Administrative Law notes · Topic 6 of 11

Natural Justice

A comprehensive explanation of the two pillars of natural justice — the right to a fair hearing and the rule against bias — and their application in Tanzanian administrative law.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 20 min read

Introduction

Imagine that you have been working as a civil servant for fifteen years. One morning, your Permanent Secretary calls you into his office and hands you a letter — effective immediately, you are dismissed. No warning, no charge sheet, no opportunity to defend yourself. Just a letter. Is this fair? Is this legal?

In administrative law, the answer is emphatically no. This is precisely the situation that the principles of natural justice were designed to prevent. Natural justice is a foundational doctrine of administrative law — indeed, of law generally — that requires procedural fairness in any decision-making process that adversely affects an individual’s rights, interests, or legitimate expectations.

Natural justice is not a complex or technical doctrine. At its core, it is about basic fairness. It tells us that before someone is penalised, dismissed, deprived of a licence, or subjected to any other adverse administrative decision, they must be told what they are accused of, given a fair opportunity to respond, and judged by an impartial decision-maker.

In Tanzania, natural justice has a dual basis: it is a common law principle inherited through the Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2023, and it has constitutional force through Article 13(6)(a) of the Constitution of Tanzania, which guarantees the right to a fair hearing before any adverse decision.

This topic is one of the most examined topics in administrative law. Master it thoroughly.


Meaning and Definition

Legal Definition

Natural justice is a body of procedural fairness rules derived from the common law that must be observed by courts, tribunals, and administrative bodies when making decisions that affect the rights, interests, or legitimate expectations of individuals. The rules are described as “natural” because they are considered so obviously fair and reasonable that any rational legal system should recognise them — they are not derived from positive legislation but from principles of reason, fairness, and justice.

Natural justice consists of two core rules (also called two pillars):

First rule — Audi Alteram Partem: Meaning “hear the other side.” Every person affected by a decision must be given a fair opportunity to be heard before the decision is made.

Second rule — Nemo Judex in Causa Sua: Meaning “no one should be a judge in their own cause.” Every decision must be made by an impartial decision-maker who has no personal interest in the outcome.

Simple Explanation

Natural justice simply means: be fair.

Before you make a decision that hurts someone — fire them, revoke their licence, fine them, expel them — you must: (1) tell them what they are accused of or what problem has arisen; (2) give them a genuine chance to respond; and (3) ensure that the person making the decision has no personal stake in the outcome.

These are not extraordinary requirements. They are the minimum standards of basic human decency applied to the exercise of legal power.


Constitutional Basis of Natural Justice in Tanzania

The constitutional basis for natural justice in Tanzania is found primarily in Article 13(6)(a) of the Constitution, which provides:

“It shall be the duty of any adjudicating authority to observe principles of natural justice before making any decision that adversely affects any person.”

This provision is remarkable for several reasons. First, it applies not just to courts but to any “adjudicating authority” — which includes administrative bodies, tribunals, disciplinary committees, regulatory agencies, and any other body exercising decision-making power over individuals.

Second, it uses the mandatory language “shall” — making natural justice a constitutional obligation, not merely a discretionary principle.

Third, it is housed in Article 13, which deals with equality and equal protection — establishing a clear link between procedural fairness and the constitutional right to equality.

Any administrative decision made in violation of natural justice is, therefore, not just unlawful under common law — it is unconstitutional. This is a powerful tool for challenging unfair administrative action in Tanzania.


The First Pillar: Audi Alteram Partem (Right to a Fair Hearing)

Meaning

The Latin phrase audi alteram partem translates as “hear the other side.” It is the principle that no adverse decision should be made against a person without first giving them a fair opportunity to be heard.

What Does the Right to a Fair Hearing Require?

The right to a fair hearing is not a single, monolithic requirement — it comprises several specific procedural entitlements, which courts have developed over time:

1. Adequate Notice

The affected person must be given prior notice that a decision is to be made that could adversely affect them. The notice must be:

  • Given sufficiently in advance of the hearing to allow adequate preparation.

  • Specific enough to inform the person of the nature of the case they must answer.

  • Communicated in a manner that the person can understand.

Example: Before a student at the University of Dodoma is expelled for examination irregularities, the university must give the student written notice specifying: the alleged irregularity, when it occurred, what evidence exists, and when the disciplinary hearing will take place.

2. Disclosure of Case / Evidence

The person must be informed not just that a hearing will take place, but of the substance of the case against them — the specific allegations, the evidence that will be considered, and the names of witnesses (if any). Without knowing what case they must answer, a person cannot prepare an effective response.

Example: A professional whose licence is to be revoked must be told the specific grounds for revocation and shown the evidence (complaints received, inspection reports, etc.) on which the authority relies. Withholding this evidence violates the right to a fair hearing.

3. Opportunity to Respond

The person must have a genuine, not merely formal, opportunity to present their own case, respond to the allegations, offer an explanation, call witnesses, and submit documents. The opportunity must be real and practical — it is not enough to hold a perfunctory hearing at which the decision has effectively already been made.

4. Right to Legal Representation

In some contexts, particularly where serious consequences are at stake, the right to a fair hearing may include the right to be represented by an advocate or other representative. In Tanzania, this right has been examined in cases involving disciplinary proceedings against public servants.

Under the Employment and Labour Relations Act, Cap. 366 R.E. 2023, an employee facing dismissal has the right to be represented at a disciplinary hearing by a fellow employee or a trade union representative.

In the context of criminal proceedings or formal tribunal hearings, the right to legal representation may be constitutionally required under Article 13(6)(a).

5. Reasoned Decision

An emerging requirement — increasingly recognised in Tanzanian and Commonwealth law — is that the decision-maker must give reasons for their decision. This is important because:

  • Reasons allow the affected person to understand why they lost, and to decide whether to appeal.

  • Reasons impose discipline on decision-makers — they must think through their reasoning carefully and articulate it.

  • Reasons facilitate effective judicial review — a court cannot assess whether a decision was rational if no reasons are given.

Tanzanian courts have increasingly required administrative bodies to give reasons for decisions, particularly where the consequences for the affected party are serious. This is also a requirement under good governance principles promoted by CHRAGG.

When Does the Right to a Fair Hearing Apply?

The right to a fair hearing applies whenever a decision adversely affects a person’s rights, interests, or legitimate expectations. This is a broad standard. It includes:

  • Dismissal from employment (public or private sector where public law applies)

Test yourself

Natural Justice Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Administrative Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now