In short
Equity is the body of rules first developed by the English Court of Chancery to soften the rigidity of the common law and to do justice where the common law gave no remedy or an unfair one. Its great creations are the trust and discretionary remedies such as injunctions and specific performance. Since the Judicature Acts of 1873 to 1875, the same courts administer law and equity, and where they conflict equity prevails. In Tanzania, s. 2(3) of the Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358 applies the doctrines of equity in force in England on 22 July 1920, so far as local circumstances permit and subject to Tanzanian statutes.
On this page 8 sections
What is equity?
- In everyday speech equity means fairness. In law it has a narrower, technical meaning: the particular rules and remedies developed by the Chancellor and the Court of Chancery.
- Equity is not a complete system. It is a gloss on the common law: it assumes the common law exists and intervenes where following it strictly would be unconscionable.
- Equity acts in personam: it operates on the conscience of the defendant and orders him to do or not do something, backed by contempt of court.
How did equity develop?
- Defects of the common law: by the fourteenth century the common law courts had become rigid. A claim had to fit a writ; damages were the main remedy; procedure was technical; juries could be intimidated.
- Petitions to the Chancellor: disappointed litigants petitioned the King, who passed them to the Lord Chancellor, keeper of the King’s conscience. Over time the Court of Chancery emerged.
- Conflict: Chancery issued “common injunctions” restraining parties from enforcing common law judgments obtained unconscionably. The conflict came to a head in the Earl of Oxford’s Case (1615) 1 Ch Rep 1, and King James I ruled that where law and equity conflict, equity prevails.
- Systematisation: under Lord Nottingham and Lord Eldon, equity became a body of settled principles bound by precedent. Its discretion is a judicial discretion exercised on principle.
- Judicature Acts 1873 to 1875: the separate courts were merged into one Supreme Court that administers both law and equity. Section 25(11) of the 1873 Act confirmed that equity prevails in any conflict.
Were law and equity fused?
- Procedural fusion: it is agreed that the Acts fused the administration of the two systems. One court can now grant both damages and an injunction in the same action.
- Substantive fusion debate: some judges have said the rules themselves have merged; the orthodox view (often described as “the two streams of jurisdiction run in the same channel but do not mingle their waters”) is that they remain distinct.
- Practical example: in Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9 a tenant under an agreement for a lease that was not by deed was treated as holding on the terms of the agreement, because equity treats as done that which ought to be done, and equity prevailed over the common law view that he was only a yearly tenant.
How does equity apply in Tanzania?
- Reception: section 2(3) of Cap. 358 applies the substance of the common law, the doctrines of equity and statutes of general application in force in England on 22 July 1920.
- Limits: they apply only so far as the circumstances of Tanzania and its people permit, subject to qualifications that local circumstances render necessary, and subject to Tanzanian written law. Equitable doctrines developed in England after 1920 are persuasive only.
- Statutory adoption: some equitable rules are now in statute, for example undue influence in the Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345, and temporary injunctions in section 68 and Order XXXVII of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33.
- Courts: Tanzanian courts apply law and equity together. Equity is visible daily in temporary injunctions, where the High Court applies the test in Atilio v Mbowe (1969) HCD 284; see Equitable Remedies: Injunctions, Specific Performance, Rescission and Rectification.
- Other systems: customary and Islamic law have their own trust-like institutions, such as family land held for the clan and the Islamic waqf. The English law of trusts applies mainly to statutory and formal trusts.
What are equity’s main contributions?
- The trust and the law of fiduciaries.
- The equity of redemption in mortgages; see Mortgages and the Matrimonial Home.
- Equitable remedies: injunction, specific performance, rescission, rectification, account.
- Doctrines of undue influence, unconscionable bargains, estoppel and confidence.
- Assignment of things in action.
Exam focus
- Explain why equity arose and the significance of the Earl of Oxford’s Case.
- Discuss the fusion debate.
- Explain how s. 2(3) of Cap. 358 applies equity in Tanzania and its limits.
Practice question: is equity still relevant?
Question: “Equity is an English historical accident with no place in modern Tanzanian law.” Discuss.
- Explain the historical origin, then show equity’s continuing role through s. 2(3) of Cap. 358.
- Give modern Tanzanian uses: temporary injunctions, specific performance, trusts and incorporated trustees, mortgages.
- Acknowledge the limits: local circumstances, statutes, and customary and Islamic institutions.
- Conclude that equity is received law with active, everyday application.
Key takeaways
- Equity corrects the common law and acts in personam.
- Where law and equity conflict, equity prevails.
- The Judicature Acts fused administration, not necessarily the rules.
- Equity applies in Tanzania through s. 2(3) of Cap. 358, as at 22 July 1920.
Key Statutes and Cases on Introduction to Equity: Nature, History and Application
Statutes
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358s. 2(3) applies the doctrines of equity in force in England on 22 July 1920, subject to local circumstances and Tanzanian written law
- Law of Contract Act, Cap. 345Codifies some equitable contract rules such as undue influence
- Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33s. 68 and Order XXXVII temporary injunctions
Cases
- Earl of Oxford's Case (1615) 1 Ch Rep 1Where common law and equity conflict, equity prevails
- Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9An agreement for a lease is as good as a lease in equity
- Atilio v Mbowe (1969) HCD 284Tanzanian test for temporary injunctions drawn from equity
Test yourself
Introduction to Equity: Nature, History and Application in Tanzania Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
