In modern legal practice, documents are everywhere:
-
Contracts
-
Bank records
-
Emails
-
Government records
Because of this, courts rely heavily on documentary evidence. However, documents raise important questions:
-
Is the document genuine?
-
Is it the original?
-
Can a copy be used?
-
Can oral evidence change what is written?
The law answers these through a detailed framework under the Evidence Act
Meaning and Definition
Legal Definition
Section 3 of the Evidence Act defines “document” as any matter expressed or described upon any substance by means of letters, figures, or marks. Following the 2007 amendments, this definition has been extended to include electronic records — data stored or processed by electronic means.
Primary evidence is defined in Section 60 as the document itself produced for inspection by the court — the original.
Secondary evidence is defined in Section 63 as certified copies, copies made from the original by a mechanical process, counterparts of documents, and oral accounts of the contents of a document.
Simple Explanation
Documentary evidence is any written or recorded material placed before the court to prove facts. The law’s basic rule is: produce the original. If you cannot produce the original, the law permits alternatives in specific circumstances. Understanding when you can use copies or oral evidence instead of the original is the core of documentary evidence law.
Key Legal Principles
The Best Evidence Rule. You must produce the best evidence available. For documents, that means producing the original. Secondary evidence — copies, oral evidence of contents — is only admissible when the original genuinely cannot be produced for one of the specified reasons.
Documents Prove Themselves in Certain Cases. Public documents — government records, court records, official certificates — are proved differently from private documents. They carry a presumption of authenticity that private documents do not.
Parol Evidence Rule. The contents of a document must be proved by the document itself, not by oral testimony about what the document says. Oral evidence is generally not admissible to alter, vary, contradict, or add to the terms of a document. This is the parol evidence rule, discussed below.
Attestation Requirements. Some documents — such as deeds, wills, and certain contracts — must be witnessed (attested) to be legally valid. The Evidence Act contains specific rules about how attested documents are proved.
Sources of Law
Sections 60–100, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2022 — the comprehensive framework on documentary evidence.
Section 60 — definition of primary evidence.
Section 63 — definition of secondary evidence.
Section 64 — when secondary evidence may be given.
Section 65 — rules on proof of documents by primary or secondary evidence.
Sections 66–72 — proof of execution, attestation, and authenticity.
Section 73 — proof of public documents.
Sections 74–79 — presumptions regarding documents.
Section 79A — electronic records: admissibility and conditions.
Sections 80–87 — banker’s books: special rules.
Section 91 — the parol evidence rule: contents of documents must be proved by the document.
Section 92 — exclusion of oral evidence to contradict or vary a document.
Electronic Transactions Act, Cap. 442 R.E. 2023 — the framework for admissibility of electronic evidence.
Essential Elements
Primary Evidence — Section 60
Primary evidence is the original document produced before the court. Where a document has been executed in multiple counterparts — such as a contract signed in duplicate — each counterpart is primary evidence of the document as against the party who signed it.
Where a document was produced by a uniform process — such as a printed circular — each copy produced by the same process is primary evidence.
Secondary Evidence — Sections 63–64
Secondary evidence is a substitute for primary evidence. Section 63 defines secondary evidence as:
-
Certified copies of the document.
-
Copies made from or compared with the original by a mechanical or photographic process.
-
Counterparts of documents against parties who did not execute them.
-
Oral accounts of the contents given by persons who have seen the document.
When Is Secondary Evidence Admissible? — Section 64. Secondary evidence may be admitted only in the following circumstances:
-
The original is shown to be in the possession of the person against whom it is to be proved and they refuse to produce it after notice.
-
The existence, condition, or contents of the original have been admitted in writing by the adverse party.
-
The original has been destroyed or lost and the loss or destruction is proved.
-
The original is of such nature that it is not easily movable.
-
The original is a public document and certified copies are permitted to be given.
-
The original is a document of which certified copy is permitted by the Act.
-
The originals consist of numerous accounts which cannot be conveniently examined in court.
Example. A claimant sues on a land sale agreement. The signed original was destroyed in a house fire. The claimant produces a photocopy made before the fire. Under Section 64(c), the secondary evidence is admissible because the original was destroyed and the loss is not the claimant’s fault.
Proof of Execution and Attestation — Sections 66–72
Attested Documents. An attested document is one witnessed by another person — a signature witnessed by a third party. Section 66 provides that where an attested document is required by law to be attested, it may not be used in evidence until at least one attesting witness has been called to prove its execution, if any attesting witness is alive and subject to the court’s process.
Where No Attesting Witness Can Be Found. Section 70 provides that if no attesting witness can be found, secondary proof of the handwriting of the party and at least one attesting witness is sufficient.
Section 67 — Proof of Execution by Admission. If the party against whom the document is tendered admits its execution, no further proof is required.
Public Documents — Sections 73–79
What Are Public Documents? Section 73 defines public documents as documents forming part of official records — records of the courts, records of public offices, parliamentary proceedings, public registers, official notices, and similar documents of a public nature.
Test yourself
Documentary Evidence Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
