Introduction to Competence and Compellability
Every case depends on witnesses — they are the people who bring facts to court.
But the law does not allow everyone to testify, and even when a person can testify, they may not always be forced to do so.
This topic answers two key questions:
-
Can this person testify? → Competence
-
Can this person be forced to testify? → Compellability
Understanding this helps you:
-
Know which witnesses you can call
-
Know when a witness can refuse to testify
Meaning and Definition
Legal Definition
A competent witness is a person who is legally allowed to give evidence in judicial proceedings. Competence is the basic qualification to testify. Where a person is not competent, they cannot take the oath, cannot enter the witness box, and their testimony is inadmissible.
A compellable witness is a competent witness who can be legally required — compelled — to give evidence in court. Not all competent witnesses are compellable. A spouse, for example, may be competent (allowed to testify) but not compellable (cannot be forced to testify) in certain proceedings.
Simple Explanation
Competence asks: can this person testify? Compellability asks: can this person be forced to testify? Most competent witnesses are also compellable. But certain categories of witnesses are protected — they may choose whether to testify, and the court cannot force them.
Key Legal Principles
The General Rule — All Persons Are Competent. Section 127 of the Evidence Act establishes a general presumption of competence: all persons are competent to testify unless the Act disqualifies them. The disqualifications are limited and specific.
Competence Does Not Guarantee Credibility. A person may be competent to give evidence but their evidence may carry little weight due to interest, bias, mental limitation, or poor perception. Competence and credibility are separate questions.
Compellability Is the Default for Competent Witnesses. A witness who is competent is generally also compellable. The exceptions to compellability are defined by law and are limited in number.
The Accused Is Not Compellable. An accused person in criminal proceedings is competent but not compellable as a witness for the prosecution. The right to remain silent is fundamental to the presumption of innocence.
Sources of Law
Section 127, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2023 — general rule: all persons are competent unless disqualified.
Section 128, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — dumb witnesses: may give evidence by any means of communication.
Section 129, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — evidence of and by spouses in civil proceedings.
Section 130, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — general competency of spouses in civil proceedings; specific rules in criminal proceedings.
Section 131, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — the accused as a witness.
Section 132, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — privilege regarding self-incrimination.
Section 136, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — order and direction of examination of witnesses.
Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20, Sections 193–200 — rights of the accused, right to silence, and procedures regarding accused as witness.
Evidence Act, Section 127(b) — a person is not competent if they are unable to understand the questions put to them or give rational answers, even if they understand the nature of the oath.
Essential Elements — Competence
The General Rule — Section 127
Section 127 provides that all persons shall be competent to testify unless the court considers that they are prevented from understanding the questions put to them, or from giving rational answers to those questions, by tender years, extreme old age, disease (whether of body or mind), or any other cause of the same kind.
This rule creates a very low threshold for competence. The question is not whether the witness will give good, accurate, or unbiased evidence — it is simply whether they can understand questions and give rational answers. A person who meets this test is competent even if the court anticipates that their evidence will be unreliable.
Children as Witnesses
Children are frequently witnesses in Tanzanian courts — particularly in cases involving domestic violence, sexual offences, or crimes occurring within families. The law distinguishes between children who can be sworn and children who cannot.
Children Who Can Take the Oath. A child who understands the nature and binding character of an oath and who appears to have sufficient intelligence to give reliable evidence may be sworn and will give evidence in the same way as an adult.
Children Who Cannot Take the Oath — Unsworn Evidence. Section 127(1)(b) of the Evidence Act (read with Section 127A) provides that where a child of tender years is called as a witness and does not understand the nature of an oath, the child may give unsworn evidence if the court is satisfied that they understand that they must tell the truth and are capable of giving reliable testimony.
The Test for Admissibility of a Child’s Unsworn Evidence. The court must conduct a preliminary examination (called a voire dire in some jurisdictions, or an inquiry in Tanzania) to assess whether the child understands the duty to tell the truth. This is a separate and prior inquiry before the child testifies on the substantive issues.
The Corroboration Warning. Where a child gives unsworn evidence, Tanzanian courts have traditionally applied the rule that it is dangerous to convict on unsworn evidence of a child without corroboration, or without the court warning itself of this danger and explaining why it considers it safe to convict notwithstanding. We examine corroboration in detail in Week 18.
Example. In a case of defilement, the complainant is a seven-year-old girl. The court conducts a preliminary examination: Does she know what it means to tell the truth? Does she understand that lying is wrong? Does she understand that she must only say what she knows? If the court is satisfied, the child may give evidence. Depending on her understanding of the oath, she may be sworn or give unsworn evidence.
Test yourself
Competence and Compellability of Witnesses Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
