On this page 2 sections
Introduction to Burden and Standard of Proof
In every court case, there is always a disagreement about facts. One party claims something happened, and the other denies it.
The court must answer two key questions:
-
Who must prove the fact? → This is the burden of proof
-
How strong must the proof be? → This is the standard of proof
These two concepts are the foundation of all legal decision-making. They determine:
-
Whether an accused is convicted or acquitted
-
Whether a claimant wins or loses a civil case
Meaning and Definition
Legal Definition
The burden of proof is the obligation placed on a party to establish the existence of a fact to the satisfaction of the court. It answers the question: on whom does the duty to prove this fact rest?
The standard of proof is the degree of certainty or persuasion that the evidence must achieve before the court accepts that a fact has been proved. It answers the question: how convincingly must the fact be proved?
Tanzania’s Evidence Act addresses burden of proof primarily in Sections 109 to 122, which set out detailed rules about who bears the burden in different types of proceedings and for different types of facts.
Simple Explanation
Think of the burden of proof as a torch. In every court case, someone must carry that torch and shine it on the facts they want the court to accept. If you carry the torch, you must light the way — you must produce the evidence. The standard of proof tells you how brightly you must shine the light before the court says “Yes, I can see it clearly enough.”
Key Legal Principles
The General Rule in Criminal Cases. The prosecution bears the burden of proving every element of the offence beyond reasonable doubt. The accused does not have to prove anything. This flows from the presumption of innocence — a person is innocent until the state proves them guilty.
The General Rule in Civil Cases. The party who asserts a fact bears the burden of proving it. In a contract dispute, the claimant bears the burden of proving the contract existed, that it was breached, and that they suffered loss. The defendant bears the burden of proving any affirmative defence they raise.
Evidential Burden vs. Legal Burden. The legal burden (also called the persuasive burden) is the ultimate responsibility of satisfying the court. The evidential burden is the lesser obligation of producing enough evidence to raise an issue for the court to consider. A party may bear an evidential burden without bearing the legal burden.
The Standard Is Fixed, Not Flexible. The standard of proof in criminal cases does not change depending on how serious the charge is. Whether the accused is charged with littering or murder, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt.
Sources of Law
Sections 109–122, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2022 — the primary statutory provisions on burden of proof.
Section 109 — the burden of proving a fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence.
Section 110 — the burden of proof regarding facts especially within the knowledge of a party.
Section 111 — burden of proving death of a person known to have been alive within thirty years.
Section 112 — burden of proving that a person is alive who has not been heard of for seven years.
Section 113 — burden of proof regarding relationship in cases of partners, landlord and tenant, and principal and agent.
Section 114 — burden of proof regarding ownership.
Section 115 — proof of good faith in transactions involving persons in a position of active confidence.
Sections 116–122 — further specific burden rules including the standard in criminal matters.
Constitution of Tanzania, Article 13(6)(b) — guarantees the presumption of innocence.
Essential Elements
The Legal Burden (Persuasive Burden)
The legal burden is the ultimate obligation to prove a fact to the required standard by the end of the proceedings. It does not shift during a trial — it remains with the party who bore it at the start. In a criminal trial, the legal burden on every element of the offence remains with the prosecution throughout. Even if the accused gives evidence and raises doubts, the prosecution must still ultimately satisfy the court beyond reasonable doubt.
Section 109 establishes the general rule: the burden of proving any fact lies on the party who would fail in their case if no evidence at all were given on that fact. In a criminal trial, if no evidence is given by either side, the accused is acquitted — therefore the prosecution bears the legal burden.
In a civil claim for breach of contract, if neither side gave any evidence, the claimant would fail — therefore the claimant bears the legal burden of proving the contract and its breach.
The Evidential Burden
The evidential burden — sometimes called the burden of adducing evidence — is the obligation to produce sufficient evidence on a particular issue to prevent the court from ruling against you on that issue without further consideration.
The evidential burden can shift during a trial. For example, in a criminal trial, once the prosecution has produced a prima facie case against the accused, the evidential burden shifts to the accused to produce some evidence in response. The accused does not need to prove their defence beyond reasonable doubt — they only need to raise enough evidence to create a reasonable doubt in the court’s mind.
Example. The prosecution charges Ally with theft and produces a witness who says they saw Ally take the money. A prima facie case is established. The evidential burden now shifts to Ally — not to prove his innocence, but to produce some evidence (perhaps an alibi) that makes the court uncertain. The legal burden remains with the prosecution throughout.
The Standard of Proof in Criminal Cases: Beyond Reasonable Doubt
In criminal proceedings, the prosecution must prove each element of the offence beyond reasonable doubt. This is the highest standard of proof in law. It does not mean absolute certainty — that would be an impossible standard, since we were not present at the scene. It means the court must be sure, having considered all the evidence, that the accused committed the offence.
The classic direction given to juries and magistrates in Tanzania and across the common law world is: if after considering all the evidence you have a reasonable doubt — a doubt based on reason, not on speculation or sympathy — you must acquit the accused.
What Is a Reasonable Doubt? A reasonable doubt is a doubt that would cause a prudent and careful person, in the conduct of their own important affairs, to hesitate and say “I am not certain.” It is not a fanciful doubt. It is not a doubt based on the hope that the accused is innocent. It is a real, rational doubt based on the evidence or the absence of evidence.
Test yourself
Burden and Standard of Proof Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
