Introduction
“No one is above the law.” This simple statement captures the essence of one of the most powerful ideas in legal history — the rule of law. The rule of law is not just a philosophical aspiration. In Tanzania, it is a constitutional principle that binds every organ of government, every public official, and every administrative body. It is the bedrock upon which administrative law is built.
Without the rule of law, administrative law would have no foundation. If government officers could act as they pleased — ignoring legal limits, exercising power arbitrarily, and victimising citizens without accountability — there would be no point in having administrative law at all. It is precisely because the rule of law demands that all exercise of power be grounded in law, applied equally, and subject to independent judicial scrutiny that administrative law has both meaning and force.
This topic explains what the rule of law means in theory and in practice, how it has been articulated in Tanzanian law, and how it serves as the foundation for the doctrines, principles, and remedies that you will study throughout the rest of this course.
Meaning and Definition
Legal Definition
The phrase “rule of law” means that law, not arbitrary power, governs society. Every person — citizen and government official alike — is subject to the law. Government must act within the framework of established legal rules, and individuals must have access to independent courts to vindicate their rights when those rules are broken.
The Constitutional Preamble of Tanzania declares commitment to democratic principles and the rule of law. Article 8(1)(c) of the Constitution expressly provides that the activities of the government of the United Republic shall be conducted in ways which comply with the democratic principles and the rule of law.
Article 26(2) of the Constitution goes further: “Every person has the right to have laws that protect him in the exercise of his rights and obligations, and in particular, the right to have the laws upheld and enforced.” This provision gives the rule of law a constitutional dimension that is directly enforceable in Tanzanian courts.
Simple Explanation
Imagine a society where the police can arrest you for any reason or no reason at all, where judges decide cases based on personal relationships rather than evidence and law, and where politicians can change the rules whenever it suits them. That is a society governed by arbitrary power — the opposite of the rule of law.
The rule of law says: everyone must follow the same rules, including those who make and enforce the rules. If a government officer exceeds their legal authority, they must be held accountable, just like any citizen who breaks the law.
Dicey’s Formulation of the Rule of Law
The most influential classical formulation of the rule of law comes from the English constitutional scholar Albert Venn Dicey, in his seminal work Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution (1885). Dicey identified three distinct meanings of the rule of law, which continue to influence legal thinking across the Commonwealth — including Tanzania.
The First Limb — Supremacy of Law (Absence of Arbitrary Power)
Dicey’s first limb states that no person shall be punished or made to suffer except for a breach of law, established in the ordinary legal manner before the ordinary courts.
In other words, government must act within law. It cannot punish citizens, deprive them of their property or liberty, or impose disadvantages on them through arbitrary executive action — without lawful authority established by the law.
Application in Tanzania: This means that a government officer cannot arrest, detain, dismiss, fine, or penalise a citizen without legal authority. The law must clearly authorise the action, and the officer must act within that authorisation. Administrative law enforces this principle through the doctrine of ultra vires and the remedy of judicial review.
Example: A Regional Commissioner cannot order the demolition of a building simply because they personally dislike the owner. The demolition must be authorised by a specific law (such as the Urban Planning Act), must follow prescribed procedures, and must be based on lawful grounds.
The Second Limb — Equality Before the Law
Dicey’s second limb states that every person, regardless of rank or status, is equally subject to the ordinary law and the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts.
No one — including government ministers, police officers, military officials, or the President — is above the law. If a government officer acts unlawfully, they can be held personally liable in the same courts as ordinary citizens.
Application in Tanzania: Article 12 of the Constitution guarantees equality before the law. Article 13 prohibits discrimination. These provisions give constitutional force to Dicey’s second limb. Government officers who act unlawfully can be challenged in the High Court, and the Government itself can be sued (with certain limitations) under the Government Proceedings Act, Cap. 5 R.E. 2023.
Qualification: The President of Tanzania enjoys personal immunity from civil and criminal proceedings while in office (Article 46 of the Constitution). This is a recognised constitutional exception to the strict principle of equality, justified by the need for governmental stability.
The Third Limb — Constitutional Rights Derived from Ordinary Law
Dicey’s third limb states that the general principles of the constitution (such as the right to personal liberty or the right to public meeting) are the result of judicial decisions determining the rights of private persons in particular cases brought before the courts. In other words, rights are not proclaimed in a written constitution — they emerge from court decisions.
Test yourself
The Rule of Law and Its Application in Tanzania Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
