In short
An express trust is enforceable only once it is completely constituted, meaning the trust property has actually become vested in the trustee. Under Milroy v Lord (1862) 4 De GF & J 264 a settlor can do this in two ways: declare himself trustee, or transfer the property to trustees using the correct method of transfer for that kind of property. If the settlor fails, equity will not assist a volunteer (someone who gave no consideration) by treating a failed gift as a declaration of trust. Exceptions exist where the donor has done everything in his power (Re Rose), where the donee becomes the donor’s executor (Strong v Bird), in gifts made in contemplation of death, and through proprietary estoppel.
On this page 8 sections
What are the ways to benefit someone under Milroy v Lord?
- Outright gift: transfer the legal title to the donee.
- Transfer to trustees: transfer the legal title to trustees to hold for the beneficiary.
- Self-declaration: declare yourself trustee of property you own.
The court will not convert one into another. If the settlor tries to transfer to trustees but uses the wrong method, the court will not rescue the attempt by treating him as having declared himself trustee. In Milroy v Lord itself, shares were not properly transferred, and the attempted trust failed.
How is legal title transferred for different property?
| Property | Method in Tanzania |
|---|---|
| Movable goods | Delivery, or a deed of gift |
| Money in a bank | Transfer to the trustee’s account, or cheque paid |
| Company shares | Executed transfer instrument and registration in the company’s register of members (Companies Act, Cap. 212) |
| Land (right of occupancy) | Disposition approved by the Commissioner where required, executed in the prescribed form and registered under the Land Registration Act, Cap. 334 |
| Debts and contractual rights | Written assignment and notice to the debtor |
Key Statutes and Cases on Constituting a Trust: Formalities and Transfer of Property
Statutes
- Land Act, Cap. 113Dispositions of rights of occupancy require approval and proper documentation
- Land Registration Act, Cap. 334Registration of dispositions of registered land
- Companies Act, Cap. 212Transfer of shares by instrument and registration
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358Reception of equity and statutes of general application as at 22 July 1920
Cases
- Milroy v Lord (1862) 4 De GF and J 264Three ways to benefit another; a failed gift will not be saved as a trust
- Re Rose [1952] Ch 499Gift complete in equity once the donor had done all in his power
- Strong v Bird (1874) LR 18 Eq 315Imperfect gift perfected when the donee becomes executor
- Re Ralli's Will Trusts [1964] Ch 288Property reaching trustees by any route constitutes the trust
- Sen v Headley [1991] Ch 425Donatio mortis causa of land
- Re Bowden [1936] Ch 71Once constituted, the trust binds the settlor
Test yourself
Constituting a Trust: Formalities and Transfer of Property Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
