Introduction
Character evidence is one of the most controversial areas of evidence law. At its heart, it raises a deeply ethical question: should a court be allowed to know that a person has done bad things in the past when deciding whether they did a bad thing in the present?
On one side of the argument: a person’s past conduct is genuinely informative. A serial fraudster is more likely to commit fraud again. A person with a violent history is more likely to have used violence now. Why should the court be kept in the dark about such relevant background?
On the other side: allowing character evidence creates a real danger of conviction by reputation rather than conviction by proof. A court that knows the accused is “a bad person” may unconsciously lower its standards of proof, reasoning that even if this particular charge is not quite proved, the accused probably deserves to be convicted of something. This is precisely the kind of reasoning that the presumption of innocence is designed to prevent.
Tanzania’s Evidence Act reflects the common law’s traditional approach: character evidence is generally excluded to prevent reasoning from propensity, but there are important and carefully defined exceptions. Mastering the balance between the rule and its exceptions is essential for criminal practitioners.
Meaning and Definition
Legal Definition
Character refers to the moral qualities and general reputation of a person in the community where they live or in the sphere in which they operate.
Character evidence is evidence of a person’s general character — their reputation, disposition, or pattern of behaviour — offered to support an inference about their conduct on a specific occasion.
Sections 52–57 of the Evidence Act govern character evidence in civil cases, and Sections 53–57 contain the specific rules for criminal cases, including the protection of the accused’s shield and the circumstances under which it may be lost.
Simple Explanation
Character evidence asks: “What kind of person is this?” It is different from similar facts evidence which asks: “Has this person done this specific type of thing before?” Character evidence is general — it is about reputation and disposition. Similar facts evidence is specific — it is about particular past acts closely resembling the act charged.
Key Legal Principles
Character of the Accused in Criminal Cases. Evidence of the accused’s bad character is generally inadmissible in the prosecution’s case. The prosecution must prove the specific acts charged — it cannot bolster a weak case by showing the accused is “a bad person.”
The Accused’s Shield. When the accused takes the witness stand, they acquire an additional protection: they cannot be cross-examined on their previous convictions or bad character unless they have lost the shield by putting their own good character in issue or by attacking the character of prosecution witnesses.
Good Character Evidence Is Admissible. The accused may always put their good character in evidence. This is a right, not a concession — it goes to both credibility (as a witness) and propensity (making it less likely they committed the offence).
Character of Witnesses. Any witness — not just the accused — may have their credibility attacked through evidence of prior convictions for dishonesty-related offences, or through evidence of bias, interest, or prior inconsistent statements. This is “impeaching the credit of a witness” under Section 157.
Character in Civil Cases. Character evidence in civil cases is more restricted than in criminal cases. Evidence of bad character is generally irrelevant to the issues in civil disputes, though character may be directly in issue in certain civil cases — such as defamation, divorce, or professional misconduct proceedings.
Sources of Law
Section 52, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2022 — character to prove conduct: in civil cases, evidence of the fact that a person is generally of a particular character is inadmissible.
Section 53, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — in criminal proceedings, a prosecutor cannot use evidence of the accused’s bad character or previous convictions as part of the prosecution’s case unless the accused has put their character in issue.
Section 54, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — previous acquittals are not admissible against the accused.
Section 55, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — the accused may give evidence of their own good character, and this is relevant to the probability of their guilt.
Section 56, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — when the accused loses the shield: cross-examination on bad character and previous convictions is permissible when (a) the accused has personally or by their advocate asked questions of prosecution witnesses intended to establish their good character, or (b) the accused has by themselves or their advocate cast imputations on the character of a prosecution witness, or (c) the accused has given evidence against any other person charged with the same offence.
Section 57, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — character of the complainant in sexual offence cases.
Section 157, Evidence Act Cap. 6 — impeachment of credit of any witness (not just the accused): through prior inconsistent statements, evidence of former conviction of any crime, and evidence of bias.
Essential Elements — Character Evidence in Criminal Cases
The General Rule Against Bad Character Evidence
The prosecution’s case must stand or fall on proof of the specific offence charged. Section 53 provides that the prosecution cannot, as part of its case, lead evidence that the accused has committed other offences, has a bad reputation, or is generally of bad character.
The Policy Reason. Allowing the prosecution to routinely use bad character evidence would undermine the presumption of innocence. A jury or magistrate who hears that the accused “has five prior convictions and is well known to the police” is likely to give that evidence too much weight — treating it as corroboration of the current charge rather than simply as background information.
Example. In a robbery trial, the prosecution cannot open by telling the court: “The accused is a habitual criminal who has been convicted of robbery three times before.” This is inadmissible character evidence that may only come in through the shield-loss rules.
The Accused’s Right to Put Good Character in Evidence
Section 55 provides that the accused may give evidence of their own good character. Good character evidence is relevant to two things:
1. Credibility. If the accused testifies, their good character supports the inference that they are telling the truth. A person of good character is less likely to be lying.
Test yourself
Character Evidence Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
