Introduction
One of the most challenging aspects of administrative law is what happens when the law gives a government official or body the power to make a decision — but without prescribing exactly how that decision should be made. This is called discretionary power: the legal authority to choose between possible courses of action (or inaction) based on judgment.
Discretion is everywhere in public administration. A licensing officer has discretion whether to grant or refuse a licence. An immigration officer has discretion whether to approve or reject a work permit. A minister has discretion in allocating government contracts. A university administrator has discretion in granting or denying examination deferrals. These powers are granted because it would be impossible for Parliament to prescribe the exact outcome in every possible situation — real life is too varied for mechanical rules to handle.
But discretion is also dangerous. If left completely unchecked, it can be abused — used for corrupt purposes, to advance personal interests, to victimise political opponents, or simply out of sheer unreasonableness. The central challenge of administrative law with respect to discretionary powers is therefore: How do we allow government officials enough flexibility to govern effectively, while still preventing abuse?
This topic examines the nature of discretion, the grounds on which the exercise of discretionary powers can be challenged, and the key distinction between the merits of a decision (which the court generally will not second-guess) and the legality of how discretion was exercised (which the court will scrutinise).
Meaning and Definition
What is Discretionary Power?
A discretionary power is a legal authority granted to an administrative body or officer that permits them to choose from among two or more courses of action (or inaction) in response to a given situation, without being bound by a specific predetermined rule requiring a particular outcome.
Discretionary powers are usually identifiable by the language of the enabling statute. Phrases such as “the Minister may”, “if the Commissioner is satisfied”, “as the authority thinks fit”, “subject to such conditions as the Board deems appropriate” all indicate discretion.
Contrast with Duty: A duty is a legally binding obligation to take a specific action. Phrases such as “the authority shall” or “the officer must” indicate a duty, not discretion. Where a duty exists, failure to perform it can be compelled by the court through a mandamus order (see Topic 8). Where discretion exists, the court generally cannot tell the authority what decision to make — it can only ensure the discretion is exercised lawfully.
Simple Explanation
Think of it this way: a traffic law that says “no vehicle shall exceed 50 km/h on this road” gives no discretion — the officer either tickets you or does not, based on whether you exceeded 50 km/h. But a law that says “the licensing authority may refuse a licence where it is satisfied that the applicant is not a fit and proper person” gives discretion — the authority must assess whether the applicant meets the standard, and reasonable people might reach different conclusions.
Why Discretion is Granted
Parliament grants discretion to administrative bodies for several legitimate reasons:
Complexity: Some situations are too complex for rigid legislative rules. For example, planning decisions involve weighing environmental, economic, social, and aesthetic considerations that cannot all be reduced to bright-line rules.
Expertise: Some bodies have specialist technical expertise that Parliament cannot replicate. A pharmaceutical regulatory authority, for instance, is better placed than Parliament to decide whether a drug is safe.
Flexibility: Society changes rapidly. Discretionary powers allow the executive to respond to new situations without waiting for Parliament to amend legislation.
Individual Circumstances: Cookie-cutter rules cannot accommodate every individual’s unique circumstances. Discretion allows for case-by-case assessment.
The Scope of Judicial Control Over Discretion
The courts do not act as an appellate body for discretionary decisions — they do not substitute their own judgment for that of the administrative authority on the merits of the decision. This would undermine the constitutional principle of separation of powers: if Parliament gave the discretion to the minister, it did not give it to the court.
However, courts do scrutinise the manner in which discretion was exercised — to ensure the authority acted within its legal powers, for proper purposes, in a procedurally fair manner, and without reaching a conclusion so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could have reached it.
Lord Diplock’s classification in Council of Civil Service Unions v. Minister for Civil Service [1984] 3 All ER 935 — illegality, irrationality, and procedural impropriety — provides the framework for this scrutiny.
Grounds for Challenging the Exercise of Discretion
Illegality
Illegality occurs when the decision-maker does not understand correctly the law that regulates their decision-making power, or acts in a manner that is not authorised by law. Lord Diplock described it as: the decision-maker must understand correctly the law that regulates their decision-making power and must give effect to it.
Specific manifestations of illegality in the exercise of discretion include:
Acting Ultra Vires (Exceeding the Scope of the Power)
The most fundamental form of illegality. An administrative body exercises its discretion illegally if it does something the enabling Act does not authorise. Even if the authority believes it is acting for good reasons, it cannot exercise a power it does not legally have.
Example: The Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority (TCRA) has discretion to revoke a broadcaster’s licence for breach of broadcasting standards. If TCRA revokes a licence because a broadcaster broadcast a political programme critical of the government — and breach of political content is not a ground for revocation under the Electronic and Postal Communications Act, Cap. 306 — the revocation is ultra vires.
Test yourself
Discretionary Powers and Their Control Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
