On this page 6 sections
Introduction
When a government body acts unlawfully — making a decision without legal authority, violating natural justice, or exercising its powers for improper purposes — what can the affected citizen do? The answer, in Tanzania as across the common law world, is: apply for judicial review.
Judicial review is the mechanism by which the High Court of Tanzania supervises the legality of decisions made by public authorities. It is the cornerstone of administrative law — the primary legal tool through which the rule of law is enforced against government.
Without judicial review, all the principles discussed in earlier topics — natural justice, the ultra vires doctrine, the rule of law — would be mere theoretical aspirations with no practical enforcement mechanism.
It is crucial to understand from the outset what judicial review is and what it is not. Judicial review is NOT an appeal. The court does not retry the case on its merits or substitute its own decision for that of the administrative body. It is a supervisory jurisdiction — the court asks not “was the right decision made?” but “was the decision made in the right way, by the right body, within its legal powers, and following proper procedures?” If the answer to any of these questions is no, the court can quash the decision, compel the authority to act, or grant other appropriate relief.
This topic examines the constitutional and statutory basis for judicial review in Tanzania, who can apply (locus standi), the grounds for review (illegality, irrationality, procedural impropriety), procedural requirements, ouster clauses, and the distinction between review and appeal.
Constitutional and Legal Basis for Judicial Review in Tanzania
The High Court’s power to conduct judicial review derives from several sources:
Article 108(1) and (2) of the Constitution: These provisions vest the High Court with unlimited original jurisdiction in all matters (Article 108(1)) and specifically empower it to supervise all courts and persons or bodies exercising judicial or quasi-judicial functions in Tanzania (Article 108(2)). This supervisory jurisdiction is the constitutional home of judicial review.
Article 30(3) of the Constitution: Provides that any person claiming that a provision of Articles 12–29 (the Bill of Rights) has been violated may petition the High Court for redress. This allows judicial review to overlap with constitutional rights enforcement.
The Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, Cap. 310 R.E. 2023: This Act empowers the Chief Justice to make rules governing applications for prerogative orders. The Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) (Judicial Review Procedure) Rules, 2026 (GN No. 288 of 2026), in force from 9 October 2026, govern the procedure. They revoked the Judicial Review Procedure and Fees Rules, 2014 (GN No. 324 of 2014).
The Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act, Cap. 3 R.E. 2023: Governs petitions for enforcement of constitutional rights, which often overlap with judicial review.
Common Law: Tanzania inherited the English common law tradition of judicial review through the Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2023. English law on judicial review, as of the 22nd July 1920 (the reception date), applies in Tanzania to the extent it is not inconsistent with local law.
Nature of Judicial Review — Review vs. Appeal
The distinction between judicial review and appeal is fundamental and frequently examined.
Appeal is a legal mechanism that allows a higher court to reconsider the merits of a lower court’s or tribunal’s decision and substitute its own decision if it disagrees with the outcome. On appeal, the appellate court asks: “Was the decision correct?”
Judicial Review is a supervisory mechanism that allows the High Court to examine the legality, procedural propriety, and rationality of administrative decisions — but not to substitute its own decision on the merits. On judicial review, the court asks: “Was the decision made lawfully, fairly, and within the authority’s legal powers?”
Practical Difference:
-
On appeal: “The tribunal’s assessment of the evidence was wrong — the correct decision is X.”
-
On judicial review: “The tribunal failed to give the applicant a fair hearing before deciding — the decision must be quashed and remade properly.”
Tanzanian courts consistently maintain this distinction. In Tanzania Air Services Ltd v. Minister for Labour [1996] TLR 217, the High Court emphasised that judicial review addresses the process and legality of decision-making, not the substantive merits of the administrative decision.
Who Can Apply for Judicial Review? Locus Standi
Locus standi (Latin for “place to stand”) refers to the legal standing of a person to bring an application for judicial review. Not everyone can challenge every government decision — a person must have a sufficient legal interest in the matter.
The Sufficient Interest Test
In Tanzania and across the Commonwealth, the test for standing in judicial review is whether the applicant has a sufficient interest in the matter to which the application relates. This test is broad enough to include anyone directly and adversely affected by the impugned decision, but excludes mere busybodies or those with no genuine stake in the outcome.
Direct interest: A person whose licence was revoked clearly has sufficient interest. A person whose application for a permit was refused clearly has sufficient interest.
Public interest standing: In Tanzania, courts have increasingly recognised standing for organisations and individuals who challenge government action in the public interest — even where they are not the direct subjects of the impugned decision. The Legal and Human Rights Centre (LHRC) and the Tanganyika Law Society (TLS) have been recognised as having standing in public interest litigation. This is supported by Article 26(2) of the Constitution, which gives every person the right to require the state to comply with the law.
Example: The LHRC brings a constitutional petition challenging a government regulation that unconstitutionally restricts the right to peaceful assembly. Even though LHRC is not directly subjected to the regulation, it has sufficient interest as an organisation dedicated to the protection of human rights.
What is Judicial Review
Judicial review is the way through which the court controls the actions of administrative bodies.
In Judicial review, the court reviews and scrutinizes the validity of the acts, decisions, instruments, or any transaction performed by administrative bodies.
De Smith in his book Judicial Review of Administrative Action (1968) (2nd Ed.), p. 23 defines judicial review to mean Judicial scrutiny and determination of the legal validity of instruments, acts, decisions, and transactions of administrative organs.
Judicial Review in Tanzania
Judicial review is recognized in Common Law jurisprudence as the means of controlling the excesses of power by public officials.
Judicial review is an inherent jurisdiction vested in the High Court.
That means all Judicial Review applications must be lodged in High Court.
Historical Development of Judicial Review
Historically in Britain, Judicial Review was a means of controlling public power developed in a very limited fashion.
Judicial Review was used as the means by which the King tried to control various inferior bodies, largely inferior adjudicative bodies (tribunals, inquiries) than administrative bodies.
Judicial Review was influenced by approaches/notions of private law rather than public law.
The scope of Judicial Review was limited on
-
Was there a public right infringed?
-
What kind of remedies?
Because the remedies of Judicial Review emanated (came) from the King were called PREROGATIVE ORDERS.
What is the Rationale for Judicial Review?
The essence of judicial review is to ensure that statutory powers are not; Usurped, Exceeded, or abused and that procedural and substantive duties are complied with.
Grounds for Judicial Review
Lord Diplock in Council of Civil Service Union v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374 stated three major grounds of Judicial Review that is Illegality, Irrationality, and Procedural impropriety.
Test yourself
Judicial Review of Administrative Action Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
