic base) shapes its political, legal and ideological superstructure.
- Class struggle: history is the history of struggles between classes: slave and master, serf and lord, worker and capitalist.
- Law as class instrument: the state is a machine for the rule of one class over another, and law is one of its tools. Property law protects the owners of the means of production; contract law presents unequal bargains between employer and worker as free agreements.
- Law as ideology: ideas such as equality before the law and freedom of contract hide real inequality, so the law appears just while serving the powerful.
- Withering away: in a classless communist society, there would be no need for a state or for law as coercion; administration of things would replace the government of people.
How did later Marxists develop the theory?
- Engels warned in later letters against crude determinism: the economic base is decisive only “in the last instance”, and law has relative autonomy and can react back on the base.
- Karl Renner showed how legal institutions like property and contract keep the same form while their social functions change: private property in a factory becomes, in effect, power over workers.
- Evgeny Pashukanis, in The General Theory of Law and Marxism (1924), argued that the legal form itself arises from the exchange of commodities between owners. Law is essentially bourgeois and would disappear under communism. Stalin’s regime rejected him and he was executed in 1937, as Soviet theory turned to strong “socialist legality”.
- Antonio Gramsci explained that ruling classes rule mainly by hegemony, winning consent through culture, education and law, not only by force.
- E.P. Thompson, in Whigs and Hunters (1975), studied the harsh 18th-century Black Act but concluded that the rule of law, by imposing restraints on the powerful, is “an unqualified human good”. This challenged the view that law is simply a tool of class rule.
Key Statutes and Cases on The Marxist Theory of Law
Statutes
- Land Ordinance, 1923 (Tanganyika)Land declared public land under the Governor
- Arusha Declaration, 1967Ujamaa and nationalisation
- Employment and Labour Relations Act, Cap. 366Employer and worker relations
Test yourself
The Marxist Theory of Law Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
