In short
After conviction, the prosecution states whether the accused has previous convictions, the defence pleads in mitigation, and the court sentences within the limits set by the offence-creating law, the Minimum Sentences Act, Cap. 90 where it applies, and the sentencing powers of that court. The Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023 gives the court a range of options beyond imprisonment: absolute or conditional discharge (section 345), probation (sections 356 to 358), community service (section 359), fines with imprisonment in default (section 349), compensation to victims (sections 368 to 371) and costs (section 365). Where a court has discretion, a short, organised, truthful plea in mitigation can change the outcome by years. Prepare it before judgment, not after.
On this page 6 sections
Baraka Mollel has been convicted on his plea under the agreement in Plea Bargaining in Practice. Juma Hassan has been convicted of manslaughter. For the law, see the LLB topic Convictions, Judgments, and Sentencing.
What happens between conviction and sentence?
- Previous recordThe prosecutor tells the court whether the accused has previous convictions. If he says “no record”, the accused is treated as a first offender. If a record is alleged and disputed, it must be proved.
- MitigationThe accused, or his advocate, addresses the court on sentence.
- Prosecution replyThe prosecutor may address aggravating factors and any mandatory sentence.
- Victim’s interestsCourts increasingly consider compensation and the victim’s loss.
- Sentence and reasonsThe court gives the sentence with reasons, and informs the accused of his right of appeal.
What sentencing options does the court have?
| Option | Provision | When to ask for it |
|---|---|---|
| Absolute or conditional discharge | CPA s. 345 | Trivial offences, first offenders, technical breaches |
| Probation | CPA ss. 356-358; Probation of Offenders Act, Cap. 247 | Young or first offenders where supervision will help |
| Community service | CPA s. 359; Community Service Act, Cap. 291 | Offences punishable by short terms where custody is not necessary |
| Fine, with imprisonment in default | CPA s. 349 | Where the client can pay; argue for time to pay |
| Compensation to the victim | CPA ss. 368-371 | Property offences; often combined with a non-custodial sentence |
| Imprisonment | Offence-creating law; Minimum Sentences Act, Cap. 90 | Argue for the lowest term the law allows |
| Costs | CPA s. 365 | Rare in practice |
Key Statutes and Cases on Sentencing and Plea in Mitigation
Statutes
- Criminal Procedure Act, Cap. 20 R.E. 2023s. 340 several offences; s. 345 discharge; s. 349 default imprisonment; ss. 356-358 probation; s. 359 community service; s. 365 costs; ss. 368-371 compensation
- Minimum Sentences Act, Cap. 90Minimum sentences
- Probation of Offenders Act, Cap. 247Probation
- Community Service Act, Cap. 291Community service orders
Test yourself
Sentencing and Plea in Mitigation Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
