In short
Two famous debates define the modern relationship between law and morality. In the Hart–Fuller debate (1958), Hart defended the positivist separation of law as it is from law as it ought to be, while Fuller argued that law has an inner morality and that Nazi “law” had fallen so far below it that it was not law. In the Hart–Devlin debate, which followed the Wolfenden Report (1957), Lord Devlin argued that society may use the criminal law to enforce its shared morality, while Hart, following John Stuart Mill, argued that the law should punish only conduct that harms others, not private immorality as such.
On this page 7 sections
- What was the Hart–Fuller debate about?
- What was the Hart–Devlin debate about?
- Which cases show courts enforcing morality?
- How does the debate apply in Tanzania?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on law and morality?
- Practice question: "The law should not concern itself with private morality." Discuss.
- Key takeaways
What was the Hart–Fuller debate about?
In 1958 the Harvard Law Review published Hart’s “Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals” and Fuller’s reply, “Positivism and Fidelity to Law”. The debate centred on how post-war German courts should treat acts done under Nazi laws.
What was the grudge informer case?
In 1944 a woman who wanted to be rid of her husband reported to the authorities remarks he had made criticising Hitler. Under Nazi statutes he was sentenced to death, though the sentence was later converted to service at the front. After the war, in 1949, she was prosecuted, and a German court convicted her of unlawfully depriving her husband of his liberty. As reported in English, the court reasoned that the Nazi statutes were contrary to the sound conscience and sense of justice of all decent people. Later research showed the court actually decided the case on narrower grounds, but the debate was conducted on the reported version.
What did Hart argue?
- Nazi laws were law, though morally iniquitous. It is clearer and more honest to say “this is law, but too evil to obey” than “this is not law”.
- If the informer was to be punished, it should be done openly by retroactive legislation, accepting the moral cost of retroactivity, not by pretending the earlier law was never law.
- Separating law from morality helps citizens criticise law and resist it when necessary.
What did Fuller argue?
- Law has an inner morality (generality, publicity, non-retroactivity and so on). Nazi rule involved secret laws, retroactive statutes and officials ignoring their own rules, so it had departed so far from legality that it was not a true legal system. See Modern Natural Law: Fuller and Finnis.
- Fidelity to law is a moral ideal; lawyers owe it only to an order that deserves the name of law.
Key Statutes and Cases on Law and Morality: The Hart–Fuller and Hart–Devlin Debates
Statutes
- Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 30(2) limitation of rights, including for public morality
- Penal Code, Cap. 16Unnatural offences and gross indecency
Cases
- Shaw v DPP [1962] AC 220Conspiracy to corrupt public morals
- Knuller v DPP [1973] AC 435Conspiracy to corrupt public morals upheld
- R v Brown [1994] 1 AC 212Consent no defence to actual bodily harm
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Daudi Pete, [1991] TZCA 1Limits on rights must be lawful and necessary
- Mbushuu alias Dominic Mnyaroje and Another v Republic [1995] TLR 97Public opinion and the death penalty
Test yourself
Law and Morality: The Hart–Fuller and Hart–Devlin Debates Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
