In short
Plea bargaining lets the prosecution and the accused agree on a plea of guilty, usually to a lesser offence or to fewer counts, in exchange for concessions such as withdrawal of other charges or an agreed sentencing position. In the Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023, it is in sections 201 to 208: section 201 (plea bargaining), 202 (consequences), 203 (requirements of the agreement), 204 and 205 (registration and procedure), 206 (offences to which plea agreements do not apply), 207 (setting aside a conviction and sentence) and 208 (power to make rules). The agreement must be in writing, entered voluntarily, and registered by the court, which checks that the accused understands it and that there is a factual basis for the plea. Good plea bargaining is negotiation, not surrender: you need to know the weaknesses of the prosecution case before you sit down.
On this page 6 sections
This topic uses both running files. Baraka Mollel’s family wants to repay part of the alleged shortage. In Juma Hassan’s murder case, the evidence points toward manslaughter (Trial of Serious Offences in the High Court). Negotiation techniques are covered in the Advocacy Skills module.
When does plea bargaining make sense?
Strong prosecution case
Where conviction is likely, a negotiated plea can reduce the offence, the number of counts or the sentence.
Overcharging
Where the charge is more serious than the evidence supports (murder where the facts show manslaughter), a plea to the lesser offence reflects the true case.
Restitution possible
In property and economic cases, repayment or forfeiture can form part of the agreement and reduce the sentence.
Long remand
For a client held on remand for a non-bailable offence, a plea may end years of uncertainty. This must be his informed choice, never pressure.
Plea bargaining requires the client’s informed and voluntary decision. Explain in writing what he is admitting, the likely sentence range, that the court is not bound by the prosecution’s recommendation unless the law provides otherwise, and that he will have a criminal record. Never advise an innocent client to plead guilty because it is convenient.
Which offences are excluded?
Section 206 lists offences to which plea agreements do not apply. Read it for every file before you open negotiations. The excluded categories are offences the legislature considered too grave for negotiated pleas, such as certain sexual offences and other serious offences listed in the section. If your client’s offence is excluded, you cannot negotiate a plea agreement under these provisions, although the prosecution may still decide what to charge or may withdraw a charge.
Key Statutes and Cases on Plea Bargaining in Practice
Statutes
- Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023s. 201 plea bargaining; s. 202 consequences; s. 203 requirements; ss. 204-205 registration; s. 206 excluded offences; s. 207 setting aside; s. 208 rules
- Penal Code, Cap. 16 R.E. 2023Lesser and included offences
Test yourself
Plea Bargaining in Practice Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
