Law of Evidence notes · Topic 12 of 19

Witness Privilege

Explains when a witness or party can refuse to disclose information in court to protect confidential communications.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 12 min read

In evidence law, the general rule is simple:

A witness must disclose all relevant information.

However, the law recognizes that some communications are too important to expose — even in court.

This protection is called privilege.

Privilege is an exception to full disclosure. It exists to protect:

  • Legal advice

  • Public interest

  • Personal rights (like avoiding self-incrimination)

Meaning and Definition

Legal Definition

Privilege is a legal right conferred on a witness or a party to refuse to disclose, or to resist the compulsory disclosure of, certain information or communications in judicial proceedings, on the ground that the protection of the communication is considered more important than its disclosure.

Simple Explanation

Privilege is the law’s recognition that some secrets are more important than the court’s need for complete information. A lawyer’s duty to their client, a government’s need to protect national security, and a person’s right not to incriminate themselves are all examples of interests that the law protects even at the cost of withholding relevant evidence.

Key Legal Principles

Privilege Belongs to the Holder, Not the Witness. In the case of legal professional privilege, the privilege belongs to the client, not the lawyer. The lawyer cannot waive it; only the client can. But the lawyer must claim it on the client’s behalf if the client has not expressly waived it.

Privilege Must Be Claimed. Unlike some other exclusionary rules, privilege does not automatically exclude evidence. The person entitled to the privilege must claim it. If they do not claim it and give the evidence anyway, the evidence is admissible.

Privilege Is Not the Same as Confidentiality. Many communications are confidential but not privileged. A communication between a doctor and a patient, for example, is confidential but is not protected by privilege under Tanzania’s Evidence Act — the doctor can generally be compelled to disclose it if relevant.

Privilege May Be Waived. The holder of a privilege may choose to waive it. Once waived, the communication can be disclosed in court.

Sources of Law

Sections 132–138, Evidence Act Cap. 6 R.E. 2023 — the primary provisions on privilege.

Section 132 — privilege against self-incrimination.

Section 133 — privilege relating to official records: a public officer cannot be compelled to produce official documents whose disclosure would harm public interest.

Section 134 — a police officer is not required to say from whom they received information about the commission of an offence.

Section 135 — professional communication: a legal adviser is not permitted (without the client’s express consent) to disclose any communication made in confidence by the client for the purpose of obtaining legal advice.

Section 136 — this privilege extends to interpreters and clerks of legal advisers.

Section 137 — no legal adviser is compelled to state the contents of any document with which they have become acquainted in their professional capacity, unless the client consents.

Section 138 — privilege is not waived by the legal adviser volunteering evidence in the matter.

Essential Elements

Legal Professional Privilege — Section 135

This is the most important form of privilege in everyday legal practice. It protects communications between a legal adviser — an advocate, barrister, or solicitor — and their client, made in confidence for the purpose of obtaining or giving legal advice.

Rationale. The privilege exists because the administration of justice depends on clients being able to tell their lawyers the truth. If lawyers could be compelled to disclose everything their clients told them, clients would conceal information from their lawyers. Lawyers could not then advise them properly or represent them effectively. The quality of legal representation — and therefore the fairness of proceedings — would collapse.

Conditions for Legal Professional Privilege:

  1. There must be a relationship of legal adviser and client.

  2. The communication must have been made in confidence — not in the presence of third parties unconnected to the matter.

  3. The communication must have been made for the purpose of obtaining or giving legal advice.

  4. The privilege belongs to the client, not the lawyer. Only the client can waive it.

What Is Covered? Communications from the client to the lawyer, and advice from the lawyer to the client, are covered. Documents prepared by the lawyer in the course of providing advice are also covered. This includes emails, letters, meeting notes, draft documents, and oral advice.

What Is NOT Covered? The privilege does not extend to communications made for a criminal or fraudulent purpose. If a client instructs their lawyer to help them commit a fraud or conceal evidence, those communications are not protected. The crime-fraud exception is a firmly established limitation on legal professional privilege.

Example. Rashida tells her advocate in confidence: “I signed that contract under duress. Here is what actually happened.” This communication is privileged. The opposing party cannot compel the advocate to disclose what Rashida said.

Test yourself

Witness Privilege Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Law of Evidence Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now