In short
Natural law, rejected in the 18th and 19th centuries in favour of utilitarianism and legal positivism, revived in the 20th century. The main reasons were: the failure of positivism to answer laws that were valid but monstrous, above all in Nazi Germany; the Nuremberg trials and the human rights movement after 1945; social and economic crises such as the rise of monopoly capitalism and the World Wars; dissatisfaction with the command theory; and the work of writers such as Rudolf Stammler, Gustav Radbruch, Lon Fuller and John Finnis. The revived natural law is less religious and more procedural or rights-based than the classical theory.
On this page 8 sections
- Why had natural law been rejected?
- What were the reasons for the revival of natural law?
- How is the revived natural law different from the classical theory?
- How does the revival show in Tanzania?
- What are the criticisms of the revival?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on the revival of natural law?
- Practice question: Account for the revival of natural law in the 20th century.
- Key takeaways
Why had natural law been rejected?
From the late 18th century, natural law was attacked on several fronts. Hume showed that moral conclusions cannot be derived from facts alone. Bentham and Austin argued that law is simply the command of a sovereign, and that its moral merit is a separate question. The 19th century preferred science and codification to metaphysics, so legal positivism and utilitarianism dominated. See Classical Natural Law: From the Greeks to Aquinas and Bentham and Austin: The Command Theory of Law.
What were the reasons for the revival of natural law?
1. Laws that were valid but evil
The Nazi regime came to power and governed through laws passed in proper form, including the Nuremberg race laws of 1935. Positivism, which says a law is valid if made by the recognised authority, seemed to have no answer to such laws. After 1945 German courts had to decide whether acts done under Nazi laws were lawful. In the “grudge informer” cases, people who had reported others to the authorities under Nazi statutes were later prosecuted. These cases were central to the debate between Hart and Fuller, discussed in Law and Morality: The Hart–Fuller and Hart–Devlin Debates.
2. The Nuremberg trials and international human rights
At Nuremberg (1945 to 1946), Nazi leaders were tried for crimes against humanity and could not rely on the defence that they were obeying the law of their state. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) then declared rights that belong to every person by virtue of human dignity, followed by the International Covenants of 1966 and regional instruments such as the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (1981). These rest on the natural law idea that some rights exist independently of any state’s law.
3. Social and economic crises
The rise of monopoly capitalism in the late 19th and early 20th centuries concentrated wealth, drove the scramble for colonies and markets, and produced inequality and conflict, including two World Wars and the Great Depression. Positivist law, neutral about content, appeared to protect powerful interests. Writers and movements looked for standards of justice above the law of the state, which encouraged the return to natural law and to ideas of social justice.
4. Dissatisfaction with the command theory and with positivism
The command theory could not explain constitutional limits on sovereign power, international law, customary law or the duty-imposing rules that bind officials themselves. Positivism also struggled with hard cases where the rules run out and judges must appeal to principles. This dissatisfaction made room for theories that link law and morality.
5. The influence of new writers
- Rudolf Stammler (1856 to 1938), a neo-Kantian, proposed a “natural law with a changing content”: the ideal of justice is constant, but the content of just law changes with time and place.
- Gustav Radbruch (1878 to 1949), once a positivist, argued after the war that where a statute’s conflict with justice reaches an intolerable degree, the statute must yield to justice as “false law”. This is known as the Radbruch formula, and German courts used it after 1945 and again after reunification in cases about East German border guards.
- Lon Fuller argued that law has an “inner morality” of eight procedural principles.
- John Finnis restated Aquinas in secular terms, with basic goods and requirements of practical reasonableness.
- Ronald Dworkin argued that law includes moral principles, not just rules.
Fuller and Finnis are covered in Modern Natural Law: Fuller and Finnis and Dworkin in Dworkin and Law as Integrity.
