Jurisprudence notes · Topic 14 of 16

Critical Legal Studies and Feminist Jurisprudence

Critical legal studies (indeterminacy, law as politics, legitimation) and feminist jurisprudence (liberal, radical, cultural, postmodern and African strands), with Tanzanian cases on domestic work, customary land and inheritance, and child marriage.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 10 min read

In short

Critical legal studies (CLS) and feminist jurisprudence challenge the claim that law is neutral, objective and separate from politics. CLS, which emerged in the United States in the late 1970s, argues that legal doctrine is indeterminate and contradictory, that “law is politics”, and that liberal legal ideas legitimise existing hierarchies. Feminist jurisprudence examines how law has been made by and for men, and how it contributes to the subordination of women. Its main strands are liberal feminism (equal treatment), radical feminism (law as male dominance), cultural feminism (an ethic of care) and postmodern and African feminisms. Tanzanian cases on customary inheritance, marriage age and matrimonial property show these ideas in action.

On this page 7 sections
  1. What are the main claims of critical legal studies?
  2. What are the main strands of feminist jurisprudence?
  3. How have Tanzanian courts dealt with women's rights?
  4. How can CLS and feminism be used in an exam answer?
  5. Exam focus: what do examiners test on CLS and feminist jurisprudence?
  6. Practice question: "The law in Tanzania is gender-neutral." Discuss from a feminist perspective.
  7. Key takeaways
  • Indeterminacy: legal rules and doctrines can usually support more than one result, so judicial decisions are not compelled by law; they reflect choices.
  • Law is politics: because law is indeterminate, legal decisions are political decisions dressed in legal reasoning.
  • Contradiction: liberal law is built on contradictions, such as individualism against altruism and rules against standards (Duncan Kennedy).
  • Legitimation: legal ideas such as freedom of contract and the public/private divide make existing inequalities seem natural and fair.
  • Methods: “trashing” (exposing hidden assumptions in legal texts) and deconstruction.

Leading figures include Roberto Unger, Duncan Kennedy and Mark Kelman. CLS draws on legal realism (indeterminacy; see Legal Realism: American and Scandinavian) and on Marxism (legitimation; see The Marxist Theory of Law), but it rejects Marxist economic determinism.

What are the criticisms of CLS?

  • It exaggerates indeterminacy: most legal questions have clear answers.
  • It is better at criticism than at offering an alternative.
  • Rights are valuable to oppressed groups, a point made by critical race scholars who otherwise share CLS’s suspicion of liberal law.

What are the main strands of feminist jurisprudence?

Key Statutes and Cases on Critical Legal Studies and Feminist Jurisprudence

Statutes

  • Law of Marriage Act, Cap. 29s. 114 matrimonial assets
  • Local Customary Law (Declaration) (No. 4) Order, 1963Customary inheritance rules
  • Sexual Offences Special Provisions Act, 1998Reform of sexual offences
  • Land Act and Village Land Act, 1999Women's equal land rights

Cases

  • Bi Hawa Mohamed v Ally Sefu, [1983] TZCA 1Domestic work counts as joint effort
  • Ephrahim v Pastory (2001) AHRLR 236 (TzHC 1990)Customary rule on clan land held discriminatory
  • Elizabeth Stephen and Salome Charles v Attorney General, Misc. Civil Cause No. 82 of 2005 (HC, 2006)Customary inheritance rules found discriminatory but not struck down
  • Attorney General v Rebeca Z. Gyumi, [2019] TZCA 348Unequal marriage ages held unconstitutional

Test yourself

Critical Legal Studies and Feminist Jurisprudence Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Jurisprudence Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now