On this page 5 sections
What is a reply to a counter affidavit?
A reply to a counter affidavit is a sworn statement in which the applicant answers new facts raised in the respondent’s counter affidavit. An application runs in three steps: the applicant files a chamber summons supported by an affidavit, the respondent answers with a counter affidavit, and the applicant may then file a reply. The reply is the applicant’s last word on the facts before the hearing.
When should you file a reply to a counter affidavit?
File a reply only when the counter affidavit raises facts you must contradict or explain, and only within the time the court allows. The court usually fixes the dates for the counter affidavit and the reply when it schedules the application. If no date was fixed, ask the court for time at the next mention rather than filing on the hearing date. Do not file a reply just to repeat your affidavit or to argue the law: arguments belong in the oral or written submissions.
What can and cannot go into a reply to a counter affidavit?
An affidavit is evidence, so a reply follows the same rules as any affidavit. Order XIX rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023 confines affidavits to facts the deponent can prove from their own knowledge, except in interlocutory applications, where statements of belief are allowed if the grounds for the belief are stated.
The leading authority on what to leave out is Uganda v Commissioner of Prisons, Ex parte Matovu [1966] EA 514, which Tanzanian courts, including the Court of Appeal, consistently follow. An affidavit must not contain extraneous matter by way of objection, prayer, legal argument or conclusion. A paragraph saying “the application has merit and should be granted” is a conclusion and can be expunged.
- Answer the counter affidavit paragraph by paragraph, in its own numbering.
- Say clearly which paragraphs you admit (“I do not dispute paragraphs 1 and 2”) and which you dispute.
- For each disputed paragraph, give the true facts briefly and refer to any annexure.
- Do not raise new grounds for the application. The court decides it on the grounds in your chamber summons and affidavit.
- Keep law, arguments and prayers out. Save them for submissions.
How do you verify and swear a reply to a counter affidavit?
End with a verification that separates facts within your own knowledge from facts based on information, and name the source of that information. In Salima Vuai Foum v Registrar of Cooperative Societies and Three Others [1995] TLR 75, the Court of Appeal held that an affidavit made on information should not be acted on unless the sources of the information are specified.
Then swear or affirm before a commissioner for oaths. Section 8 of the Notaries Public and Commissioners for Oaths Act, Cap. 12 requires the commissioner to insert their name and to state truly in the jurat the place and date on which the affidavit was made. A jurat with no place or no date is a classic ground for striking out the whole application, so check it before you file. The guide Jurat of Attestation in Tanzania shows correct and defective examples. A deponent who objects to an oath affirms instead, under the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act, Cap. 34.
See how the application starts in the chamber summons supported by an affidavit sample, and how the respondent answers in the counter affidavit sample. The Law School topic Interlocutory Applications: Injunctions, Chamber Summons and Certificates of Urgency walks through a full application.
Sample Reply to counter affidavit Format
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TANZANIA
AT TANGA
MISC. CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 21 OF 20…..
(Arising from (PC) Civil Appeal No. 8 of 20… of the High Court of Tanzania at Tanga, Matrimonial Appeal. 4 of 20… of the District Court
of Korogwe at Korogwe and Original Civil Case No. 16 of 20….
of Manundu Primary Court)
NEMES JUMA KESI ….……………………… APPLICANT
Versus
EZEKIA MIHAYO DONGO…………………………. RESPONDENT
APPLICANT REPLY TO THE RESPONDENT’S COUNTER-AFFIDAVIT
I, NEMES JUMA KESI, a Christian male adult of P.O.Box 100 Bukombe, Geita do swear and state as follows:-
-
That I have read the counter-affidavit of the respondent.
-
That I do not dispute paragraphs 1 and 2 of the counter-affidavit.
-
That I dispute paragraphs 3 and 4 of the counter-affidavit and state that the High Court appellate Judge did not properly evaluate the evidence adduced at the trial court and the additional evidence recorded by the first appellate court. I further state that the High Court appellate Judge erred in not finding that regardless of some motor vehicle registration cards bearing names of third parties, the said car was de facto owned by the parties in the case.
Download this template
- PDF ready to printPro
- Word fully editableElite
Each copy carries your name for personal use.
Pakua template hii kwa PDF au Word.
Learn the law behind it