How is the revived natural law different from the classical theory?
| Classical natural law | Revived natural law |
|---|---|
| Rooted in God and an unchanging cosmic order | Largely secular, based on reason, human dignity and rights |
| Fixed, universal content | Variable content (Stammler) or minimum content |
| Concerned with the substance of law | Also concerned with procedure and legality (Fuller) |
| Natural duties | Human rights enforceable through constitutions and international law |
Because it was influenced by Kant’s ethics, especially the idea that every person must be treated as an end and never merely as a means, the revived theory is sometimes called neo-Kantian.
How does the revival show in Tanzania?
- The Bill of Rights was entrenched in the Constitution by the Fifth Constitutional Amendment of 1984 and became enforceable in 1988. Its language of inherent dignity and equality reflects the post-war human rights tradition.
- In Director of Public Prosecutions v Daudi Pete [1991] TZCA 1, the Court of Appeal held that laws limiting basic rights must be lawful and not arbitrary, and must go no further than reasonably necessary.
- In Ephrahim v Pastory (2001) AHRLR 236 (TzHC 1990), the High Court held that a Haya customary rule preventing women from selling clan land discriminated on grounds of sex, relying on the Bill of Rights and on international instruments such as CEDAW and the African Charter.
- In Attorney General v Rebeca Z. Gyumi, Civil Appeal No. 204 of 2017, [2019] TZCA 348, the Court of Appeal upheld the High Court’s decision that the Law of Marriage Act provisions allowing girls to marry younger than boys were discriminatory.
What are the criticisms of the revival?
- Positivists such as Hart reply that it is clearer to say a Nazi law was law but too evil to obey, rather than that it was not law.
- Disagreement about what justice requires makes natural law standards uncertain.
- Judges who apply higher law may override democratic choices, as the debate after Mbushuu on the death penalty shows.
Exam focus: what do examiners test on the revival of natural law?
- Why natural law was rejected, then why it revived: Nazi laws, Nuremberg, human rights, crises of capitalism and war, the limits of positivism, and new writers.
- Stammler’s natural law with a changing content, and the Radbruch formula.
- Differences between classical and revived natural law.
- Tanzanian illustrations: the Bill of Rights, Daudi Pete, Ephrahim v Pastory and Rebeca Gyumi.
Practice question: Account for the revival of natural law in the 20th century.
- Introduction: define natural law and explain its rejection in the 18th and 19th centuries.
- Reasons: Nazi laws and the grudge informer cases; Nuremberg and the UDHR; monopoly capitalism, war and depression; the weaknesses of the command theory; Stammler, Radbruch, Fuller and Finnis.
- Nature of the revival: secular, variable in content, rights-based and procedural.
- Tanzania: the Bill of Rights and decisions such as Daudi Pete and Rebeca Gyumi.
- Conclusion: evaluate whether the revival answers the positivist objections.
Key takeaways
- Natural law revived because positivism could not deal with lawful tyranny, especially Nazi law.
- Nuremberg and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights made rights based on human dignity part of international law.
- Economic crises, war and dissatisfaction with the command theory pushed lawyers to look for standards above the state.
- Stammler, Radbruch, Fuller, Finnis and Dworkin gave the revived theory its modern forms.
- In Tanzania, the Bill of Rights and cases such as Daudi Pete, Ephrahim v Pastory and Rebeca Gyumi show the revival in practice.
Key Statutes and Cases on The Revival of Natural Law in the 20th Century
Statutes
- Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Bill of Rights (Arts. 12 to 32), entrenched by the Fifth Constitutional Amendment, 1984
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948Rights based on human dignity
- African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, 1981Regional human rights instrument
Cases
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Daudi Pete, [1991] TZCA 1Limits on basic rights must be lawful, necessary and not arbitrary
- Ephrahim v Pastory (2001) AHRLR 236 (TzHC 1990)Customary rule barring women from selling clan land held discriminatory
- Attorney General v Rebeca Z. Gyumi, [2019] TZCA 348Marriage age provisions held discriminatory
Test yourself
The Revival of Natural Law in the 20th Century Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
