Imagine you’re preparing your client’s case for trial. You’ve drafted the plaint, the WSD has come in, the issues are coming into focus. Now you need to know what evidence the other side has. You suspect that the defendant company holds an internal report that admits the defect in its product. You suspect that the plaintiff has emails that contradict her sworn account of the events. How do you get at those documents and those facts before the trial begins, so that you can prepare your case properly?
The answer is the pre-trial discovery procedures in Orders XI and XII of the CPC. These rules give each side the right to extract information and documents from the other, and to narrow the area of dispute by securing admissions. The whole purpose, as the Tanzanian textbooks put it, is to prevent trial by ambush — to ensure that, by the time the trial starts, neither side is taken by surprise.
This topic has three sub-doctrines:
Interrogatories — written questions put by one party to the other, which must be answered on oath.
Discovery and inspection of documents — disclosure of relevant documents and the right to examine them.
Admissions — formal acceptance by one party of facts or documents alleged by the other, with the costs sanction for unreasonable refusal.
Why These Tools Exist — the Marriot v Chamberlain Principle
The foundational principle of pre-trial procedure is in the classical English case Marriot v Chamberlain (1886) 17 QBD 154:
Every party to civil proceedings is entitled to know the nature of his opponent’s case so that he may know beforehand what case he has to meet at the hearing. However, such a party is not entitled to know facts which constitute exclusively the evidence of his opponent’s case, since an unscrupulous party may tamper with his opponent’s evidence once he knows of it, or he may manufacture evidence to oppose it.
That paragraph holds the whole logic of the topic. There are two competing interests. On one hand, fairness — each side should know the case it has to meet. On the other hand, the integrity of evidence — you shouldn’t be able to find out the contents of your opponent’s evidence in advance to tamper with witnesses or fabricate counter-evidence. The pre-trial procedures balance these by allowing discovery of the facts and documents on which the other side relies, but not the evidence by which they will be proved.
Interrogatories — Order XI
What interrogatories are
Interrogatories are written questions put by one party to civil proceedings to his opponent. The opponent must answer them on oath, by affidavit, within the time prescribed (commonly 10 days from service). They are normally administered in preparation for the hearing.
Functions of interrogatories
Three functions, all worth knowing:
To enable the party administering them to know the nature of the opponent’s case. This allows him to prepare his own evidence.
To shorten the proceedings. Once the opponent admits certain facts in answer to interrogatories, those facts no longer need to be proved at trial. The answers help determine what evidence is necessary and what is not.
To lessen the expense of litigation. Fewer witnesses, less time, narrower issues.
Limits on what can be asked
The Marriot v Chamberlain principle sets the boundary, and three categories of interrogatories are not allowed:
A party may not interrogate to discover facts that constitute the exclusive evidence of the opponent’s case or title.
A party may not interrogate on confidential communications between the opponent and his legal adviser.
A party may not put interrogatories that would be injurious to the public interest or security — for example, a defendant who is a military officer cannot be interrogated on military matters.
A further category to know: fishing interrogatories — interrogatories whose sole purpose is to discover the evidence of the opponent — are objectionable. The party answering may, in his affidavit, take just exception to such interrogatories.
How interrogatories are administered
The party wishing to administer interrogatories applies to the court for leave under Order XI Rule 1. Leave granted, the interrogatories are served on the opponent. The form is straightforward — numbered questions, in concise form, framed in the manner of “Did you…”, “Were you…”, “Was it…”, “If not, was it not…”.
A standard form template, which you should be familiar with for drafting purposes:
TITLE
Interrogatories on behalf of the above-named Plaintiff (Defendant) for the examination of the above-named Defendant (Plaintiff) pursuant to the order herein dated the …….. day of …………… 2024.
Did you…
Were you…
Was it…
If not, were you not…
The Defendant (Plaintiff) AB is requested to answer the interrogatories numbered …
Served this …….. day of …………… 2024.
………………………… Advocate for the Plaintiff (Defendant)
To: The above-named Defendant (Plaintiff)
Answering interrogatories
Under Order XI Rule 7, the party served with interrogatories must file an affidavit in answer, within 10 days. The affidavit must answer each interrogatory precisely and correctly. The deponent should distinguish between matters within his own knowledge and matters of belief or information.
If a particular interrogatory is objectionable — for example, fishing, or relating to privileged communications — the deponent may take just exception to it in his affidavit. He does not refuse to file the affidavit altogether; he files it and raises the objection paragraph by paragraph.
Inadequate answers
If the party administering the interrogatories considers the answers inadequate or evasive, he may apply to the court under Order XI Rule 9 for an order requiring fuller or further answers.
Key Statutes and Cases on Discovery, Inspection, and Admissions
Statutes
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023s. 31 discovery; Orders XI, XII and XIII
- Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023s. 66 primary evidence; s. 67 secondary evidence; s. 68 notice to produce
Test yourself
Discovery, Inspection, and Admissions Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
