In short
Public international law is the body of rules that binds states and other international persons, such as international organisations, in their relations with each other. It has no world legislature, court with compulsory jurisdiction or police force, yet states generally obey it because it is in their interest and because breaches carry legal and political consequences. Its sources are listed in Article 38(1) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice: treaties, international custom (general practice accepted as law), general principles of law, and, as subsidiary means, judicial decisions and the teachings of the most highly qualified publicists. Custom needs both state practice and opinio juris (North Sea Continental Shelf Cases [1969] ICJ Rep 3).
On this page 9 sections
- What is public international law?
- Is international law really law?
- What are the sources of international law?
- How is customary international law formed?
- What are jus cogens and obligations erga omnes?
- Where does Tanzania fit?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on nature and sources?
- Practice question: the new fishing rule
- Key takeaways
What is public international law?
I want you to separate three things you will meet in your LL.B: public international law (relations between states and international organisations), private international law (conflict of laws between private parties; see the separate Private International Law notes) and municipal law (a state’s internal law). Public international law governs matters such as borders, treaties, the sea, diplomats, the use of force, human rights and international crimes.
Is international law really law?
- The sceptical view: John Austin described international law as “positive morality” because there is no sovereign commanding it.
- The answer: law does not depend only on a central enforcer. States accept international rules as binding, argue about them in legal terms, incorporate them into their constitutions and treaties, and comply most of the time.
- Enforcement mechanisms: reciprocity, countermeasures, Security Council action under Chapter VII of the UN Charter, judgments of the International Court of Justice (ICJ), regional courts such as the African Court in Arusha, and domestic courts applying domesticated treaties.
- Hart treated international law as a primitive legal system with primary rules but undeveloped secondary rules; you can link this to your Jurisprudence studies.
What are the sources of international law?
| Source (Art. 38(1) ICJ Statute) | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| (a) International conventions | Treaties expressly recognised by the states in dispute | UN Charter; Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969 |
| (b) International custom | Evidence of a general practice accepted as law | Diplomatic immunity; prohibition of the use of force |
| (c) General principles of law | Principles common to major legal systems | Good faith; reparation for breach (Chorzów Factory, 1928) |
| (d) Judicial decisions and writings | Subsidiary means for determining rules | ICJ judgments; leading textbooks |
Article 38 lists no formal hierarchy, but in practice a specific treaty usually prevails between its parties over general custom, and jus cogens norms override both.
How is customary international law formed?
- State practice: must be extensive and virtually uniform, including among states whose interests are specially affected (North Sea Continental Shelf Cases [1969] ICJ Rep 3).
- Opinio juris: states must act out of a sense of legal obligation, not habit or courtesy (same case).
- Regional custom: may exist between a group of states, but the party relying on it must prove it (Asylum Case (Colombia v Peru) [1950] ICJ Rep 266).
- Persistent objector: a state that consistently objects while a rule is forming may not be bound (Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries Case [1951] ICJ Rep 116).
- Treaty and custom co-exist: a rule can bind as custom even where a treaty also covers it (Nicaragua v USA [1986] ICJ Rep 14).
What are jus cogens and obligations erga omnes?
- Jus cogens: peremptory norms accepted by the international community as a whole from which no derogation is permitted; a treaty conflicting with one is void (Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Art. 53). Examples include the prohibitions of genocide, slavery, torture, aggression and racial discrimination.
- Erga omnes: obligations owed to the international community as a whole, so every state has a legal interest in their protection (Barcelona Traction [1970] ICJ Rep 3).
- Soft law: UN General Assembly resolutions and declarations are not binding as such, but may evidence opinio juris or crystallise custom (for example, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948).
Where does Tanzania fit?
Tanganyika joined the United Nations in December 1961 and the United Republic continues that membership. Tanzania is a party to the UN Charter and the ICJ Statute, the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (acceded 1976), the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the Treaty for the Establishment of the East African Community, and hosts international courts in Arusha. How these rules take effect inside Tanzania is covered in International Law and Tanzanian Law: Monism, Dualism and Domestication.
Exam focus: what do examiners test on nature and sources?
- Is international law law? Austin, Hart and state practice.
- Article 38(1) and the relationship between sources.
- Elements of custom: North Sea, Asylum, Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries.
- Jus cogens, erga omnes and soft law.
Practice question: the new fishing rule
Question: Twenty coastal states, including Tanzania, have for ten years seized foreign vessels fishing for tuna within 250 nautical miles of their coasts. State X, which has always protested, says it is not bound. Advise.
- Ask whether a customary rule has formed: is the practice widespread and consistent, including among specially affected fishing states (North Sea)?
- Is there opinio juris, or are the seizures merely assertions of interest contrary to UNCLOS, which limits the EEZ to 200 nautical miles?
- Even if a rule formed, State X may be a persistent objector (Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries).
- Between UNCLOS parties, the treaty limit applies; see The Law of the Sea and Tanzania’s Maritime Zones.
Key takeaways
- International law binds states and international organisations.
- Article 38(1) lists treaties, custom, general principles and subsidiary sources.
- Custom requires state practice plus opinio juris.
- Jus cogens norms cannot be derogated from; erga omnes obligations are owed to all.
- Tanzania participates actively in the UN, AU and EAC systems.
Key Statutes and Cases on Nature and Sources of International Law
Statutes
- Statute of the International Court of Justice, 1945Art. 38(1) sources of international law
- Charter of the United Nations, 1945Founding treaty; Chapter VII enforcement
- Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969Art. 53 jus cogens; Tanzania acceded on 12 April 1976
Cases
- North Sea Continental Shelf Cases [1969] ICJ Rep 3Custom requires state practice and opinio juris
- Asylum Case (Colombia v Peru) [1950] ICJ Rep 266Regional custom must be proved
- Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries Case (UK v Norway) [1951] ICJ Rep 116Persistent objector
- Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua [1986] ICJ Rep 14Custom and treaty co-exist
- Barcelona Traction (Belgium v Spain) [1970] ICJ Rep 3Obligations erga omnes
- Factory at Chorzów (1928) PCIJ Series A No. 17Reparation as a general principle
Test yourself
Nature and Sources of International Law Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
