Introduction
Knowing that a government authority has acted unlawfully is only half the battle. The other half — and often the more practically important half — is knowing what remedy is available and how to obtain it. A legal right without a remedy is, as the Latin maxim says, ubi jus ibi remedium (“where there is a right, there is a remedy”) — and administrative law has developed a rich set of remedies for unlawful government action.
In Tanzania, the primary remedies for unlawful administrative action are the prerogative orders — certiorari, prohibition, mandamus, and habeas corpus — together with the private law remedies of declaration, injunction, and damages. Each remedy has a specific purpose, specific conditions for its award, and specific limitations.
Critically, all these remedies are discretionary — even if a ground for judicial review is established, the court is not obliged to grant a remedy. The court weighs all the circumstances, including delay, the conduct of the applicant, the public interest, and the likely consequences of granting or refusing relief, before deciding whether and what remedy to award.
This topic examines each remedy in detail, explains when it applies, and discusses the court’s discretion in awarding relief.
Historical and Legal Framework
The prerogative orders originated as common law remedies from the English Court of King’s Bench. Tanzania received them through the Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358.
The substantive power for orders of mandamus, prohibition, and certiorari is in section 17 of the Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, Cap. 310 R.E. 2023. The High Court shall not issue the old prerogative writs; instead, it makes orders requiring an act to be done (mandamus), prohibiting proceedings or matters (prohibition), or removing and quashing proceedings or matters (certiorari). Any reference in written law to the old writs is construed as a reference to the corresponding order.
Procedure is governed by the Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) (Judicial Review Procedure) Rules, 2026 (GN No. 288 of 2026), in force from 9 October 2026, which revoked the Judicial Review Procedure and Fees Rules, 2014 (GN No. 324 of 2014). You apply for leave within six months, then file the main application within 14 days of leave, each by chamber summons supported by an affidavit. See our Judicial Review Application template.
Certiorari (Quashing Order)
What is Certiorari?
Certiorari (pronounced “ser-shyo-rar-ee”) is a prerogative order by which the High Court quashes (cancels) an unlawful decision made by a lower court, tribunal, or administrative body. The effect of certiorari is to remove the impugned decision to the High Court and annul it — restoring the legal position to what it was before the decision was made.
The word “certiorari” is Latin for “to be more fully informed” — historically, the King’s Bench court would summon the record of an inferior tribunal to examine whether it had acted within its jurisdiction.
When is Certiorari Available?
Certiorari is available to quash decisions that are:
-
Made without jurisdiction (the body had no legal authority to make the decision).
-
Made in excess of jurisdiction (the body had authority to act, but went beyond that authority).
-
Made in violation of natural justice (no fair hearing, or biased decision-maker).
-
Made for improper purposes or on irrelevant considerations.
-
Erroneous in law on the face of the record (there is a legal error apparent from the decision document itself).
Certiorari is not a remedy for mere factual errors — courts generally do not quash decisions simply because they disagree with the authority’s assessment of the facts.
Against Whom Does Certiorari Lie?
Certiorari lies against any body — not just courts — that exercises public functions of a judicial or quasi-judicial nature. This includes administrative tribunals, regulatory bodies, disciplinary committees, local authorities, government agencies, and any other body that makes decisions affecting individuals’ rights.
It does not lie against purely private bodies exercising entirely private powers (though the Datafin principle, discussed in Topic 3, may extend it to private bodies exercising public functions).
Effect of Certiorari
The grant of certiorari quashes the impugned decision — it is as if the decision was never made. The matter may then be:
-
Remitted back to the original body for reconsideration in accordance with the law (most common outcome).
-
Decided by the High Court itself in appropriate cases.
-
Left quashed, with no further action required.
Prohibition
What is Prohibition?
Prohibition is a prerogative order by which the High Court orders a lower court, tribunal, or administrative body to refrain from continuing with proceedings or action that would be unlawful. Unlike certiorari (which quashes a completed decision), prohibition is prospective — it prevents an anticipated unlawful act.
Prohibition is appropriate where:
-
A body is about to exceed its jurisdiction in proceedings that have not yet concluded.
-
A body is about to violate natural justice in ongoing proceedings.
-
A body is about to act unlawfully in a way that, if completed, would cause irreparable harm to the applicant.
Difference Between Certiorari and Prohibition
Both certiorari and prohibition address jurisdictional and procedural errors, but they operate at different stages:
-
Certiorari: After the decision — quashes a completed unlawful act.
-
Prohibition: Before the decision — prevents an anticipated unlawful act.
In practice, the two orders are often sought together in the alternative: “the applicant seeks an order of certiorari quashing the decision of [body X], or an order of prohibition preventing [body X] from continuing with the proceedings.”
Mandamus (Mandatory Order)
What is Mandamus?
Mandamus (Latin for “we command”) is a prerogative order by which the High Court commands a public body or officer to perform a public duty that they have unlawfully refused or failed to perform. It is the remedy for inaction or refusal where there is a legal duty to act.
Test yourself
Prerogative Remedies and Other Reliefs Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
