On this page 21 sections
- Introduction to the Nature of Law
- Meaning and Definition of Law
- Formal Law and Informal Law
- Characteristics of Law
- The Distinction Between “Law”, “A Law”, and “The Law”
- Classification of Law
- Positive Law and Natural Law
- Common Law and Civil Law Systems
- Public Law and Private Law
- Civil Law and Criminal Law
- Substantive Law and Procedural Law
- Common Law and Equity
- Sources of Law in Tanzania
- The Constitution
- Statutes (Legislation)
- Judicial Precedent
- Customary Law
- Islamic Law
- Received Laws
- Public International Law
- Key Exam Takeaways
Introduction to the Nature of Law
One of the first questions every law student encounters is “What is law?”
This question is central to jurisprudence, which is the philosophy and theory of law. Different scholars and legal schools have provided different answers.
However, in Legal Method, the goal is not to debate every philosophical theory of law. Instead, students must understand how law operates in practice within the Tanzanian legal system.
In simple terms, law provides the rules that organize society, regulate behavior, and resolve disputes.
Without law, society would lack order, predictability, and justice.
Meaning and Definition of Law
Basic Definition of Law
In its simplest form, law can be defined as:
A body of rules recognized by the state as binding upon members of society and enforceable by state institutions such as courts.
This definition highlights three essential elements:
• Law consists of rules
• The rules are recognized by the state
• The rules are enforceable by institutions such as courts and police
Distinguishing Law from Other Social Rules
Law is not the only system of rules guiding human behaviour. Society also has:
• Moral rules
• Religious rules
• Social customs
• Cultural traditions
These rules influence behaviour but they are not always enforced by the state.
For example:
-
A moral rule may say that lying is wrong.
-
But not every lie is punishable by law.
Law becomes different because the state can impose sanctions when legal rules are broken.
Examples of legal sanctions include:
• Fines
• Imprisonment
• Compensation (damages)
• Court orders (injunctions)
Formal Law and Informal Law
Formal Law
Formal law refers to rules created or recognized through official legal processes.
Examples include:
• Acts of Parliament
• Regulations made by ministers
• Judicial decisions (case law)
These rules are clearly identifiable and enforceable through courts.
Examples in Tanzania include:
• Penal Code [Cap 16]
• Law of Contract Act [Cap 345]
• Civil Procedure Code Act No. 49 of 1966
Informal Law
Informal law refers to rules followed by society based on:
• traditions
• customs
• social pressure
These rules may not be written but are widely accepted in communities.
Customary Law: A Unique Position
In Tanzania, customary law occupies a special position.
It originates from community traditions but has been recognized by courts and legislation.
Its recognition is provided under the:
Judicature and Application of Laws Act [Cap 358]
Courts may apply customary law particularly in matters such as:
• marriage
• inheritance
• land rights
However, customary law must pass the repugnancy test, meaning it must not be:
• contrary to justice
• contrary to morality
• inconsistent with written law
Characteristics of Law
Legal scholars often identify three main characteristics that help us understand the nature of law.
Nominal Characteristics of Law
Nominal characteristics refer to the external and observable features of law.
Law usually:
• exists in the form of rules
• is associated with state institutions
• carries official authority
Examples of state institutions associated with law include:
• courts
• police
• parliament
• regulatory authorities
These institutions enforce and interpret legal rules.
Conventional Characteristics of Law
Law is also a social product.
This means law develops from:
• social agreements
• customs
• political arrangements
• societal values
Legal systems therefore reflect the history and culture of a society.
For example:
Many Tanzanian laws reflect both British common law traditions and African customary practices.
Real Characteristics of Law
Real characteristics focus on what law actually does in society.
In practice, law performs several functions:
• regulates behaviour
• resolves disputes
• allocates rights and responsibilities
• maintains social order
Law also reflects existing power relationships and social structures.
Therefore, lawyers must not only read the law as written, but also understand how it operates in practice.
The Normative Nature of Law
A very important feature of law is that it is normative.
This means law tells people what they ought to do, not simply what they actually do.
Law creates obligations.
People are expected to follow the law, and failure to comply may lead to sanctions.
However, not all obedience to law comes from fear of punishment.
