In short
Every court applies its own procedure, the lex fori, even when the substance of the dispute is governed by foreign law. So the line between substance and procedure decides which law applies to issues such as limitation periods, evidence, remedies and damages. Under the common law received in Tanzania, limitation periods have traditionally been treated as procedural (so Tanzanian limitation rules apply), the heads of recoverable damage are substantive but the assessment of damages is procedural (Boys v Chaplin), and some evidential rules are substantive if they really affect rights (Re Cohn).
On this page 10 sections
- Why does the substance and procedure distinction matter?
- Which matters are clearly procedural?
- Are limitation periods substance or procedure?
- How are damages divided between substance and procedure?
- Are presumptions and burden of proof substantive or procedural?
- Are rules requiring written evidence substantive or procedural?
- What about remedies, parties and priorities?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on substance and procedure?
- Practice question: the Rwandan delivery contract
- Key takeaways
Why does the substance and procedure distinction matter?
Procedure is always governed by the law of the forum. A Tanzanian court cannot be expected to run its proceedings according to Chinese, German or Indian procedure. But if too much is labelled “procedure”, the forum’s law takes over issues that should be governed by the foreign lex causae, and the choice-of-law rule is defeated. So the distinction is itself a characterisation problem, as explained in Characterisation (Classification) in Private International Law.
A useful working test is: does the rule concern the existence and extent of the parties’ rights and obligations (substance), or the machinery by which the court enforces them (procedure)?
Which matters are clearly procedural?
- Court structure, jurisdiction of particular courts and the mode of trial.
- Service of process, pleadings, discovery and interlocutory applications.
- Admissibility of evidence and competence of witnesses, in general.
- Methods of execution and enforcement of judgments.
- Costs and interest on judgment debts.
In Tanzania these are governed by the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2019, the Evidence Act, Cap. 6 and the relevant court rules, whatever law governs the merits.
Are limitation periods substance or procedure?
At common law, limitation statutes that merely bar the remedy, without extinguishing the right, were classified as procedural. So an English court applied English limitation periods even to claims governed by foreign law (Huber v Steiner (1835) 2 Bing NC 202; Harris v Quine (1869) LR 4 QB 653). Rules that extinguish the right itself, such as limitation periods for recovering land that destroy the title, were substantive.
England changed this by the Foreign Limitation Periods Act 1984, which generally applies the limitation law of the lex causae. That Act was passed long after the 22 July 1920 reception date in section 2(3) of JALA, so it is not part of Tanzanian law. Tanzania has no equivalent statute, and the Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89 does not contain a special rule for foreign claims.
Key Statutes and Cases on Substance and Procedure in Cross-Border Cases
Statutes
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2019Procedure in Tanzanian courts applies whatever law governs the merits
- Law of Limitation Act, Cap. 89Tanzanian limitation periods
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 R.E. 2019s. 2(3): English Foreign Limitation Periods Act 1984 not received
Cases
- Boys v Chaplin [1971] AC 356Heads of damage substantive; quantification procedural
- Harding v Wealands [2006] UKHL 32Assessment of damages procedural
- Huber v Steiner (1835) 2 Bing NC 202Limitation barring the remedy is procedural
- Harris v Quine (1869) LR 4 QB 653Foreign limitation that bars only the remedy does not bar a claim in the forum
- Re Cohn [1945] Ch 5Survivorship presumption substantive
- Leroux v Brown (1852) 12 CB 801Statute of Frauds writing requirement treated as procedural
- The Halcyon Isle [1981] AC 221Priorities governed by the lex fori
Test yourself
Substance and Procedure in Cross-Border Cases Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
