On this page 9 sections
Introduction
The separation of powers is one of the oldest and most important principles in constitutional law. It holds that the functions of government should be divided among different institutions — so that no single person or body has absolute power. In Tanzania, this principle is not merely theoretical: it is embedded in the constitutional structure and regularly litigated.
Understanding this doctrine helps you analyse whether government actions are constitutional. Whenever you see the executive trying to act like a legislature, or the legislature interfering with judicial decisions, the separation of powers doctrine is engaged.
Introduction
The separation of powers is one of the oldest and most important principles in constitutional law. It holds that the functions of government should be divided among different institutions — so that no single person or body has absolute power. In Tanzania, this principle is not merely theoretical: it is embedded in the constitutional structure and regularly litigated.
Understanding this doctrine helps you analyse whether government actions are constitutional. Whenever you see the executive trying to act like a legislature, or the legislature interfering with judicial decisions, the separation of powers doctrine is engaged.
The Origin: Montesquieu’s Theory
The doctrine was articulated most influentially by the French philosopher Charles-Louis de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu, in his 1748 work L’Esprit des Lois (The Spirit of the Laws). He observed that England’s relative freedom was due to the separation of its three functions — legislative, executive, and judicial — into three distinct bodies. He concluded that combining any two of these in one body would lead to tyranny.
John Locke earlier (in the Second Treatise on Government, 1689) proposed a distinction between legislative and executive power. But it was Montesquieu who gave the doctrine its classic formulation, which influenced constitutions worldwide — including Tanzania’s.
The Tanzanian Constitutional Framework
The Executive (Articles 33–61)
The President is the head of the executive. Executive power includes: governing the country, implementing laws, managing public finances, commanding the armed forces, and directing foreign policy. The executive cannot legislate (make laws) except as authorised by Parliament through delegated legislation.
The Legislature (Articles 62–106)
Parliament (the President and National Assembly) has the exclusive power to make laws. No institution — not the President, not the courts — can make law of general application except through Parliament (except delegated legislation authorised by Parliament). Parliament also holds the executive to account through oversight mechanisms.
The Judiciary (Articles 107A–125)
The courts interpret and apply the law. The courts do not make law in the same sense as Parliament (though judicial decisions create precedent — a form of “judge-made law”). Courts also have the power of judicial review — examining whether executive and legislative actions comply with the Constitution.
Checks and Balances in Tanzania
The separation of powers alone is insufficient — if each arm is completely independent, there is no mechanism to prevent abuse. Checks and balances ensure that each arm constrains the others:
Executive Checks on Legislature
-
The President must assent to Bills passed by the National Assembly (Article 97(1)). If the President withholds assent, the Bill does not become law.
-
The President can dissolve Parliament (Article 90).
-
Presidential nominees to Parliament give the executive representation in the legislature.
Legislature Checks on Executive
-
Parliament can pass a vote of no confidence in the Prime Minister (Article 53A).
-
Parliament must approve the budget — the executive cannot spend money without Parliamentary appropriation.
-
Parliament debates and scrutinises government policy through committees and questions.
-
Parliament can impeach the President (Articles 46A–46B) with a two-thirds majority.
-
Parliament must ratify international treaties (by convention and specific statutes).
Judicial Checks on Executive and Legislature
-
Judicial review: courts can declare executive actions unlawful or unconstitutional.
-
Courts can declare laws passed by Parliament void if inconsistent with the Constitution (Article 64(5)).
-
Habeas corpus: courts can order the release of persons unlawfully detained by the executive.
-
Courts can grant injunctions against government actions pending a constitutional challenge.
Delegated Legislation and Constitutional Limits
Parliament sometimes delegates legislative power to the executive — giving a Minister or the President authority to make regulations, by-laws, or statutory instruments. This is called delegated or subsidiary legislation. It is constitutionally valid provided:
-
The parent Act (passed by Parliament) clearly authorises the delegation.
-
The delegated legislation does not go beyond the scope of the authorising Act (ultra vires doctrine).
-
The delegated legislation complies with the Constitution.
Courts can strike down delegated legislation that is ultra vires the parent Act or inconsistent with the Constitution.