Many people obey the law because:
• they believe it is just
• they accept its authority
• they want social order
The Distinction Between “Law”, “A Law”, and “The Law”
Students often use these terms interchangeably, but in legal studies they have distinct meanings.
Law (Abstract Meaning)
“Law” refers to the general system of rules governing society.
Example questions include:
• What is law?
• What is the purpose of law?
Here, we are referring to law as a concept.
A Law
“A law” refers to a specific legal rule or statute.
Examples include:
• The Penal Code
• The Traffic Act
• The Law of Contract Act
Each of these is a particular law within the legal system.
The Law
“The law” refers to the entire body of legal rules applicable in a jurisdiction.
When a lawyer says:
“The law requires this action.”
They are referring to all applicable legal rules, including:
• statutes
• case law
• constitutional provisions
Understanding these distinctions helps students interpret legal texts accurately.
Classification of Law
Law can be divided into different categories to help us understand how it operates.
These classifications are important because different categories involve different procedures, remedies, and institutions.
Positive Law and Natural Law
Positive Law
Positive law refers to law created by human authority.
It includes laws:
• enacted by legislatures
• declared by courts
• recognized through custom
Positive law is simply the law that exists, whether or not it is morally good.
John Austin’s Theory
Legal positivist John Austin defined law as:
The command of the sovereign backed by a sanction.
Under this theory:
• the sovereign issues commands
• citizens must obey
• disobedience leads to punishment
Natural Law
Natural law theory argues that law must be based on moral principles.
It claims that there exists a higher law derived from reason, nature, or divine authority.
The famous principle is:
“Lex iniusta non est lex”
An unjust law is not a true law.
One of the major proponents was St. Thomas Aquinas.
Natural law ideas influenced many important developments such as:
• abolition of slavery
• human rights movements
• constitutional rights protections
Natural Law Influence in Tanzania
While Tanzanian courts apply positive law, natural law ideas influence constitutional rights.
For example:
Articles 12–29 of the Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania (1977) establish the Bill of Rights, protecting fundamental human dignity.
Common Law and Civil Law Systems
These are the two major legal traditions in the world.
The Common Law System
The Common Law system originated in England.
Its main characteristic is that judges develop legal principles through court decisions.
This system relies heavily on precedent.
The principle governing precedent is called:
Stare decisis
(“to stand by decided cases”)
Under this doctrine:
• lower courts must follow decisions of higher courts
Tanzania and the Common Law Tradition
Tanzania follows the Common Law tradition due to its colonial history under Britain.
Courts therefore rely on:
• statutes
• judicial precedents
Important courts include:
• High Court of Tanzania
• Court of Appeal of Tanzania
The Civil Law System
The Civil Law system originated from Roman law and developed in continental Europe.
Its key feature is codification.
Law is organized into comprehensive written codes such as:
• the Napoleonic Code
• the German Civil Code
Judges mainly apply the code rather than create law through precedent.
Countries using this system include:
• France
• Germany
• Italy
Public Law and Private Law
Public Law
Public law governs the relationship between the state and individuals.
Examples include:
• Constitutional law
• Administrative law
• Criminal law
Example:
If a person is prosecuted for theft, the case is State vs Accused.
Private Law
Private law governs relationships between individuals or private entities.
Examples include:
• Contract law
• Tort law
• Family law
• Property law
• Company law
In these cases, one private party sues another.
Example:
A dispute over breach of contract between two companies.
Civil Law and Criminal Law
This classification is based on the nature of disputes and remedies involved.
Civil Law
Civil law deals with disputes between private parties.
Purpose:
To compensate or restore the injured party.
Remedies may include:
• damages (money compensation)
• injunctions
• specific performance
Standard of proof:
Balance of probabilities
Example:
A person sues another for breach of contract.
Criminal Law
Criminal law deals with offences against society.
The state prosecutes offenders through the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP).
Purpose includes:
• punishment
• deterrence
• rehabilitation
• protection of society
Standard of proof:
Beyond reasonable doubt
Possible punishments include:
• imprisonment
• fines
• community service
Example:
A prosecution for theft under the Penal Code [Cap 16].
Substantive Law and Procedural Law
Substantive Law
Substantive law defines:
• legal rights
• duties
• liabilities
Examples:
• Law of Contract Act [Cap 345]
• Penal Code [Cap 16]
These laws explain what conduct is lawful or unlawful.
