Law of Evidence notes · Topic 13 of 19

Examination of Witnesses

Explains how witnesses are questioned in court, including examination-in-chief, cross-examination, and re-examination.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 14 min read

Introduction to Examination of Witnesses

Once a witness is declared competent, the next step is examining them in court.

This is where:

  • Evidence is presented

  • Truth is tested

  • Cases are won or lost

The law provides a structured process with three stages:

  1. Examination-in-chief

  2. Cross-examination

  3. Re-examination

Meaning and Definition

Examination-in-Chief is the initial questioning of a witness by the party who called them, designed to elicit the witness’s direct evidence on the matters in issue.

Cross-Examination is the questioning of a witness by the party who did not call them, designed to test and challenge the accuracy, truthfulness, and completeness of the witness’s evidence.

Re-Examination is the questioning of a witness after cross-examination by the party who originally called them, designed to explain or clarify matters raised in cross-examination.

Key Legal Principles

No Leading Questions in Examination-in-Chief. A leading question is one that suggests the desired answer to the witness. The rule against leading questions in examination-in-chief prevents a party from coaching their own witness through their testimony.

Leading Questions Are Permitted in Cross-Examination. In cross-examination, the purpose is to challenge the witness, and leading questions are the primary tool. The advocate may suggest that the witness is wrong, lying, or mistaken — and may put propositions directly to them.

A Witness May Be Cross-Examined on Credit. A witness’s credibility may be attacked in cross-examination through prior inconsistent statements, evidence of bias, interest, or prior convictions.

Re-Examination Is Limited to Matters Arising in Cross-Examination. The party who called the witness cannot use re-examination to add new evidence — it may only address matters raised or damaged in cross-examination.

A Party May Not Impeach Their Own Witness. As a general rule, the party who called a witness cannot attack that witness’s credibility. However, where the witness gives evidence materially inconsistent with a previous statement, the court may permit the party to cross-examine their own witness — who then becomes a “hostile witness.”

Sources of Law

Sections 139–165, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2022 — the comprehensive set of provisions governing examination of witnesses.

Section 139 — order of examination: examination-in-chief, cross-examination, re-examination.

Section 140 — cross-examination of person called to produce a document.

Section 141 — witnesses to character.

Section 142 — meaning of leading questions.

Section 143 — when leading questions must not be asked (examination-in-chief and re-examination).

Section 144 — when leading questions may be asked (cross-examination).

Section 145 — evidence as to matters in writing.

Section 146 — cross-examination on previous statements in writing.

Section 147 — questions lawful in cross-examination.

Section 148 — when a witness may be compelled to answer.

Section 149 — court to decide questions asked.

Section 150 — cross-examination as to previous statements.

Section 151 — procedure for cross-examining the accused.

Section 152 — questions not to be asked without reasonable grounds.

Section 153 — indecent and scandalous questions.

Section 154 — questions intended to insult or annoy.

Section 155 — exclusion of evidence to contradict answers to questions affecting credit.

Section 156 — question by party to own witness.

Section 157 — impeaching credit of witness.

Section 158 — questions tending to corroborate evidence of relevant fact.

Section 159 — former statements of witness may be proved to corroborate later testimony.

Section 160 — refreshing memory.

Section 161 — when a witness can use a document to refresh memory.

Section 162 — right to inspect document used to refresh memory.

Section 163 — hostile witnesses.

Section 164 — evidence of prior statements.

Section 165 — power of court to ask questions.

Essential Elements

Examination-in-Chief

Examination-in-chief is the first stage of examination. Its purpose is to allow the witness to tell their story in their own words, drawing out the evidence that supports the case of the party who called them.

The Rule Against Leading Questions — Section 143. A leading question is one that either suggests the answer (“Did you see the accused strike the deceased?”) or assumes the existence of a disputed fact (“When the accused was beating the deceased, were you present?”). Section 143 provides that leading questions must not be asked in examination-in-chief without the court’s permission.

Why? Because a witness should give their own account in their own words. If their counsel frames every question so as to prompt the “correct” answer, the evidence ceases to be the witness’s independent recollection — it becomes the counsel’s version, with the witness simply nodding along.

Exceptions. Leading questions are permitted in examination-in-chief on matters that are introductory (name, address, occupation), on facts that are not disputed between the parties, and on matters as to which the court gives special permission.

Refreshing Memory — Sections 160–162. A witness may, while under examination, refer to a document they made at the time of the events or so shortly afterwards that the events were still fresh in their memory, in order to refresh their recollection. The document itself does not become evidence — only the oral testimony of the witness is evidence. But the opposing party has the right to inspect the document and to cross-examine on it.

Example. A police officer who made a detailed notebook entry immediately after arriving at a crime scene may refer to their notebook while giving evidence, to ensure accuracy of details such as times, descriptions, and sequence of events.

Cross-Examination

Cross-examination is the most powerful tool in a litigator’s arsenal. Its purpose is not merely to tell the court what the advocate thinks — it is to test the witness’s evidence by putting challenging propositions to them.

Test yourself

Examination of Witnesses Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Law of Evidence Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now