On this page 8 sections
Introduction
After the evidence has been heard and the closing addresses delivered, the trial court must deliver its judgment. Judgment is the formal decision of the court — determining whether the accused is guilty or not guilty. If guilty, the court then proceeds to sentence: imposing the legally prescribed consequence.
This topic covers the law on judgments, alternative verdicts, the process of sentencing, and the types of punishments available in Tanzanian law. It also addresses compensation to victims — an often overlooked but practically important aspect of the criminal process.
Alternative Verdicts — Sections 300–307 CPA
A court is not necessarily limited to convicting the accused of the specific offence charged. Where the evidence establishes a lesser or related offence, the court may return an alternative verdict — convicting the accused of a different (usually lesser) offence that is included within the charged offence.
General Rule — Section 300 CPA
|
⚖ Criminal Procedure Act — Section 300, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023 Where a person is charged with an offence and facts are proved which reduce it to a minor offence, the court may convict the person of that minor offence, even though that person was not specifically charged with it, provided the minor offence is included in the offence charged. Attempt — Section 301 CPAWhere a person is charged with a completed offence but the evidence only establishes an attempt, the court may convict of the attempt. For example, where a person is charged with stealing but the evidence shows they only attempted to steal, a conviction for attempted theft is available. Alternative Verdicts in Sexual Offences — Section 302 CPAWhere a person is charged with rape and the full offence is not proved, the court may convict of: • Attempted rape • Indecent assault • An offence contrary to any other section of the Penal Code relating to sexual offences Alternative Verdicts in Property Offences — Section 303 CPAWhere a person is charged with robbery and the full offence is not proved, the court may convict of: • Stealing • Obtaining by false pretences (if applicable facts are established) • Attempted robbery The Judgment — Sections 312–313 CPA
Mode of Delivering Judgment — Section 312 CPAThe judgment must be delivered in open court. The accused (if convicted) must be present when the judgment is delivered. The judgment may be read out in full or the operative parts may be read with the full text available to the parties. Content of Judgment — Section 313 CPA
The requirement for reasons is critically important. A judgment without reasons is defective and may be quashed on appeal. Reasons serve two functions: • They demonstrate that the court considered the evidence properly • They enable the appellate court to understand the basis of the decision and to review it meaningfully Motion in Arrest of Judgment — Section 317 CPAAfter conviction but before sentence, the accused may apply for a ‘motion in arrest of judgment’ — a formal application arguing that the charge or the record of the proceedings discloses no legal offence for which the accused can be sentenced. If the motion succeeds, no sentence is imposed. |
