In short
States are the primary subjects of international law. Under Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States, 1933, a state has a permanent population, a defined territory, a government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. Recognition is the act by which an existing state acknowledges a new state or government. Under the declaratory theory (the majority view), recognition only confirms statehood that already exists; under the constitutive theory, recognition creates it. Tanzania has its own important practice: it was the first state to recognise Biafra in 1968, and the 1964 Union of Tanganyika and Zanzibar raised questions of state succession, for which Tanganyika’s “Nyerere doctrine” (1961) on succession to colonial treaties remains a classic example.
On this page 8 sections
- What are the criteria for statehood?
- What is the effect of recognition?
- What is Tanzania's practice on recognition?
- What is state succession?
- How does self-determination relate to secession?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on statehood and recognition?
- Practice question: the breakaway province
- Key takeaways
What are the criteria for statehood?
- Permanent population: no minimum size; it must be stable.
- Defined territory: borders need not be fully settled; disputed boundaries do not prevent statehood.
- Effective government: able to exercise control internally; the standard may be relaxed for states emerging from decolonisation.
- Capacity to enter into relations with other states: independence from the control of another state.
- Additional modern considerations: creation in breach of jus cogens (for example, by unlawful use of force or apartheid) may lead to collective non-recognition.
What is the effect of recognition?
| Theory | Effect | Criticism |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutive | A state exists only when recognised by others | Makes statehood depend on political choices; inconsistent recognition creates a state for some but not others |
| Declaratory | Statehood depends on meeting the criteria; recognition only acknowledges it | Majority view, supported by state practice and the Montevideo Convention, Art. 3 |
- Recognition of governments: many states now focus on dealing with governments rather than formally recognising them, especially after unconstitutional changes. The African Union suspends members after unconstitutional changes of government.
- De facto and de jure: de facto recognition acknowledges effective control provisionally; de jure recognition is full and formal.
- In domestic courts: recognition determines whether a foreign entity can sue and claim immunity; see State Jurisdiction and Immunities.
What is Tanzania’s practice on recognition?
- Biafra (1968): Tanzania was the first state to recognise the secessionist Republic of Biafra in April 1968, on humanitarian grounds; only a handful of states followed and Biafra ceased to exist in 1970. The episode shows recognition as a political act with legal consequences.
- Self-determination: Tanzania hosted liberation movements from southern Africa and supported recognition of peoples’ right to self-determination, now a principle of the UN Charter and the African Charter (Art. 20).
- Western Sahara: Tanzania recognises the Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic, an African Union member.
What is state succession?
State succession is the replacement of one state by another in responsibility for the international relations of territory. Key questions are what happens to treaties, state property, debts, archives and nationality.
- Clean slate: newly independent states traditionally start free of their predecessor’s treaties (Vienna Convention on Succession of States in respect of Treaties, 1978, Art. 16), except for boundary treaties and territorial regimes, which continue (Art. 11 and 12).
- Uti possidetis: African states accepted colonial boundaries at independence (OAU Cairo Resolution 1964), confirmed by the ICJ in Frontier Dispute (Burkina Faso v Mali) [1986] ICJ Rep 554.
- The Nyerere doctrine (1961): on independence, Tanganyika declared that it would continue to apply bilateral treaties concluded by the United Kingdom on its behalf for two years on a reciprocal basis, during which it would decide which to keep. After that period, treaties not continued or renegotiated would lapse, unless they were boundary treaties or reflected custom. Many new African states followed this approach.
- The Union of 1964: on 26 April 1964, Tanganyika and Zanzibar united to form the United Republic. The Union notified the UN that the treaties of both states would continue to apply within their original territorial limits, and the United Republic took over UN membership as a single state.
How does self-determination relate to secession?
Self-determination entitles colonial peoples and peoples under alien domination to independence, but international law protects the territorial integrity of existing states and does not grant a general right of secession. The Supreme Court of Canada, in Reference re Secession of Quebec [1998] 2 SCR 217, held that a right of unilateral secession arises at most where a people is denied meaningful internal self-determination. In its Kosovo Advisory Opinion [2010] ICJ Rep 403, the ICJ held only that the declaration of independence did not violate international law, without deciding on statehood.
Exam focus: what do examiners test on statehood and recognition?
- Montevideo criteria and their application.
- Constitutive versus declaratory theories.
- Recognition of governments and Tanzania’s Biafra practice.
- State succession: clean slate, uti possidetis, the Nyerere doctrine and the 1964 Union.
- Self-determination and secession (Quebec, Kosovo).
Practice question: the breakaway province
Question: A province of an East African state declares independence after a short war, controls its territory and population, and is recognised by three states. The parent state says the new entity is not a state. Advise.
- Apply the Montevideo criteria: population, territory and effective government seem present; independence may be doubtful if it depends on foreign support.
- Under the declaratory theory, recognition by three states does not itself create statehood, but widespread non-recognition is evidence that criteria or legality are lacking.
- Territorial integrity and uti possidetis weigh against secession unless the people were denied internal self-determination (Quebec).
- If created by unlawful force, there may be a duty of non-recognition.
Key takeaways
- Statehood: population, territory, government, capacity for relations (Montevideo, Art. 1).
- The declaratory theory is the majority view.
- Tanzania recognised Biafra in 1968 and follows African uti possidetis.
- The Nyerere doctrine and the 1964 Union are key Tanzanian examples of succession.
- Self-determination does not normally include a right to secede.
Key Statutes and Cases on Statehood, Recognition and State Succession
Statutes
- Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States, 1933Art. 1 criteria for statehood; Art. 3 statehood independent of recognition
- Vienna Convention on Succession of States in respect of Treaties, 1978Arts. 11, 12 and 16
- African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, 1981Art. 20 self-determination
Cases
- Frontier Dispute (Burkina Faso v Mali) [1986] ICJ Rep 554Uti possidetis in Africa
- Reference re Secession of Quebec [1998] 2 SCR 217Limits of a right to secede
- Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in respect of Kosovo [2010] ICJ Rep 403Declaration of independence not unlawful
Test yourself
Statehood, Recognition and State Succession Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
