Before a court will hear a civil suit on its merits, three threshold questions must be satisfied. Does the plaintiff have a recognised legal claim on the facts pleaded? This is the question of cause of action. Is this particular plaintiff the right person to bring that claim? This is the question of locus standi. Was the suit brought within the time the law allows? This is the question of limitation. A defendant can defeat even a sympathetic claim by upholding any one of these three points in a preliminary objection, often before evidence is heard.
In Tanzanian practice these issues come up constantly. A plaint that fails to plead the essential facts of a recognised cause of action can be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023. A plaintiff with no real stake in the matter — a busybody, a stranger, a relative who is not entitled to sue — can be dismissed for lack of standing. And a plaintiff who has slept on his rights past the period in the Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89 R.E. 2023, will see the suit dismissed by the court itself, even if the limitation point is not raised by the defendant.
Meaning / Definition
A cause of action is the bundle of essential facts which, if proved, entitles the plaintiff to a remedy from the court. It is everything the plaintiff must establish — every material fact, every essential element of the legal right asserted, every fact showing the wrong done. If one essential fact is missing on the face of the plaint, the plaint is said to “disclose no cause of action” and can be rejected.
A useful working definition was offered in the Tanzanian and East African textbook tradition: the cause of action is the totality of facts which the plaintiff must prove in order to be entitled to the relief he seeks. It is not the evidence by which he proves them — it is the operative facts themselves. The distinction between material facts and evidence is sharper than students sometimes realise, and is a source of pleading errors that destroy otherwise good cases. To plead a contract claim, for instance, the plaintiff must plead the offer and acceptance, the consideration, the performance, the breach, and the damage. He need not, at the pleading stage, set out who said what at the meeting where the deal was struck — that is evidence.
Locus standi is a Latin phrase meaning “a place to stand.” It is the legal capacity, or sufficient personal interest, that a person must have to be entitled to bring a particular suit. A person who has suffered no infringement of a recognised right has no standing to sue, even if some legal wrong has been committed against someone else. The doctrine prevents busybodies and strangers from clogging the courts with claims that do not belong to them and ensures that suits are brought by the persons whose rights are at stake.
Limitation of actions is the rule that a suit must be brought within a fixed period of time, after which the legal right to sue is lost (or, more precisely, the remedy is barred — the right may continue in the abstract but cannot be enforced). The law fixes deadlines so that disputes are resolved while evidence is fresh, so that potential defendants are not left under threat of litigation for ever, and so that finality is brought to legal relations. In Tanzanian practice the limitation periods are mostly statutory, found in the First Schedule to the Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89 R.E. 2023.
ause of Action
The essential elements of a cause of action
The plaintiff’s plaint must, on its face, allege the operative facts that make up the cause of action. These facts will vary depending on the nature of the claim, but the structural elements that every cause of action must contain can be expressed as follows. First, the existence of a legal right in the plaintiff. Second, the infringement or violation of that right by the defendant. Third, the consequences of that infringement — the loss, damage, or other adverse effect that grounds the prayer for relief.
To take a concrete example. In a suit for breach of contract under the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345 R.E. 2023, the plaintiff must plead: (a) the contract — its parties, its date, its essential terms; (b) the plaintiff’s performance or readiness to perform on his side; (c) the defendant’s breach of the contract; and (d) the loss or damage suffered as a consequence of the breach. If any one of these elements is missing from the pleading, the plaint discloses no cause of action.
In a suit for negligence in tort, the plaintiff must plead: (a) a duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiff; (b) breach of that duty; (c) damage to the plaintiff resulting from the breach; and (d) the causal link between the breach and the damage. Again, a plaint that omits any of these elements is liable to rejection.
The point is general. To plead a cause of action competently, the advocate must first identify the legal claim being asserted, then list its essential elements, then verify that each is alleged on the face of the plaint.