Procedural Law
Procedural law explains how legal rights are enforced.
Examples include:
• Civil Procedure Code Act No. 49 of 1966
• Criminal Procedure Act [Cap 20]
Procedural law governs:
• filing cases
• court procedures
• evidence rules
• trial processes
Failure to follow procedural rules may result in losing the right to pursue a case.
Common Law and Equity
Development of Equity
Early English common law was very rigid.
Courts could only grant monetary damages.
People who could not obtain justice petitioned the King, whose representative — the Lord Chancellor — decided cases based on fairness.
This developed into equity.
Equitable Remedies
Equity introduced remedies such as:
• Specific performance
• Injunctions
• Rescission
• Rectification
Example:
If a contract involves sale of land, damages may not be enough.
A court may order specific performance, requiring the party to complete the contract.
Maxims of Equity
Important equitable principles include:
• Equity will not suffer a wrong without a remedy
• He who comes to equity must come with clean hands
• Equity follows the law
Position in Tanzania
Both common law and equity were received into Tanzanian law.
Where there is a conflict:
Equity prevails over common law.
This principle is recognized under the Judicature and Application of Laws Act [Cap 358].
Sources of Law in Tanzania
A source of law refers to the authority from which legal rules derive their validity.
Tanzania recognizes several major sources of law.
The Constitution
The Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977 is the supreme law of the land.
It establishes:
• structure of government
• powers of state institutions
• fundamental rights
Constitutional Supremacy
Article 64(5) provides:
Any law inconsistent with the Constitution is null and void.
This means:
• Parliament cannot pass unconstitutional laws
• Courts can strike down unconstitutional legislation
The High Court has power to interpret and enforce constitutional provisions.
Statutes (Legislation)
Statutes are laws passed by Parliament.
Examples include:
• Penal Code [Cap 16]
• Law of Marriage Act No. 5 of 1971
• Law of Contract Act [Cap 345]
Subsidiary Legislation
Parliament may delegate law-making powers to ministers or authorities.
This results in:
• regulations
• rules
• orders
• by-laws
These must remain within the authority granted by the parent statute.
If they exceed that authority, they are ultra vires and invalid.
Judicial Precedent
Court decisions are an important source of law.
The legal principle derived from a decision is called the:
Ratio decidendi
Under stare decisis:
• lower courts must follow decisions of higher courts
Important Tanzanian law reports include:
• Tanzania Law Reports (TLR)
• Law Reports of Tanzania (LRT)
• High Court Digest (HCD)
Customary Law
Customary law refers to traditional rules recognized by communities.
Tanzania has over 120 ethnic groups, each with customary traditions.
Customary law is particularly relevant in:
• marriage
• inheritance
• land matters
Primary Courts frequently apply customary law.
However, customary law must not be:
• inconsistent with written law
• repugnant to justice or morality
Islamic Law
Islamic law is applied mainly in matters involving Muslims, particularly:
• marriage
• divorce
• inheritance
On the mainland it operates alongside statutory law such as the Law of Marriage Act 1971.
In Zanzibar, Islamic law plays a more prominent role.
Received Laws
Under the Judicature and Application of Laws Act [Cap 358], Tanzania received certain laws from England.
These include:
• Common law
• Doctrines of equity
• English statutes of general application in force on 22 July 1920
These laws apply only if:
• they suit Tanzanian conditions
• they are not overridden by local legislation
Public International Law
International law also influences Tanzanian law.
Tanzania is party to many international treaties such as:
• International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)
Courts may refer to international law when interpreting domestic laws, especially in human rights cases.
International agreements often influence national legislation and policy.
Key Exam Takeaways
Students should remember the following points:
• Law is a system of enforceable rules recognized by the state
• Law has nominal, conventional, and real characteristics
• Distinguish between law, a law, and the law
• Major classifications include public/private, civil/criminal, substantive/procedural
• Tanzania follows the Common Law legal tradition
• The Constitution is the supreme source of law
• Other sources include statutes, judicial precedents, customary law, Islamic law, received law, and international law
Test yourself
Understanding the Nature, Classification, and Sources of Law Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
