Civil Procedure notes · Topic 13 of 20

Trial, Hearing, Adjournments, Withdrawal, and Compromise

How a civil trial is actually conducted in Tanzanian courts — the order of hearing, examination of witnesses, the submission of no case to answer, adjournments, withdrawal of suits, and consent decrees.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 21 min read

Introduction

So far we’ve been preparing the case. Now we conduct it. This topic covers what actually happens when the trial begins — the order in which witnesses are called, how they are questioned, the discipline of adjournments, the unusual procedure of a submission of no case to answer in civil litigation, and the ways a suit can end before judgment by withdrawal or compromise.

I want to highlight two points before we begin. First, Tanzanian civil procedure operates on the adversarial model — the parties run the case, the court is a relatively passive umpire, and evidence comes out through examination and cross-examination by the advocates. Second, the rules of trial are governed by the CPC (especially Orders XVIII and XVII) and supplemented by the Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023, which governs the admissibility and quality of evidence.

This is also a topic where Tanzania has developed some distinctive jurisprudence — particularly on the submission of no case to answer in civil suits, addressed in Daikin Air Conditioning (E.A.) Ltd v Harvard University (HC Civil Appeal No. 21 of 1976) [1977] TZHC 546. Make sure you know that case.

Two Foundational Principles

Before we get to the procedure, two principles you should keep in mind.

Orality of proceedings

The trial in Tanzania operates on the principle of orality — evidence is given viva voce, by mouth, before the court. The court sees the witness, hears the testimony, observes the demeanour. This is distinguished from the principle of mediacy (where evidence comes through written affidavits or commissions, without the court seeing the witness). Although affidavits are accepted in some contexts, the general rule for trial is oral evidence.

Party prosecution and dispositive election

Two related principles run through the conduct of a trial.

The principle of party prosecution means that the conduct of the case is left to the parties. They prosecute their own cases, decide what evidence to lead, and choose tactics. The court is a relatively passive umpire — it does not investigate; it does not gather evidence on its own initiative. This is the essence of the adversarial system, as distinguished from the inquisitorial system of civil law jurisdictions.

A connected idea is party investigation versus judicial investigation. Under party investigation, the parties are responsible for gathering and presenting evidence; the court is ignorant of the case until the parties present it.

The principle of dispositive election means each party has the choice of what to tell the court and what not to — what evidence to lead, what arguments to make. The court does not compel a party to disclose more than he chooses.

These principles have qualifications, which we’ll come to — particularly the court’s power under Order XVI Rule 14 to summon witnesses on its own initiative.

The Order of Hearing — Order XVIII

When the trial begins, the order of proceedings is governed by Order XVIII of the CPC. The order is:

Who begins

As a general rule, the plaintiff begins — he has the burden of proof on the main issues, so he leads evidence first. The exception is where the defendant admits the plaintiff’s allegations but raises counter-allegations of his own. In that situation, the defendant has the affirmative burden and he begins.

Opening address

The plaintiff (or whichever party has the right to begin) gives an opening address — a general overview of his case. He tells the court the way he will proceed to discharge his burden of proof, identifies his witnesses, and summarises the evidence he will lead.

In Tanzanian practice, formal opening addresses are not always made — they’re more common in complex commercial cases. But you should know that they exist and are part of the procedure.

The plaintiff’s evidence

After the opening address, the plaintiff calls his evidence:

He gives evidence himself on oath (if he’s a witness in his own cause).

He calls his witnesses one by one.

Each witness is subjected to three stages of questioning:

Examination-in-chief — questioning by the party who called the witness (here, the plaintiff’s advocate), to elicit the witness’s account. Leading questions are not generally permitted in examination-in-chief.

Cross-examination — questioning by the opposing party (the defendant’s advocate), to test, qualify, or contradict the account. Leading questions are permitted in cross-examination.

Re-examination — further questioning by the calling party, limited to matters that arose in cross-examination. The purpose is to clarify or explain points raised in cross-examination, not to introduce new evidence.

When the plaintiff has called all his evidence and closes his case, the position passes to the defendant.

The defendant’s evidence

At this stage, the defendant has a choice. He can call his evidence, or he can make a submission of no case to answer (more on this below). If he calls evidence, the same three-stage procedure applies: examination-in-chief, cross-examination by the plaintiff’s advocate, re-examination.

Final submissions

When all evidence has been taken, the parties address the court in final submissions:

The defendant’s advocate addresses the court first (because he is now in the position of responding to the plaintiff’s case as proved).

Then the plaintiff’s advocate replies.

In some cases the plaintiff may reply on points of law.

The court then reserves judgment to a date to be fixed.

Submission of No Case to Answer in Civil Suits

This is a topic that Tanzanian jurisprudence has developed in a distinctive way, and it’s important.

The question

In criminal procedure, section 230 of the Criminal Procedure Act allows the court to rule, at the close of the prosecution’s case, that there is no case to answer — meaning the accused need not even open his defence. The question in civil procedure has been: can a defendant, at the close of the plaintiff’s case, similarly submit that there is no case to answer?

The CPC has no express provision on this. There is a lacuna. The Tanzanian courts have filled it by reference to section 2 of the Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2023, which brings in English common law for matters not specifically provided in our statutes.

The two situations

The English authority Ramsden v Ramsden [1954] All ER 623 sets out two situations in which a defendant in a civil case may submit no case to answer:

The submission is that, accepting the plaintiff’s evidence at its highest value, no case has been established in law. (This is a submission on a point of law — the plaintiff’s evidence, even if believed, does not amount to the cause of action.)

The submission is that the evidence led by the plaintiff is so unsatisfactory or unreliable that the burden of proof has not been discharged. (This is a submission on the evidence — the plaintiff’s case is too weak to require an answer.)

A second supporting authority is Vye v Vye [1969] All ER 29.

The Tanzanian application

The leading Tanzanian authority is Daikin Air Conditioning (E.A.) Ltd v Harvard University [1977] TZHC 546 (HC, Samatta J). The court considered the doctrine in detail and adopted the substance of the English approach.

Later High Court decisions continue to follow Daikin. The principle, as it is usually summarised:

A submission of no case to answer in a civil case stands on the same footing as a submission of no case to answer in a criminal case, save that there is a difference in the standard of proof.

The test: when the dismissal of the plaintiff’s case on the basis that no case has been made out is prayed for, the court should not ask itself whether the evidence given establishes what would finally be required to be established. The court should ask: is there evidence upon which a court, applying its mind reasonably to such evidence, could or might (not should or ought to) find for the plaintiff?

Key Statutes and Cases on Trial, Hearing, Adjournments, Withdrawal, and Compromise

Statutes

  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023Orders XVII adjournments, XVIII hearing, XXIII withdrawal and compromise
  • Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2023s. 2 reception of English law (no case to answer)

Cases

  • Daikin Air Conditioning (E.A.) Ltd v Harvard University, HC Civil Appeal No. 21 of 1976 [1977] TZHC 546A submission of no case to answer is available in a civil suit

Test yourself

Trial, Hearing, Adjournments, Withdrawal, and Compromise Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Civil Procedure Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now