Jurisprudence notes · Topic 2 of 16

Classical Natural Law: From the Greeks to Aquinas

Classical natural law theory: Antigone, Aristotle, the Stoics and Cicero, Roman jus naturale and jus gentium, Aquinas's four kinds of law, natural rights in Grotius, Hobbes and Locke, and why natural law declined.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 11 min read

In short

Natural law theory holds that there are moral principles, discoverable by human reason, against which human-made (positive) law can be measured, so that a seriously unjust law may lack the full character of law. It began with the Greeks, who contrasted what is just by nature with what is just by convention; was systematised by the Stoics and Cicero as a universal law of right reason; was absorbed into Roman law as jus naturale; and reached its classical form in St Thomas Aquinas, who placed human law beneath eternal, natural and divine law. Later writers such as Grotius and Locke turned natural law into a theory of natural rights.

On this page 10 sections
  1. What is natural law?
  2. What did the Greek philosophers contribute?
  3. How did the Stoics and the Romans develop natural law?
  4. What did Aquinas teach about law?
  5. How did natural law become a theory of natural rights?
  6. Why did natural law decline in the 18th and 19th centuries?
  7. Where can natural law reasoning be seen in Tanzanian courts?
  8. Exam focus: what do examiners test on classical natural law?
  9. Practice question: "An unjust law is no law at all." Discuss with reference to Aquinas.
  10. Key takeaways

What is natural law?

Natural law is a body of moral principles said to arise from the nature of human beings or of the universe, rather than from the decision of any legislator. Natural law theorists make two connected claims: that such principles exist and can be known by reason, and that the validity or authority of human law depends, at least in part, on its conformity to them. The famous slogan lex iniusta non est lex (an unjust law is not law) is usually attributed to Augustine and Aquinas, though modern writers such as Finnis read it as meaning that an unjust law is law in a defective sense.

What did the Greek philosophers contribute?

  • The Sophists and Sophocles: in Sophocles’ play Antigone, Antigone buries her brother against King Creon’s decree, appealing to the unwritten and unfailing laws of the gods. The play dramatises the conflict between human command and a higher law.
  • Socrates and Plato: Socrates accepted his death sentence rather than escape, out of respect for the laws of Athens, but taught that justice is objective. Plato’s ideal state was ruled by philosopher-kings who knew the Form of the Good.
  • Aristotle: distinguished natural justice, which has the same force everywhere, from legal or conventional justice, which depends on what a community has laid down. He saw humans as political animals who flourish in a community governed by law, and developed the ideas of distributive and corrective justice, discussed in Theories of Justice: Aristotle, Rawls and Nozick.

How did the Stoics and the Romans develop natural law?

The Stoics taught that the universe is governed by reason (logos) and that every person shares in that reason, so there is a single law for all humanity. Cicero, in De Re Publica, described true law as right reason in agreement with nature, of universal application, unchanging and everlasting, the same in Rome and Athens. Roman jurists distinguished:

  • jus civile: the law of Roman citizens;
  • jus gentium: the law common to all peoples, applied to foreigners; and
  • jus naturale: the law that nature teaches all creatures, which Ulpian and Justinian’s Institutes treated as an ideal standard.

The jus gentium gave practical content to natural law, and later influenced international law.

What did Aquinas teach about law?

St Thomas Aquinas (1225 to 1274), in the Summa Theologica, defined law as an ordinance of reason for the common good, made by whoever has care of the community, and promulgated. He identified four kinds of law:

  1. Eternal law: God’s rational plan for the whole universe.
  2. Natural law: the share of eternal law that rational creatures grasp through reason. Its first precept is that good is to be done and pursued and evil avoided, and it reflects natural inclinations such as preserving life, family life, living in society and knowing the truth.
  3. Divine law: law revealed in scripture, guiding humans to their supernatural end.
  4. Human law: rules made by human authorities, derived from natural law either by deduction (for example, do not kill) or by determination of details (for example, the specific penalty for killing, or which side of the road to drive on).

