Human Rights Law notes · Topic 3 of 9

Enforcing Basic Rights in Tanzania: Article 30(3) and the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act

How to enforce the Bill of Rights: Article 30(3) and (4), petitions to the High Court under the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act, Cap. 3 and the 2014 Rules, the three-judge panel, joining the Attorney General, standing and the 2020 amendments, the bar where other adequate remedies exist, remedies, and appeals.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 11 min read

In short

Under Article 30(3) of the Constitution, any person alleging that a provision of the Bill of Rights has been, is being or is likely to be contravened in relation to him may petition the High Court for redress. The Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act, Cap. 3 R.E. 2023 and its 2014 Rules set the procedure: a petition, usually against the Attorney General, heard by a panel of three judges. The court will not hear the petition if adequate redress is available under another law (s. 8(2)). The court may declare a law or act unconstitutional and grant remedies, and appeals go to the Court of Appeal.

On this page 8 sections
  1. What do Articles 26(2) and 30(3) provide?
  2. How is a petition brought under Cap. 3?
  3. When will the court decline to hear a petition?
  4. What remedies can the court give?
  5. How does this relate to judicial review?
  6. Exam focus
  7. Practice question: the demolition notice
  8. Key takeaways

What do Articles 26(2) and 30(3) provide?

  • Article 30(3): a person who alleges that any provision of Part III has been, is being or is likely to be contravened in relation to him may institute proceedings in the High Court for redress.
  • Article 30(4): Parliament may make laws for the procedure and powers of the High Court in such proceedings; Cap. 3 is that law.
  • Article 26(2): every person has the right to take legal action to ensure the protection of the Constitution and the laws. In Rev. Christopher Mtikila v AG [1995] TLR 31 the High Court read this as allowing public interest litigation even without personal injury.

How is a petition brought under Cap. 3?

  1. Petition: filed in the High Court in the form required by the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2014, supported by affidavit, setting out the provisions allegedly contravened and the relief sought.
  2. Parties: where the complaint concerns a law or Government action, the Attorney General is joined as respondent.
  3. Standing: amendments made in 2020 require the petitioner to show in the affidavit how the alleged contravention affects him personally, narrowing earlier public interest practice under Art. 26(2). Check the current text of s. 4 when advising.
  4. Preliminary scrutiny: the court may dismiss a petition that is frivolous, vexatious or brought only to annoy.
  5. Panel: the petition is heard by three judges of the High Court.

When will the court decline to hear a petition?

  • Adequate alternative remedy (s. 8(2)): the High Court will not exercise its powers if satisfied that adequate means of redress are or have been available under any other law. A person who can appeal, apply for judicial review or sue in tort should normally use that route.
  • Challenges to the Constitution itself: in AG v Rev. Christopher Mtikila [2010] TZCA 162 the Court of Appeal held that courts cannot declare a provision of the Constitution unconstitutional; changes are for Parliament.
  • Matters that are purely private disputes not involving State action or the application of a law may fall outside the Bill of Rights.

What remedies can the court give?

  • Declaration that a law, or a provision of it, is void to the extent of inconsistency with the Constitution (Art. 64(5) makes the Constitution supreme).
  • Directions to Government: the court may, instead of striking down a law, give Government time to correct it. Under the Act, a law found unconstitutional may be treated as valid until corrected within the period the court sets.
  • Orders and writs to stop or prevent a contravention, and compensation in appropriate cases.
  • Statutes are presumed constitutional; the petitioner must show the contravention, after which the State must justify the limitation (Ndyanabo v AG [2002] TZCA 14).

How does this relate to judicial review?

Judicial review challenges the legality of administrative decisions (illegality, irrationality, procedural impropriety). A constitutional petition challenges laws or acts as contrary to the Bill of Rights. Where judicial review gives adequate redress, s. 8(2) of Cap. 3 points the applicant there. See Judicial Review of Administrative Action and Enforcement of Fundamental Rights.

Exam focus

  • Articles 26(2) and 30(3) and their relationship.
  • Procedure under Cap. 3: petition, AG, three judges, s. 8(2).
  • Standing before and after 2020.
  • Remedies and the Mtikila limit.

Practice question: the demolition notice

Question: A municipal council gives traders 24 hours’ notice to demolish stalls built under valid permits, citing an old by-law. A traders’ association wants to file a constitutional petition. Advise.

  1. Rights engaged: property (Art. 24), fair hearing (Art. 13(6)) and work (Art. 22).
  2. Standing: each petitioner must show personal effect under the amended Cap. 3; individual traders should join.
  3. Section 8(2): judicial review of the council’s decision may be an adequate remedy; the court may refuse a petition if so. Consider an urgent judicial review application with an interim order.
  4. If the by-law itself is challenged as unconstitutional, a petition against the council and the AG is appropriate.

Key takeaways

  • Petition the High Court under Art. 30(3) and Cap. 3.
  • Three judges hear petitions; the AG is joined.
  • Section 8(2) bars petitions where other adequate remedies exist.
  • Courts cannot strike down the Constitution itself.

Key Statutes and Cases on Enforcing Basic Rights in Tanzania: Article 30(3) and the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act

Statutes

  • Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 26(2) action to protect the Constitution; Art. 30(3) and (4) petition to the High Court for redress
  • Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act, Cap. 3 R.E. 2023Petitions to the High Court; s. 8(2) court not to exercise powers where adequate means of redress exist under other law; panel of three judges; Attorney General as respondent; amendments of 2020 on standing
  • Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2014 (GN 324 of 2014)Form and procedure of petitions

Cases

  • Rev. Christopher Mtikila v Attorney General [1995] TLR 31 (HC)Article 26(2) supports public interest litigation without personal injury
  • Attorney General v Rev. Christopher Mtikila, Civil Appeal No. 45 of 2009, [2010] TZCA 162Courts cannot declare a provision of the Constitution itself unconstitutional
  • Julius Ishengoma Francis Ndyanabo v Attorney General [2002] TZCA 14Generous interpretation; presumption of constitutionality of statutes

Test yourself

Enforcing Basic Rights in Tanzania: Article 30(3) and the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Human Rights Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfEnforcing Basic Rights in Tanzania: Article 30(3) and the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement ActTake the quiz