In short
Sociological jurisprudence studies law as a social institution: how it actually works in society and how it can be used to shape society. Eugen Ehrlich (1862 to 1922) argued that the centre of legal development lies in society itself, in the “living law” that governs everyday life, rather than in statutes or court decisions. Roscoe Pound (1870 to 1964) saw law as social engineering: balancing individual, public and social interests to satisfy as many wants as possible with the least friction and waste, and distinguished “law in books” from “law in action”. Max Weber (1864 to 1920) explained how types of authority and types of legal rationality shape legal systems. Durkheim linked types of law to types of social solidarity.
On this page 7 sections
- What did Ehrlich mean by the living law?
- What was Pound's theory of social engineering?
- What did Weber and Durkheim contribute?
- How can sociological jurisprudence be applied in Tanzania?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on sociological jurisprudence?
- Practice question: Evaluate Pound's theory of law as social engineering with reference to Tanzania.
- Key takeaways
What did Ehrlich mean by the living law?
In Fundamental Principles of the Sociology of Law (1913), Ehrlich argued that most social order comes not from the state but from the inner order of associations: families, villages, clans, businesses, churches and trade unions. The norms these associations actually follow are the living law. State law (norms for decision used by courts) is only a small part of law, and it is effective only if it is in line with living law. To know the law, the jurist must observe social life, documents and practices, not only statutes.
Critics say Ehrlich blurred law into all social norms, and underrated the state’s power to change behaviour.
What was Pound’s theory of social engineering?
- Law in books and law in action: the written rules often differ from what officials and citizens actually do. Jurisprudence must study the actual effects of law.
- Law as social engineering: the task of law is to reconcile and balance conflicting interests so as to satisfy the maximum of wants with the minimum of friction.
- Classification of interests:
- individual interests: personality, domestic relations and substance (property, contract);
- public interests: interests of the state as a legal person and as guardian of social interests; and
- social interests: general security, security of social institutions, general morals, conservation of social resources, general progress and individual life.
- Jural postulates: each civilised society has assumptions, for example that people will not intentionally harm others and will keep their undertakings, from which legal rules develop.
Key Statutes and Cases on Sociological Jurisprudence: Ehrlich, Pound and Weber
Statutes
- Law of Marriage Act, Cap. 29s. 114 division of matrimonial assets
- Villages and Ujamaa Villages (Registration, Designation and Administration) Act, 1975Villagisation
- African Chiefs (Abolition of Office) Act, 1963Abolition of chiefs
- Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 30(2) limitation of rights
Cases
- Bi Hawa Mohamed v Ally Sefu, [1983] TZCA 1Domestic work recognised as contribution
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Daudi Pete, [1991] TZCA 1Limits on rights must be reasonably necessary
Test yourself
Sociological Jurisprudence: Ehrlich, Pound and Weber Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
