What “Appearance” Means
Appearance is a party’s formal presentation before the court — in person, by advocate, or by recognised agent — on the date stated in the summons. The classical Tanzanian statement is in East African Posts and Telecommunications Corporation v M/s Terrazo Paviors [1973] LRT 58: “appearance under the Code means attendance in person or by an advocate in court on the date stated in the summons, which is also the date of hearing. Once the defendant is present, either in person or by an advocate when the case is called up, that is sufficient appearance.“
What “sufficient appearance” looks like has been explored in three useful East African cases:
Shah Kachra Merag v Chandi & Co. Ltd [1957] EA 466 — the appellant appeared himself but his advocate was absent. The appellant elected not to say anything and prayed for an adjournment. The court refused the adjournment and dismissed the suit. The court held that the mere presence of a party in court is sufficient to constitute appearance — but you have to do more than be physically there if you want to defend the case.
Din Mohamed v Lalui Visram & Co. (1937) EACA 1 — an advocate duly instructed appears but withdraws upon failing to obtain an adjournment. He is deemed to have appeared. So a withdrawal after appearance is still an appearance for procedural purposes.
Where a recognised agent appears for his principal under Order III Rule 1, and takes steps in furtherance of the proceedings, that is sufficient appearance.
The point of these distinctions is to know whether the consequences of non-appearance apply or not. If somebody has appeared, even briefly, before withdrawing, the proceedings have not strictly been ex parte.
Consequences of Non-Appearance — the Order IX Scheme
The CPC handles non-appearance by asking: who has failed to appear, and was the absent party properly served? The answers determine the consequence.
Where neither party appears — Order IX Rule 3
If the date of hearing arrives and neither the plaintiff nor the defendant turns up, the court dismisses the suit under Order IX Rule 3. The plaintiff is given three options:
He can file a fresh suit within the limitation period.
He can apply to set aside the order of dismissal on showing sufficient cause for the non-appearance.
He can refer the matter to the High Court for review in appropriate cases.
A dismissal under Rule 3 is procedural; it is not a decision on the merits and is not res judicata.
Where only the plaintiff appears — Order IX Rules 6 and 13
If the plaintiff turns up on the date of hearing and the defendant does not, the court’s response depends on whether the defendant was duly served and what type of summons was issued.
If the suit is in the High Court, the summons was duly served, and the defendant doesn’t appear, the court can order ex parte proof. The plaintiff is allowed to lead his evidence in the defendant’s absence.
If the suit is in a subordinate court, the summons was to file a WSD, the summons was duly served, and the defendant didn’t file or appear, the court may order ex parte proof.
If the suit is in a subordinate court, the summons was to appear, the summons was duly served, and the defendant didn’t appear, the court may enter judgment for the plaintiff directly.
If the summons was not duly served — or there is no proof that it was — the court cannot proceed ex parte. It must adjourn to a future date and issue notice to the defendant. The point is reinforced by Ester David Mmari v Emmanuel Makaidi [1967] HCD 178 and Kanji Naran v Velji Ramji (21 EACA 20): proper service must be proved before the court can act on the defendant’s non-appearance.
Where only the defendant appears — Order IX Rule 8
If the defendant turns up on the date of hearing and the plaintiff does not, the court dismisses the suit under Order IX Rule 8, unless the defendant admits the claim (in whole or in part), in which event the court enters judgment to the extent of the admission.
A dismissal under Rule 8 is more serious than a dismissal under Rule 3. It operates as res judicata — the plaintiff is precluded from bringing a fresh suit on the same cause of action. His only remedy is to apply to set aside the dismissal under Order IX Rule 9, on showing sufficient cause for his non-appearance, after giving notice to the defendant. The Tanzanian case Mussa v Kaporo [1957] EA 189 confirms that a dismissal in default of the plaintiff’s appearance is deemed a decision on the merits for the purpose of res judicata.
There’s a nuance worth knowing. If the plaintiff has already led part of his evidence and then fails to appear on subsequent dates, the court does not dismiss; it hears the defendant and decides the case on the available evidence — see Gamaba v Lwavu [1970] HCD 257.
Failure to pay court fees or postal charges — Order IX Rule 2
If the plaintiff fails to pay court fees or postal charges so that the defendant cannot be served, the court may dismiss the suit. The plaintiff may bring a fresh suit, provided he is within the limitation period. But if the defendant appears on his own initiative, no dismissal can be ordered — the court has the defendant before it, and the purpose of service has effectively been achieved.
Key Statutes and Cases on Appearance and Non-Appearance of Parties
Statutes
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023Order IX appearance and non-appearance
Cases
- Mbeya-Rukwa Auto Parts and Transport Ltd v Jestina George Mwakyoma [2003] TLR 251 (CAT, Civil Appeal No. 45 of 2001)A decision reached without hearing a party is a nullity (Art. 13(6)(a) of the Constitution)
Test yourself
Appearance and Consequences of Non-Appearance Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
