On this page 9 sections
Introduction
The trial is the centrepiece of the criminal justice process — the moment at which the accusation is tested against the evidence and a verdict is reached. Understanding trial procedure requires knowing not just the rules themselves but the rationale behind them: why the prosecution goes first, why the accused is not compelled to testify, why evidence must be given under oath, and what happens at each stage.
Tanzania’s criminal trial procedure is adversarial in character. The prosecution and defence present their respective cases before an impartial judge or magistrate who evaluates the evidence and determines whether the prosecution has discharged the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The court is not an investigator — it is an umpire.
Trial procedure differs between subordinate courts (summary trial) and the High Court. We examine each in turn.
Summary Trial in Subordinate Courts — Section 213 CPA
Opening of the Case
The prosecution opens the trial by briefly outlining the case to the court — what the accused is charged with, what the prosecution intends to prove, and what witnesses it will call. This opening statement sets the scene but is not itself evidence.
Plea of the Accused
The charge is read to the accused in a language they understand, and the accused is asked to plead. The possible pleas are:
• Guilty: The accused admits the charge. The court must be satisfied the plea is voluntary and unequivocal before recording a conviction.
• Not guilty: The accused denies the charge. The trial proceeds.
• Autrefois acquit: The accused claims they have already been acquitted of the same charge by a competent court. This is a plea in bar of trial — if established, the accused cannot be tried again for the same offence.
• Autrefois convict: The accused claims they have already been convicted of the same offence. Similarly, a plea in bar of trial.
• Guilty to a lesser offence: The accused pleads guilty to a lesser included offence. The court may accept this if the prosecution agrees.
|
⚖ Constitution of Tanzania — Article 13(9) No person shall be tried or punished again for an offence of which they have previously been convicted or acquitted by a competent court — this is the constitutional basis for the autrefois pleas. |
Procedure Where Accused Pleads Guilty — Section 213(1) CPA
Section 213(1) provides a special streamlined procedure for minor non-warrant offences where the accused pleads guilty:
• The charge is read to the accused
• The facts are outlined by the prosecution
• The accused admits the facts
• The court may convict without recording prosecution evidence, if satisfied the plea and admission of facts are unequivocal
This procedure saves enormous court time for minor cases. However, the court must be absolutely certain the accused understands the charge and is pleading guilty voluntarily — not out of confusion, pressure, or a misunderstanding of the law.
The Preliminary Hearing — Section 192 CPA
Once the accused pleads not guilty, before the substantive evidence is heard, the court must conduct a preliminary hearing. The purpose of the preliminary hearing is to identify matters that are not in dispute between the parties — facts that both prosecution and defence agree are true — so that court time is not wasted proving what is already agreed.
|
⚖ Criminal Procedure Act — Section 192, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023 Before hearing evidence in a criminal case, the court shall hold a preliminary hearing to determine facts and issues which are agreed upon by the parties and those that are in dispute, with a view to expediting the proceedings. The court records agreed facts and issues in the form of a memorandum signed by both parties. |
Examples of matters commonly agreed at preliminary hearing:
• The identity of the accused
• That a certain document (e.g. a medical report) is authentic
• That a certain transaction took place on a certain date
The preliminary hearing speeds up trials significantly and is mandatory. Failure to hold a preliminary hearing may be cited as an irregularity on appeal.
Prosecution Case
Calling of Prosecution Witnesses
After the plea of not guilty, the prosecution calls its witnesses one by one. Each witness gives evidence in three stages:
• Examination-in-chief: The prosecution lawyer asks the witness questions about the facts. Leading questions (questions that suggest the answer) are generally not permitted in examination-in-chief.
Test yourself
Trial Procedure in Tanzanian Criminal Courts Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
