In short
H.L.A. Hart’s The Concept of Law (1961) is the most influential modern account of legal positivism. Rejecting Austin’s command theory, Hart explained law as the union of primary rules (which impose duties) and secondary rules (rules about rules): the rule of recognition, rules of change and rules of adjudication. Rules exist because people take an internal point of view towards them, treating them as standards. The ultimate test of validity in a legal system is its rule of recognition, which exists as a practice of officials. Hart also argued that rules have an “open texture”, that judges have discretion in hard cases, and that every legal system must have a “minimum content of natural law”.
On this page 10 sections
- Why did Hart reject the command theory?
- What are the internal and external aspects of rules?
- What are primary and secondary rules?
- What is the rule of recognition?
- What did Hart say about open texture and judicial discretion?
- What is the minimum content of natural law?
- What are the main criticisms of Hart?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on Hart?
- Practice question: Identify and explain the rule of recognition in Tanzania.
- Key takeaways
Why did Hart reject the command theory?
Hart showed that Austin’s model of orders backed by threats could not explain power-conferring rules, the continuity and persistence of law, or limited sovereignty, and that it confused being obliged (as by a gunman) with having an obligation. See Bentham and Austin: The Command Theory of Law. Hart needed the idea of a rule.
What are the internal and external aspects of rules?
A habit is merely convergent behaviour (people go to the cinema on Saturdays). A social rule also has an internal aspect: people treat it as a standard, criticise deviations, and use words like “ought”, “must” and “should”. An observer who only records regularities takes the external point of view; a participant who accepts the rule as a guide takes the internal point of view. Legal obligation exists where a rule is accepted from the internal point of view, at least by officials.
What are primary and secondary rules?
Hart imagined a simple society governed only by primary rules of obligation, such as rules against violence, theft and deception. Such a society would suffer three defects, each cured by a type of secondary rule:
| Defect | Remedy | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Uncertainty: no way to tell what the rules are | Rule of recognition | Identifies valid rules of the system |
| Static character: no way to change rules deliberately | Rules of change | Empower people or bodies to make, amend and repeal rules (legislation, contracts, wills) |
| Inefficiency: no authoritative way to settle disputes | Rules of adjudication | Empower courts to decide whether rules have been broken and to impose remedies |
Key Statutes and Cases on Hart’s Concept of Law
Statutes
- Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 64(5) supremacy of the Constitution
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358Reception of English law (22 July 1920); customary and Islamic law
Test yourself
Hart’s Concept of Law Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
