In short
In a subordinate court trial, the prosecution calls its witnesses and tenders its exhibits after a plea of not guilty (section 246 of the Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023). At the close of the prosecution case, the court decides whether a case has been made out sufficiently to require a defence. If not, it acquits under section 247. If so, it explains the accused’s rights under section 248: to give evidence on oath or affirmation, to make an unsworn statement or to remain silent, and to call witnesses, with the warning that the court may draw an adverse inference from silence (section 248(3)). After any evidence in reply (section 249), the court gives its decision under section 252, in a judgment that complies with sections 330 and 331. Every documentary exhibit must be cleared, admitted and read out (Robinson Mwanjisi v Republic [2003] TLR 218).
On this page 6 sections
Baraka Mollel’s case is now set for hearing in the District Court of Moshi after the preliminary hearing in Preliminary Hearing and Committal Proceedings. For the theory, read the LLB topic Trial Procedure in Tanzanian Criminal Courts.
What are the stages of a summary trial?
How does the prosecution case run?
Each prosecution witness is sworn or affirmed, examined in chief by the prosecutor, cross-examined by the defence and re-examined. The magistrate records the evidence in narrative form, and each witness’s evidence should be read back to the witness. Exhibits are tendered through witnesses who can produce them.
Tendering exhibits properly
- Lay a foundationThe witness explains what the document or item is, how he knows it, and how it came into his possession.
- Tender it“Your Honour, I pray to tender the audit report as an exhibit.”
- Objection stageThe court asks the defence whether there is an objection. Object on admissibility now, or the point is weaker later.
- Admission and markingThe court admits it and marks it (for example, Exhibit P1).
- Read it outThe contents of a documentary exhibit must be read out in court after admission, so the accused knows what it says. In Robinson Mwanjisi v Republic [2003] TLR 218, the Court of Appeal set out this sequence of clearing, admitting and reading out. Documents admitted but not read out are routinely expunged on appeal.
Key Statutes and Cases on Conducting a Criminal Trial in the Subordinate Courts
Statutes
- Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023s. 200(4)-(6) alibi notice; s. 246 procedure on not guilty plea; s. 247 no case to answer; s. 248 defence; s. 249 evidence in reply; s. 252 decision; ss. 330-331 judgment
- Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023Admissibility of documents and witnesses
Cases
- Robinson Mwanjisi and 3 Others v Republic [2003] TLR 218Documents must be cleared, admitted and read out
Test yourself
Conducting a Criminal Trial in the Subordinate Courts Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
