On this page 9 sections
Introduction
Committal proceedings occupy a unique and sometimes controversial position in the Tanzanian criminal justice system. They are a procedural step that occurs between the charging of an accused person with a serious offence in a subordinate court and the commencement of the actual trial in the High Court. Their purpose is to act as a ‘filter’ — to ensure that an accused person is not put on trial before the High Court unless there is sufficient evidence to justify it.
Think of committal proceedings as a preliminary examination: the subordinate court reviews the prosecution evidence to decide whether there is a prima facie case — a case that, if not answered, could result in a conviction. If so, the accused is ‘committed’ (sent) to the High Court for trial. If not, the accused is discharged.
Committal proceedings are provided for in sections 243 to 263 of the CPA. They apply only to offences triable by the High Court — that is, offences designated in the First Schedule as requiring High Court trial (including capital offences such as murder).
Meaning and Definition
|
📖 Definition: Committal Proceedings Committal proceedings are proceedings held before a subordinate court magistrate with the purpose of determining whether there is sufficient evidence to justify committing (sending) an accused person to the High Court for trial. The magistrate does not decide guilt or innocence — only whether the evidence, if believed, could support a conviction. |
Key Terminology
• Committing magistrate: The magistrate who conducts the committal proceedings
• Prima facie case: Literally ‘at first face’ — a case that discloses sufficient evidence on each element of the offence to justify requiring the accused to answer it
• Transmission of record: The process of sending the record of committal proceedings to the High Court
Which Courts Hold Committal Proceedings?
|
⚖ Criminal Procedure Act — Section 244, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023 Where a person is charged before a subordinate court with an offence which is required by the First Schedule to be tried by the High Court, that subordinate court shall hold committal proceedings and shall not proceed to try the accused summarily. |
This means that when an accused appears before a District Court or Resident Magistrate Court charged with, say, murder or robbery with violence, the subordinate court does NOT try the case. Instead, it holds committal proceedings and, if the evidence is sufficient, sends the case to the High Court.
The Procedure for Committal Proceedings — Sections 245–263 CPA
Step 1: Preliminary Steps — Section 245 CPA
When an accused person charged with an offence triable by the High Court appears before a subordinate court, the magistrate must:
• Explain to the accused the nature of the charge
• Inform the accused that they are not required to answer the charge at this stage but that the proceedings are for the purpose of determining whether there is sufficient evidence to commit them to the High Court
• Read or cause to be read to the accused any statement they have made to the police
Step 2: Prosecution Evidence — Section 246 CPA
The prosecution calls its witnesses. Unlike a full trial, at committal proceedings:
• The prosecution is not required to call all its witnesses — only enough to establish a prima facie case
• Witnesses give evidence orally; their statements are recorded in writing
• The accused (or their lawyer) may cross-examine each prosecution witness
• Written statements may be tendered in lieu of oral evidence in certain circumstances
Step 3: Decision by the Magistrate — Section 246(3) CPA
After the prosecution has presented its evidence, the magistrate makes a decision:
• If there is NO prima facie case: the magistrate discharges the accused. Discharge at committal proceedings is NOT the same as an acquittal — the prosecution may subsequently bring fresh committal proceedings if new evidence emerges
Test yourself
Committal Proceedings Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
