Constitutional Law notes · Topic 4 of 12

The Union Between Tanganyika and Zanzibar

The legal structure of the United Republic — Union Matters, the Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar, and the complexities of shared sovereignty.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 7 min read
On this page 8 sections
  1. Introduction
  2. Historical Foundation of the Union
  3. The Nature of the Union: Federal, Unitary, or Sui Generis?
  4. Recurring Tensions in the Union
  5. Important Case Law
  6. Practical Example
  7. Exam Tips and Key Takeaways
  8. Quick Summary

Introduction

The Union between Tanganyika and Zanzibar is one of the most legally complex and politically sensitive aspects of Tanzania’s constitutional order. Understanding the Union is not optional for a Tanzanian law student — it is essential. Many constitutional disputes, legislative competence questions, and political debates in Tanzania arise from the Union structure.

The Union is unique in Africa and in the world: it is not fully federal, not fully unitary, and not a confederation. It is a special arrangement that has evolved over sixty years and continues to generate legal debate.

Historical Foundation of the Union

The United Republic of Tanzania was formed on 26 April 1964, when the Republic of Tanganyika and the People’s Republic of Zanzibar merged under the Articles of Union signed by President Julius Nyerere (Tanganyika) and President Abeid Amani Karume (Zanzibar). The constitutional basis for the Union is found in Articles 1–5 of the Constitution.

Article 1(1): “Tanzania is one state and is a sovereign United Republic.” This establishes the unitary character of the Union.

Article 1(2): “The United Republic shall consist of the whole of Tanganyika and the whole of Zanzibar.” This defines the territorial extent.

The Nature of the Union: Federal, Unitary, or Sui Generis?

Legal scholars have long debated the nature of Tanzania’s constitutional arrangement:

Arguments for Federal Character

  • Zanzibar has its own Constitution (1984), its own President, its own legislature (House of Representatives), and its own government (Revolutionary Government).

  • Zanzibar has exclusive legislative competence over non-Union matters within its territory.

  • Zanzibar’s President is elected separately by Zanzibar’s voters.

Arguments for Unitary Character

  • Article 1(1) declares Tanzania “one state.”

  • There is no Tanganyika government — Union institutions serve as Tanganyika’s government for non-Union matters.

  • The Union Parliament (National Assembly) is supreme over the entire territory.

  • The President of the URT is directly elected by all voters in Tanzania.

The Prevailing View

Most constitutional scholars characterise the Union as sui generis — a unique arrangement that does not fit neatly into any category. The Constitution creates a two-government system: the Union Government and the Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar, with specified Union Matters falling to the former and remaining matters for Zanzibar. There is no government of “Tanganyika” — this asymmetry is the Union’s most distinctive feature.

Union Matters — The First Schedule

The First Schedule to the Constitution lists the matters that fall under the jurisdiction of the Union Government. These matters are legislated for by the Union Parliament and administered by Union institutions for the whole of Tanzania. As of the current Constitution, there are 22 Union Matters, including:

  • The Constitution and the Government of the United Republic.

  • External Affairs.

  • Defence and Security.

  • Police.

  • Emergency Powers.

  • Citizenship.

  • Immigration.

  • External Trade and Borrowing.

  • Income Tax.

  • Customs and Excise Duties.

  • Harbours and Maritime Administration.

  • Posts and Telecommunications.

  • Currency and Banking.

  • Higher Education.

  • Statistics.

  • Courts (the Court of Appeal serves both mainland Tanzania and Zanzibar).

Non-Union matters — everything else — are within the exclusive competence of Zanzibar for Zanzibar’s territory, and within the competence of the Union Parliament for mainland Tanzania (since there is no separate Tanganyika government).

The Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar

Articles 102–108 of the Constitution establish and recognise the Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar. Key features:

The President of Zanzibar

Article 102 provides that there shall be a President of Zanzibar who shall be the Head of the Executive in Zanzibar and the Chairman of the Revolutionary Council of Zanzibar. The President of Zanzibar is elected directly by Zanzibari voters in a separate election (Article 103).

The House of Representatives

Article 63(2) provides that Parliament of the United Republic shall consist of the President of the URT and the National Assembly. But Zanzibar also has the House of Representatives (Articles 63(4) and 119–124) as the legislature for Zanzibar’s non-Union matters.

The Revolutionary Council

The Revolutionary Council of Zanzibar functions as the Cabinet of the Zanzibar government, comprising the President of Zanzibar, the Chief Minister, and other ministers.

The Special Constitutional Court

Articles 125–126 establish the Special Constitutional Court, which has exclusive jurisdiction over disputes between the Union Government and the Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar concerning the interpretation of the Constitution as it relates to the Union. The Court is composed of the Chief Justice of Tanzania as Chairman, the Chief Justice of Zanzibar, and three other judges appointed by the President of the URT after consultation with the President of Zanzibar.