Material facts, not evidence
The CPC distinguishes sharply between material facts and evidence. Order VI Rule 1 of the CPC requires pleadings to state the material facts on which the party relies; Order VII Rule 1 requires the plaint to contain the facts constituting the cause of action and when it arose. The rule against pleading evidence — drawn from Order VI Rule 1 read with the general principle that pleadings should be concise — means that the plaint should not set out the witnesses, the delivery notes, the bank statements, or the verbatim conversations. Those are matters of proof, brought out at trial. The plaint sets out the operative facts to be proved.
The leading Tanzanian decision on the consequences of failing to plead the cause of action properly is Ali Mukibi v Amblal Bavsar [1965] EA 557 (a Ugandan authority adopted in Tanzania). The plaintiff sued the defendant for wrongful removal of goods over which the plaintiff claimed ownership. The defendant raised a preliminary objection on a point of law that the plaint disclosed no cause of action. The court held that, to maintain an action for trespass to goods, the plaintiff must have been in possession of the goods at the time of the trespass; trespass to goods, like trespass to land, is an injury to possession, not to ownership. The plaintiff in Ali Mukibi had not been in possession of the goods at the time the defendant removed them; possession lay with the tenant. Accordingly, neither trespass nor detinue nor trover could lie at the suit of the plaintiff. The plaint was rejected for failure to disclose a cause of action.
The case is examinable for two propositions. First, the absence of a single essential element — possession at the time of the trespass — defeats the entire cause of action. Second, an alternative plea (for instance, injury to the reversion) may be available where the facts support it; one element does not necessarily exclude another, but each must be pleaded properly.
Rejection under Order VII Rule 11 and the proviso of 1971
Where a plaint, on its face, discloses no cause of action, Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC empowers the court to reject the plaint. The rule lists four grounds for rejection: that the plaint does not disclose a cause of action; that the relief claimed is undervalued and the plaintiff, on being required, has refused to correct the valuation; that the plaint is insufficiently stamped with court fees and the plaintiff has refused to make up the deficiency; and that the suit appears, from the statement in the plaint, to be barred by any law — the obvious examples being limitation, res judicata, and res sub judice.
The Tanzanian flexible approach to procedure produced an important amendment in 1971. By Government Notice No. 228 of 1971, the Chief Justice exercised his rule-making power under section 91 of the CPC to add a proviso to Order VII Rule 11. The proviso reads, in working effect, that where the plaint does not disclose a cause of action or appears from its statement to be barred by any law, and the court is of the opinion that by allowing an amendment the plaint will disclose a cause of action or the suit will cease to appear to be barred, the court may allow the plaintiff to amend the plaint instead of rejecting it, on such conditions as to costs or otherwise as the court may deem fit.
The proviso embodies the principle that procedure is the servant of justice. Rather than throwing out a defective plaint, the court can, in proper cases, allow amendment. The leading Tanzanian authority on the application of the proviso is Hirji v Sarudin Alibai [1974] EA 13. Onyiuke J held that the court can exercise its discretion under the proviso to Order VII Rule 11 to allow amendment of a plaint so as to disclose a cause of action. The case stands for the proposition that a defective plaint is not always fatal; the court will, on appropriate facts, give the plaintiff a chance to put it right.
But there are limits. The court will not allow an amendment that would amount to introducing a new and different cause of action, or substituting one cause of action for another. That principle, drawn from Eastern Bakery v Castelins [1958] EA 461 and Shivji v Pallegrini (1972) HCD 76, applies as much to amendments invited by Order VII Rule 11 as to amendments under Order VI Rule 17. The proviso saves a plaint that is salvageable; it does not save a plaint that, on amendment, would become a new suit.
Key Statutes and Cases on Cause of Action, Locus Standi and Limitation of Actions
Statutes
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023Order VII r. 11 rejection of plaint; s. 11 res judicata; s. 91 rule-making power
- Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89 R.E. 2023s. 3 time-barred suits dismissed; periods in the Schedule
Cases
- Lujuna Shubi Ballonzi, Senior v Registered Trustees of Chama cha Mapinduzi [1996] TLR 203 (HC)Locus standi: a plaintiff must show a right or interest of his own that has been interfered with
Test yourself
Cause of Action, Locus Standi and Limitation of Actions Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
