Jurisprudence notes · Topic 12 of 16

Legal Realism: American and Scandinavian

Legal realism: Holmes's prediction theory and the bad man, rule and fact scepticism, Frank and Llewellyn, Scandinavian realism of Hägerström, Olivecrona and Ross, Hart's critique and Tanzanian examples.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 10 min read

In short

Legal realism shifts attention from what the rules say to what courts and officials actually do. American realists, building on Oliver Wendell Holmes’s definition of law as “prophecies of what the courts will do in fact”, argued that rules do not decide cases by themselves: judges’ personalities, values and the facts as found drive outcomes. Jerome Frank and Karl Llewellyn led the movement. Scandinavian realists such as Axel Hägerström, Karl Olivecrona and Alf Ross attacked the idea of binding norms as metaphysical, explaining law instead as psychological and social facts. Both schools reject the formalist idea that law is a closed, logical system.

On this page 9 sections
  1. What did Holmes contribute?
  2. What were the main ideas of American realism?
  3. What did the Scandinavian realists argue?
  4. How do American and Scandinavian realism differ?
  5. What are the criticisms of realism?
  6. How is realism useful for Tanzanian lawyers?
  7. Exam focus: what do examiners test on legal realism?
  8. Practice question: "Law is what the judges say it is." Discuss.
  9. Key takeaways

What did Holmes contribute?

In “The Path of the Law” (1897), Holmes said that to know the law you should look at it as a “bad man” would: someone who cares only about the material consequences the courts will impose. On that view, law is the prophecy of what the courts will do in fact. He also wrote that “the life of the law has not been logic: it has been experience”, meaning that law grows from social needs, policy and the prejudices of judges, not from deduction.

What were the main ideas of American realism?

  • Rule scepticism: written rules are indeterminate; judges can usually find a rule or precedent to support either side. Llewellyn showed that canons of statutory interpretation come in opposing pairs.
  • Fact scepticism: Jerome Frank, in Law and the Modern Mind (1930), argued that the greater uncertainty lies in fact-finding: witnesses err, and trial judges and juries decide facts in unpredictable ways. Appellate rules matter less than trial court fact-finding.
  • Judicial behaviour: judges often reach a result by intuition (a “hunch”) and then justify it with rules. Law should be studied through what judges actually do.
  • Law as a means to social ends: rules should be evaluated by their effects; law should draw on the social sciences.
  • Llewellyn’s law-jobs: every group must handle trouble cases, channel conduct, allocate authority and organise. He contrasted the Grand Style of judging (reasoning from policy and purpose) with the Formal Style (mechanical application of rules).

Key Statutes and Cases on Legal Realism: American and Scandinavian

Cases

  • Republic v Mbushuu [1994] TLR 146 (HC)Death penalty held unconstitutional
  • Mbushuu alias Dominic Mnyaroje and Another v Republic [1995] TLR 97 (CAT)Same Constitution, opposite conclusion
  • Julius Ishengoma Francis Ndyanabo v Attorney General, [2002] TZCA 14Purposive interpretation

Test yourself

Legal Realism: American and Scandinavian Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Jurisprudence Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now