Now we move to the defendant’s side. The plaintiff has filed her plaint, the court has issued summons, and you’ve received it on behalf of your client. You have, depending on the form of the summons, a fixed period (typically 21 days, but check the summons) to file a Written Statement of Defence — the WSD. This is the defendant’s first formal pleading, his answer to the plaint.
Three things matter in this topic and I’ll work through each.
First, the rules for drafting a competent WSD — especially the rule on specific denials and the danger of evasive or general denials, which can effectively concede the case before you’ve even started.
Second, the doctrine of set-off: how a defendant who is himself owed money by the plaintiff can use that debt as a defence to reduce or extinguish the plaintiff’s claim.
Third, the counter-claim: how a defendant can convert his own grievance against the plaintiff into a cross-suit within the same proceedings, potentially winning a net judgment against the very plaintiff who sued him.
The whole framework is in Order VIII of the CPC, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023. Get this topic right and you can act competently for a defendant.
When and How the WSD Is Filed
The WSD must be filed within the time fixed by the summons. In subordinate courts the usual period is 21 days from receipt of the summons. If the defendant fails to file within that time, he has no right to file it later — at least not as of right. In practice, the defendant may apply to the court for leave to file the WSD out of time, by chamber summons supported by affidavit explaining why the delay is excusable. The court has discretion. But never rely on this; file in time if you possibly can.
If there is a joinder of defendants, the WSD may be filed by one defendant individually, or by more than one defendant jointly. Joint WSDs are common where the defendants share a defence; separate WSDs are necessary where they have inconsistent positions. The joint WSD should make clear which defendant is pleading what.
Anatomy of a WSD
A well-drafted WSD follows the same structural rules as a plaint:
A title identifying the court, the case number, and the parties. The name of the document — WRITTEN STATEMENT OF DEFENCE — capitalised and centred. First paragraphs describing the defendant (and, by reference, the plaintiff), with any updated address for service. The substantive paragraphs dealing with each allegation in the plaint — admitting, denying, or putting the plaintiff to proof. Any positive defence — for example, that the contract was illegal, that there was a release, that the suit is time-barred. Any set-off or counter-claim (we’ll come to these separately). Signature, date, verification, and drawer’s details at the foot.
The Rule on Specific Denials
This is the most important rule in Order VIII. Each and every allegation in the plaint must be specifically denied or specifically admitted. A general or evasive denial — “the defendant denies each and every allegation in the plaint” — is dangerous because, under Order VIII Rule 5 (read with the general principles), any allegation of fact in the plaint that is not specifically denied (except against a person under disability) is deemed to be admitted.
The technique is to take each numbered paragraph of the plaint and respond to it in turn, in a numbered paragraph of the WSD. Something like this:
Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the plaint are admitted (those usually contain the descriptions of the parties).
Paragraph 3 of the plaint is denied. Even if there was a contract, which is denied, there was a failure of consideration.
Paragraph 4 of the plaint is denied. Even if there was a contract and consideration, which is denied, the defendant asserts that the contractual amount was paid in full on 15 March 2024.
Save as hereinabove expressly admitted, the defendant denies each and every fact contained in the plaint as if the same were set forth seriatim and specifically traversed.
The last paragraph — the omnibus traverse — is the safety-net clause. It works only as a final sweep after you’ve gone through the allegations specifically; it does not work as a substitute for specific denials.
What “evasive denial” means
A denial is evasive if it doesn’t squarely address the allegation. If the plaintiff alleges “the defendant received TZS 5,000,000 on 10 March 2024,” a denial of “the defendant did not receive TZS 5,000,000” is potentially evasive (because the plaintiff may have meant a slightly different sum, and the defendant has technically denied something different from what was alleged). The proper denial is “paragraph 4 of the plaint is denied. The defendant did not receive TZS 5,000,000 or any sum from the plaintiff on 10 March 2024 or at all.”
The Warner v Sampson position
The English Court of Appeal in Warner v Sampson [1959] All ER 120 at 123, per Denning LJ, addressed the general denial — describing how it has been used in nearly every defence:
Whenever the pleader knows there is a serious contest, he takes no instructions on a particular allegation, but he covers it by a general denial of this kind so that he can, if need be, put the plaintiff to proof of it at trial. Sometimes the pleader denies; sometimes he does not admit each and every allegation; but whatever phrase is used it all comes back to the same thing. The allegation has to be regarded as if it were specifically set out and traversed seriatim. In other words, it is traversed — no more, no less. The effect of the traverse has been known to generations of pleaders. It casts upon the plaintiff the burden of proving the allegations denied.
The position is therefore more nuanced than “general denials are always bad.” A general denial after specific denials operates as a sweep; a general denial instead of specific denials concedes the points not specifically denied. The safe practice — and the practice the law expects — is specific denials first, omnibus traverse at the end.
The Technique of Confession and Avoidance
This is one of the most useful pleading techniques you’ll learn. Confession and avoidance means the defendant admits the existence of certain facts but avoids their legal consequences by adding further facts that defeat the claim.
For example: a plaintiff alleges that the defendant agreed to deliver vegetables and failed to do so. The defendant doesn’t deny the contract; he says: “The defendant admits the existence of the contract. However, the vegetables that the plaintiff supplied were rotten and unfit for human consumption. The defendant therefore was not bound to accept them.”
Or: “The defendant admits receiving TZS 10,000,000 from the plaintiff on the date alleged. However, that money was received as a gift, not as a loan.”
The technique lets you concede what’s harmless and even helpful (the existence of the dealing) while attacking what’s harmful (the legal consequence the plaintiff wants to draw).
Defences Available in a WSD
Beyond simply denying the plaintiff’s allegations, the defendant can plead positive defences. Examiners sometimes ask you to list these, so know the main ones. They include:
Accord and satisfaction (in contract); acquiescence; failure of condition precedent; custom and usage; lack of capacity; estoppel; fraud; illegality; lack of jurisdiction; limitation; laches (equitable limitation); misjoinder of parties or causes of action; non-joinder; mistake; insufficient notice (especially in suits against the Government); payment; the penalty rule (penalty clauses as opposed to genuine pre-estimates of damages); release; rescission; remoteness of damages; res judicata; res sub judice; set-off; tender; undue influence; duress; lack of special damages; waiver; and want of cause of action.
Key Statutes and Cases on Written Statement of Defence, Set-Off, and Counter-Claim
Statutes
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023Order VIII written statement of defence, set-off and counterclaim; s. 105 inherent powers
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2023s. 2(2) equity (equitable set-off)
Test yourself
Written Statement of Defence, Set-Off, and Counter-Claim Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