Aquinas held that a human law that conflicts with natural law is “not a law but a corruption of law”. Yet he did not say that every unjust law may be disobeyed: a law that is unjust only because it is burdensome may still be obeyed to avoid scandal or disturbance, while a law that commands something against divine law must never be obeyed.

How did natural law become a theory of natural rights?

  • Hugo Grotius (1583 to 1645) argued that natural law would have validity even if, as he put it, God did not exist, which secularised the theory, and he used it to found international law in On the Law of War and Peace (1625).
  • Thomas Hobbes saw life in the state of nature as “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short” and argued that people give up their natural liberty to an absolute sovereign for security.
  • John Locke held that people have natural rights to life, liberty and property, form government by consent to protect them, and may resist a government that violates them.
  • Rousseau grounded legitimate law in the general will of the people.

These ideas influenced the American Declaration of Independence (1776) and the French Declaration of the Rights of Man (1789), and through them modern bills of rights, including Part III of Chapter One of the Constitution of Tanzania.

Why did natural law decline in the 18th and 19th centuries?

Hume argued that one cannot derive an “ought” from an “is”, which challenged any attempt to draw moral rules from facts about human nature. Bentham called natural rights “nonsense upon stilts”. The rise of science, codification and legal positivism, examined in Bentham and Austin: The Command Theory of Law, pushed natural law to the margins until its revival in the 20th century: see The Revival of Natural Law in the 20th Century.

Where can natural law reasoning be seen in Tanzanian courts?

In Republic v Mbushuu [1994] T.L.R. 146, Mwalusanya, J. held the death penalty unconstitutional as cruel, inhuman and degrading, an argument from human dignity that echoes natural law. The Court of Appeal in Mbushuu alias Dominic Mnyaroje and Another v Republic [1995] T.L.R. 97 agreed that the penalty is inherently inhuman, cruel and degrading, but held it saved by Article 30(2), so the text of the Constitution prevailed. Students can use the case to show both the appeal and the limits of natural law arguments in a written constitution.

Exam focus: what do examiners test on classical natural law?

  • The meaning of natural law and the slogan lex iniusta non est lex.
  • Contributions of Aristotle, the Stoics, Cicero and Roman law.
  • Aquinas’s four kinds of law and his view of unjust laws.
  • The shift from natural law to natural rights (Grotius, Hobbes, Locke) and its effect on bills of rights.
  • Criticisms: Hume’s is-ought gap and Bentham’s attack.

Practice question: “An unjust law is no law at all.” Discuss with reference to Aquinas.

  1. Explain the origin of the maxim and Aquinas’s definition of law.
  2. Set out the four kinds of law and how human law derives from natural law.
  3. Show that Aquinas distinguished laws unjust because burdensome from laws contrary to divine law, so the maxim is less absolute than it sounds.
  4. Give the positivist reply: Austin and Hart say an unjust law is still law, though it may not deserve obedience.
  5. Apply to Tanzania: the two Mbushuu judgments.

Key takeaways

  • Natural law holds that moral principles knowable by reason are a standard for human law.
  • Aristotle distinguished natural from conventional justice; the Stoics and Cicero made natural law universal; Roman law recognised jus naturale and jus gentium.
  • Aquinas identified eternal, natural, divine and human law, and treated unjust human law as a corruption of law.
  • Grotius, Hobbes and Locke turned natural law into natural rights, influencing modern bills of rights.
  • Natural law declined under attack from Hume, Bentham and positivism, before reviving in the 20th century.

Key Statutes and Cases on Classical Natural Law: From the Greeks to Aquinas

Statutes

  • Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Part III of Chapter One, Basic Rights and Duties (Arts. 12 to 32)

Cases

  • Republic v Mbushuu [1994] TLR 146 (HC)Death penalty held unconstitutional on grounds of human dignity
  • Mbushuu alias Dominic Mnyaroje and Another v Republic [1995] TLR 97 (CAT)Death penalty inherently cruel but saved by Art. 30(2)

Test yourself

Classical Natural Law: From the Greeks to Aquinas Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Jurisprudence Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfClassical Natural Law: From the Greeks to AquinasTake the quiz