In short
Three kinds of evidence decide most Tanzanian criminal appeals: confessions, identification and physical exhibits. A confession (a cautioned statement to police or an extra-judicial statement before a justice of the peace) is admissible only if it was made voluntarily and recorded within the rules of the Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023, including the interview periods in sections 51 and 52 and the recording rules in sections 58 and 59. If voluntariness is challenged, the court must hold a trial within a trial (in a subordinate court, an inquiry) before admitting it. Visual identification must eliminate all possibility of mistaken identity: Waziri Amani v Republic [1980] TLR 250. Physical exhibits need an unbroken chain of custody, a chronological paper trail from seizure to court: Paulo Maduka and 4 Others v Republic, Criminal Appeal No. 110 of 2007. And every documentary exhibit must be read out after admission: Robinson Mwanjisi v Republic [2003] TLR 218.
On this page 5 sections
This topic draws on both running files: Baraka Mollel’s stealing case and Juma Hassan’s murder trial. For the theory, read the LLB topics Confessions, Documentary Evidence and Electronic and Digital Evidence.
How do you challenge a cautioned statement?
A cautioned statement is often the strongest prosecution evidence, and the defence’s best chance is to keep it out. There are two kinds of objection, and you must say which you are making.
Retracted
The accused admits making the statement but says he made it involuntarily (for example after a beating, threat or promise). This raises voluntariness and requires a trial within a trial or inquiry.
Repudiated
The accused says he never made the statement at all (for example, he signed blank paper). This is a question of fact for the court at the end of the trial, but you still object on the record.
Procedural
Recorded outside the lawful interview period (ss. 51-52), rights not explained (ss. 53-54), access to a lawyer refused (s. 55), not read over before signing.
Form
No caution recorded, no certificate by the recording officer, interpreter not identified, statement in a language the accused does not understand.
- Object when the statement is tendered“Your Lordship, the defence objects to the cautioned statement on the ground that it was not made voluntarily: the accused was beaten. We pray for a trial within a trial.”
- The trial within a trialThe prosecution calls the recording officer and others to prove voluntariness. You cross-examine on the times, the injuries, who was present and the absence of a lawyer. The accused may testify on the issue alone.
- RulingThe court rules whether the statement is admitted. The Court of Appeal has stressed the need to conduct a trial within a trial whenever voluntariness is challenged; in Twaha Ali and 5 Others v Republic, Criminal Appeal No. 78 of 2004 (unreported), the Court addressed this requirement.
- WeightEven if admitted, a retracted confession is treated with caution, and the court will look for corroboration as a matter of practice.
Key Statutes and Cases on Criminal Evidence in Practice: Confessions, Identification and Exhibits
Statutes
- Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023ss. 51-52 interview periods; ss. 53-55 rights; ss. 58-59 statements; s. 61 identification parades
- Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023Confessions, documents and electronic evidence
- Criminal Procedure (Audio and Video Recording of Interviews with Suspects) Rules, 2023 (GN No. 792 of 2023)Recorded interviews
Cases
- Waziri Amani v Republic [1980] TLR 250Visual identification guidelines
- Paulo Maduka and 4 Others v Republic, Criminal Appeal No. 110 of 2007 (CAT, unreported)Chain of custody
- Robinson Mwanjisi and 3 Others v Republic [2003] TLR 218Documents must be read out
- Twaha Ali and 5 Others v Republic, Criminal Appeal No. 78 of 2004 (CAT, unreported)Trial within a trial
Test yourself
Criminal Evidence in Practice: Confessions, Identification and Exhibits Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
