In short
Lon Fuller and John Finnis are the two leading modern natural lawyers. Fuller, in The Morality of Law (1964), argued that law has an “inner morality”: eight procedural requirements, such as generality, publication, clarity and non-retroactivity, without which a system fails to be law at all. His theory is procedural, not about the content of law. Finnis, in Natural Law and Natural Rights (1980), restated Aquinas in secular terms: there are seven basic goods (life, knowledge, play, aesthetic experience, friendship, practical reasonableness and religion) and nine requirements of practical reasonableness, and law exists to serve the common good. For Finnis an unjust law is still law, but law in a defective, non-central sense.
On this page 6 sections
How did Fuller explain the inner morality of law?
Fuller told the story of King Rex, who tried to make law and failed in eight ways: he made no rules at all and decided case by case; kept his rules secret; made them retroactive; wrote them so that no one could understand them; made contradictory rules; demanded the impossible; changed them so often that no one could follow them; and applied them in ways unconnected to what they said. From these failures Fuller drew eight principles of legality:
- Generality: there must be rules, not ad hoc decisions.
- Promulgation: rules must be published.
- Non-retroactivity: rules must generally operate prospectively.
- Clarity: rules must be understandable.
- Non-contradiction: rules must not conflict.
- Possibility of compliance: rules must not require the impossible.
- Constancy: rules must not change too frequently.
- Congruence: official action must match the declared rules.
A total failure in any one of these does not merely produce bad law; it produces something that is not properly called a legal system. Fuller also distinguished the morality of duty (the basic rules without which ordered society is impossible) from the morality of aspiration (the pursuit of excellence). The eight principles are mostly matters of aspiration, achieved in degrees.
Why is Fuller’s law-making a moral matter?
Fuller argued that the principles respect people as responsible agents who can plan their lives by known rules. A government that keeps to them treats citizens with a basic reciprocity: it announces the rules and then judges people by those rules. He also believed that a regime that observes legality is less likely to pursue wicked ends, because evil aims are hard to pursue openly through clear, public, general rules.
Key Statutes and Cases on Modern Natural Law: Fuller and Finnis
Statutes
- Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 13(6)(c) no retroactive offences or heavier penalties
Cases
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Daudi Pete, [1991] TZCA 1Laws limiting rights must be lawful and not arbitrary
Test yourself
Modern Natural Law: Fuller and Finnis Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
