In short
After a plea of not guilty, the court holds a preliminary hearing under section 198 of the Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023 to identify the matters that are not in dispute. Those matters are recorded in a memorandum, read over, and signed by the accused, his advocate and the prosecutor; they are then treated as proved, so witnesses on those points need not be called. For offences triable by the High Court, such as murder, the subordinate court does not try the case. It remands the accused until the DPP files an information, then conducts committal proceedings (sections 259 to 263): the information and the statements of the intended witnesses are read to the accused, and the record is sent to the High Court (section 273). Both stages look like paperwork, but careless admissions at a preliminary hearing can convict your client before trial begins.
On this page 6 sections
This topic uses two files: Baraka Mollel’s stealing by servant case in the District Court of Moshi, and a new High Court file, Republic v Juma Hassan, a murder charge arising from a fight at a bar in Same District. For the theory, see the LLB topic Committal Proceedings.
What is the purpose of a preliminary hearing?
Section 198 requires the court, after a plea of not guilty and as soon as is convenient, to hold a preliminary hearing to consider matters that are not in dispute and that will promote a fair and expeditious trial. In practice the prosecutor reads out a summary of the facts. The accused, through his advocate, states which facts he admits. The admitted facts are written down in a memorandum.
Typical facts to admit
The accused’s name and address, that he was employed as a cashier, the date of arrest, that he was taken to the police station.
Typical facts to dispute
That he took the money, the amount of any shortage, that he had sole access to the till, the accuracy of the audit.
Exhibits
You may admit the existence of a document (for example, the appointment letter) without admitting the truth of its contents.
Witness list
The prosecution names its witnesses and exhibits, which helps you plan cross-examination.
How do you protect your client at the preliminary hearing?
- Get the facts in advanceAsk the prosecutor for the summary of facts before the hearing. Go through it with the client line by line.
- Admit only what is harmless and trueFormal facts (identity, employment, arrest) can be admitted to save time. Never admit facts that make up an ingredient of the offence.
- Distinguish documents from contentsSay “the existence of the audit report is not disputed; its contents and conclusions are disputed”.
- Read the memorandum before signingSection 198 requires the memorandum to be read over and explained, and signed by the accused and his advocate. Check the wording matches what was said.
- Note any irregularityIf the accused did not sign, or the memorandum was not read, note it. On appeal the Court of Appeal has held that facts in an unsigned or unread memorandum cannot be treated as proved.
Key Statutes and Cases on Preliminary Hearing and Committal Proceedings
Statutes
- Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023s. 198 preliminary hearing; ss. 259-263 committal for trial; s. 262(6)-(7) information; s. 273 committal record
Test yourself
Preliminary Hearing and Committal Proceedings Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