The Special Constitutional Court is distinct from the Court of Appeal — it has a specific and limited jurisdiction relating only to Union disputes.

Recurring Tensions in the Union

The Three-Government Debate

One of the most persistent debates in Tanzanian politics is whether the Union should move to a three-government structure: a Tanganyika government, a Zanzibar government, and a Union government. The 2013 Draft Constitution proposed this structure. Mainland Tanzanians have long complained that they lack their own government — Union institutions serve as Tanganyika’s government, creating an asymmetry.

Oil and Gas Resources

Significant offshore gas reserves have been discovered in Tanzania, primarily off the coast of mainland Tanzania. Disputes have arisen over whether these resources are a Union Matter (under government control) or a Tanzanian matter (with revenue implications for mainland administration). This illustrates how the Union structure affects everyday policy.

Important Case Law

CASE: AG v. Rev. Christopher Mtikila, Civil Appeal No. 45 of 2009 (Court of Appeal)

Court: Court of Appeal of Tanzania

Year: 2009

Facts: (Note: This is one of several Mtikila cases. In this particular appeal, the Court examined the constitutional validity of requiring candidates for Union government positions to be members of registered political parties.)

Legal Issue: Did the constitutional provisions requiring party membership for parliamentary and presidential candidates violate fundamental rights?

Decision: The Court of Appeal reversed the High Court’s earlier decision (Mtikila HC 1993) and held that the ban on independent candidates was constitutionally valid — the Constitution itself, as amended, expressly required party membership. Since the Constitution is supreme, provisions in the Constitution itself cannot be challenged as unconstitutional.

Significance: Established the important principle that constitutional provisions cannot themselves be declared unconstitutional — they can only be changed through the amendment procedure (Article 98). This was later challenged internationally — see the African Court case below.

CASE: Tanganyika Law Society & Rev. Mtikila v. United Republic of Tanzania, African Court App. Nos. 009 and 011/2011 (African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Judgment 14 June 2013)

Court: African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (Arusha)

Year: 2013

Facts: After the Court of Appeal upheld the ban on independent candidates, Mtikila and the Tanganyika Law Society took the case to the African Court. They argued that Tanzania’s constitutional ban violated Articles 2, 3, 10 and 13(1) of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (right to equality, freedom of association, right to participate in government).

Decision: The African Court held that Tanzania had violated Articles 2, 3, 10 and 13(1) of the African Charter. The Court ordered Tanzania to take constitutional and legislative measures to remedy the violation.

Significance: (1) This was the first case decided on the merits by the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights. (2) It demonstrated that even constitutionally entrenched provisions in national constitutions can violate regional human rights treaties. (3) Tanzania subsequently amended the Constitution to allow independent candidates in certain local elections (though not yet for Parliament or the Presidency).

Practical Example

The Government of Zanzibar wishes to negotiate and enter into a bilateral trade agreement with China, covering imports of Chinese goods into Zanzibar. Can Zanzibar do this? External Trade is a Union Matter under the First Schedule. Therefore, Zanzibar does not have the competence to enter into international trade agreements — this is a Union matter that must be handled by the Union Government. However, Zanzibar can promote domestic tourism, regulate local markets, and administer local businesses — these are non-Union matters within its competence.

Exam Tips and Key Takeaways

Examiners frequently ask students to explain the nature of the Union — give a nuanced answer (not simply “federal” or “unitary”). Use the term “sui generis” or “asymmetric union” with explanation.

Memorise at least 5–8 Union Matters from the First Schedule.

Know the difference between the Special Constitutional Court (Articles 125–126, Union disputes only) and the Court of Appeal (general appellate jurisdiction).

Quick Summary

  • Union formed 26 April 1964 — Articles of Union, Nyerere and Karume.

  • Articles 1–5 TCUR establish the United Republic.

  • 22 Union Matters in the First Schedule — exclusive Union Government jurisdiction.

  • Non-Union Matters: Zanzibar’s government has jurisdiction for Zanzibar; Union Parliament for mainland.

  • Zanzibar has own President (Art. 102), House of Representatives (Arts. 119–124), and constitution.

  • Special Constitutional Court (Arts. 125–126): Union disputes only.

  • Three-government debate remains unresolved — Draft 2013 failed.

  • African Court 2013 (Mtikila): ban on independent candidates violated African Charter.

Test yourself

The Union Between Tanganyika and Zanzibar Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Constitutional Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfThe Union Between Tanganyika and Zanzibar Practice QuizTake the quiz