On this page 15 sections
- Introduction
- Meaning of Special Categories of Relevance
- Key Legal Principles
- Sources of Law
- Section 10 — Statements by Conspirators
- Section 11 — Facts Making Other Facts Probable or Improbable
- Section 12 — Facts Relevant to Damages
- Section 13 — Rights and Customs
- Section 14 — State of Mind
- Section 15 — Similar Facts (Course of Conduct)
- Section 16 — Course of Business
- Important Distinctions
- Practical Scenarios
- Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
- Quick Summary
Introduction
In earlier topics, you learned general categories of relevant facts such as res gestae, motive, and explanatory facts.
Now, we move to a more advanced and exam-important area — the special categories of relevant facts under Sections 10–16 of the Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023.
These provisions deal with specific legal situations, especially:
-
Criminal cases (e.g. conspiracy, fraud)
-
Civil disputes (e.g. damages, customary rights)
-
Cases involving intention, knowledge, or good faith
Understanding these sections gives you a strong advantage in exams and legal practice.
Meaning of Special Categories of Relevance
Definition
Special categories of relevance refer to specific types of facts declared relevant by law under Sections 10–16, even if they may not fall under general relevance rules.
Key Idea
A fact is relevant if it:
-
Makes a fact in issue more probable, or
-
Makes it less probable
What makes these categories “special” is that:
-
Each section applies to a specific situation
-
If a fact fits within the section → it is automatically relevant
Key Legal Principles
Statutory Control Principle
-
Each section (10–16) defines its own category
-
If a fact fits → it is relevant
-
If it does not fit → it is not relevant under that section (but may fit elsewhere)
Probative vs Prejudicial Value
-
Courts may exclude evidence if:
-
Its prejudicial effect outweighs its probative value
-
-
This is especially important in Section 15 (Similar Facts)
Caution Against Unfair Reasoning
Courts avoid reasoning like:
“He did it before, so he must have done it again”
This is called propensity reasoning and is generally not allowed unless strict conditions are met.
Sources of Law
Statutes
-
Evidence Act, Cap. 6 R.E. 2023 (Sections 10–16)
-
Penal Code, Cap. 16 (for conspiracy and intention)
Case Law
-
DPP v. Boardman [1975] AC 421 (HL)
-
Makin v. Attorney-General for New South Wales [1894] AC 57 (PC)
-
R v. Smith [1915] 11 Cr App R 229
These cases are highly examinable.
Section 10 — Statements by Conspirators
Meaning of Conspiracy
A conspiracy is:
An agreement between two or more persons to commit an unlawful act or a lawful act by unlawful means.
Legal Rule
Under Section 10, anything:
-
Said
-
Done
-
Written
By one conspirator in furtherance of the common intention is admissible against all conspirators.
Essential Requirements
Test yourself
Relevance — Special Categories Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
