Law of Evidence notes · Topic 16 of 19

Opinion Evidence and Expert Witnesses

Explains when opinion evidence is admissible and the role, qualification, and limits of expert witnesses in Tanzanian courts.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 15 min read

The general rule in evidence law is:

πŸ‘‰ Witnesses testify about facts, not opinions.

For example:

  • A witness describes what they saw in an accident

  • The court decides whether the driver was negligent

However, some issues are too technical for judges to decide without help. This is where expert witnesses come in.

Meaning and Definition

Legal Definition

Opinion evidence is testimony in which a witness expresses a belief, judgment, or inference about a fact, rather than directly describing what they perceived.

Section 48 of the Evidence Act provides that facts, not opinions, are the proper subject of testimony. However, Section 47 carves out the expert exception: where the court has to form an opinion on a point of foreign law, science, art, or as to the identity or genuineness of handwriting or finger impressions, the opinions of persons specially skilled in such matters are relevant facts.

An expert witness is a person with specialised knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education in a particular field, whose opinion on matters within that field is admissible as evidence to assist the court.

Simple Explanation

Most witnesses tell the court what happened β€” facts they personally observed. An expert witness goes further: they tell the court what the facts mean. A doctor tells the court what injuries the victim sustained β€” that is fact. The same doctor then gives an opinion about what type of weapon could have caused those injuries β€” that is expert opinion. Because the magistrate has no medical training, the expert’s opinion genuinely helps the court.

Key Legal Principles

Opinion Evidence Is Generally Inadmissible. The general rule, based on Section 48, is that opinions are not facts and are not admissible. The court forms its own opinion from the facts proved before it.

Experts Are the Main Exception. Section 47 creates the most important exception: expert opinion is admissible on matters requiring specialised knowledge. The court receives the expert’s opinion but is not bound by it β€” the court retains the ultimate duty of assessing and deciding.

Lay Witnesses May Give Limited Opinions. Section 49 permits witnesses to give opinions on certain matters within common human experience β€” such as age, speed, identity, mental state, and handwriting β€” where the opinion is really a shorthand description of observed facts rather than a specialist judgment.

The Court Is Not Bound by Expert Opinion. An expert assists the court β€” they do not decide the case. The court may accept, reject, or qualify expert opinion. Where expert opinions conflict, the court must weigh them and choose between them, or find a middle ground.

The Expert Must Be Qualified. Before expert opinion is received, the court must be satisfied that the witness is indeed an expert β€” that they possess the relevant qualifications, training, experience, or skill in the relevant field.

Sources of Law

Section 47, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2023 β€” expert opinion: opinions of persons specially skilled are relevant facts where the court needs to form a view on science, art, foreign law, handwriting, or finger impressions.

Section 48, Evidence Act Cap. 6 β€” the general rule: facts, not opinions, are the subject of testimony.

Section 49, Evidence Act Cap. 6 β€” opinions on relationship, identity, handwriting, and other matters of common knowledge by non-experts.

Section 50, Evidence Act Cap. 6 β€” opinions on questions of foreign law, customs, and usages are admissible.

Section 51, Evidence Act Cap. 6 β€” grounds of opinion: when a witness gives opinion, the grounds of that opinion are also relevant.

Section 52, Evidence Act Cap. 6 β€” character evidence by opinion.

Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 β€” procedures for calling expert witnesses in criminal proceedings.

Essential Elements β€” The Rules on Opinion Evidence

The General Prohibition β€” Section 48

Section 48 establishes that evidence may not be given about an opinion β€” only about facts. A witness who has no special expertise has no business telling the court what the facts mean. Their job is to describe what they experienced, and the court draws its own conclusions.

The Policy Reason. If ordinary witnesses were permitted to give opinions freely, trials would be flooded with lay speculation and conjecture. Every witness would be a part-time analyst. The proper function of the court β€” to weigh facts and draw inferences β€” would be usurped.

Example of Impermissible Opinion. A bystander at a road accident says in court: “In my opinion, the driver was drunk.” This is inadmissible opinion from a non-expert β€” unless the witness is expressing what they perceived (swaying, slurred speech, smell of alcohol) in a shorthand form. The witness should instead describe those observations: “The driver was swaying, his speech was slurred, and I could smell alcohol on his breath.”

Expert Opinion β€” Section 47

Section 47 provides that when the court has to form an opinion on:

  • A point of foreign law or science or art

  • The identity or genuineness of handwriting

  • Finger impressions

The opinions of persons specially skilled in such matters are relevant facts.

What Fields Qualify as Science or Art? The categories of “science” and “art” in Section 47 have been broadly interpreted by courts across East Africa. They include: medicine and pathology, forensic chemistry, toxicology, ballistics, digital forensics, DNA analysis, structural engineering, accounting and auditing, handwriting analysis, and psychiatric assessment. The key is whether specialised training or expertise is genuinely required to assist the court.

Qualification of Experts. Before testifying as an expert, a witness must be formally qualified. The court conducts a preliminary examination of the proposed expert’s credentials β€” their academic qualifications, professional training, years of experience, publications, and practical work in the field. Only after this preliminary qualification does the expert give substantive testimony.

The Expert’s Report. In most Tanzanian proceedings, an expert witness prepares a written report that is served on the other party before trial. At trial, the expert adopts the report as their evidence, may elaborate on it in examination-in-chief, and is then cross-examined by the opposing party.

Test yourself

Opinion Evidence and Expert Witnesses Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Law of Evidence Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now