Ouster Clauses and Their Constitutional Validity
An ouster clause is a provision in a statute that attempts to exclude judicial review of certain decisions. For example: “No court shall have jurisdiction to review any decision made by the Electoral Commission.” Tanzanian courts have held that ouster clauses cannot validly exclude the High Court’s constitutional jurisdiction under Article 30(3) — because Article 64(5) (supremacy of the Constitution) means that Parliament cannot override the constitutional right of access to the courts.
Judicial Review of Executive Action
Judicial review in Tanzania takes two forms:
Constitutional Judicial Review
Under Article 30(3) and the Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act (Cap. 3, R.E. 2002), any person can challenge executive action that violates fundamental rights. The High Court can grant: declarations, injunctions, compensation, and orders of certiorari, mandamus, or prohibition.
Administrative Law Judicial Review
Under the Law Reform (Fatal Accidents and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act (Cap. 310) and common law, courts can review administrative decisions for: illegality (acting outside powers), irrationality/unreasonableness (Wednesbury unreasonableness), and procedural impropriety (failing to observe natural justice — the right to be heard, and the rule against bias).
Important Case Law
|
CASE 1: Festo Balegele & 794 Others v. Dar es Salaam City Council [1991] TLR 94 (High Court) |
|
Court: High Court of Tanzania, Dar es Salaam Year: 1991 Facts: The City Council, an executive body, ordered demolition of houses without following due process. The petitioners argued the Council had acted outside its legal authority and violated their constitutional rights. Decision: Mwalusanya J held that local authorities (part of the executive arm) must act within their constitutionally and statutorily authorised limits. Demolishing property without compensation or due process violated the petitioners’ rights under Article 24. Principle: The separation of powers requires that executive bodies act only within their constitutional and statutory authority. Courts have jurisdiction to check executive excess at all levels of government. |
|
CASE 2: Joseph Ngereza v. Republic [1987] TLR 101 (High Court) |
|
Court: High Court of Tanzania Year: 1987 Facts: The applicant challenged an executive order made under the Preventive Detention Act, arguing the order was made in bad faith and for an improper purpose. Decision: The court affirmed its jurisdiction to review executive detention orders for compliance with constitutional guarantees of personal liberty (Article 15), even where the statute purported to grant wide discretion to the executive. Principle: Statutory discretion given to the executive must be exercised consistently with the Constitution. The courts are the guardians of constitutional rights against executive overreach. |
|
CASE 3: AG v. Lohay Akonaay [1995] TLR 80 (Court of Appeal — Separation of Powers Aspect) |
|
Court: Court of Appeal of Tanzania Year: 1995 Separation of Powers Aspect: The Court of Appeal’s willingness to strike down an Act of Parliament — the Regulation of Land Tenure (Established Villages) Act — confirmed that the judiciary has the power to check the legislature. Parliament is not sovereign; it is subject to the Constitution. The courts, as guardians of the Constitution, can invalidate parliamentary legislation. Principle: Separation of powers in Tanzania does not mean each arm is unaccountable. The judiciary acts as the ultimate check on both the executive and the legislature by enforcing constitutional limits. |
Practical Scenario — How Separation of Powers Works
SCENARIO: Parliament passes the “National Security Act 2025” giving the President power to suspend any court proceedings that involve “matters of national security” by issuing a presidential decree. Analyse this provision using the separation of powers doctrine.
ANALYSIS: (1) The provision gives the executive (President) power over the judiciary (suspending court proceedings). This violates the separation of powers. (2) Article 107A(2)(e) provides that courts “shall not be subject to control or direction of any person or authority.” A presidential decree suspending proceedings is exactly this kind of direction. (3) Such a provision in an ordinary Act of Parliament cannot override a constitutional guarantee of judicial independence — under Article 64(5), the constitutional provision prevails. (4) The High Court, on a constitutional petition, should declare the relevant section of the National Security Act void.
Quick Summary
-
Separation of powers: executive (Arts. 33–61), legislature (Arts. 62–106), judiciary (Arts. 107A–125).
-
Montesquieu: combining two functions = tyranny; three separate arms = freedom.
-
Checks and balances: each arm constrains the others.
-
Judicial review: courts can strike down executive and legislative acts inconsistent with the Constitution.
-
Delegated legislation valid if within the parent Act’s scope and constitutionally compliant.
-
Ouster clauses cannot validly exclude the High Court’s constitutional jurisdiction.
-
Key cases: Festo Balegele [1991], Ngereza [1987], Lohay Akonaay [1995].
Test yourself
Separation of Powers and Checks & Balances Practice Quiz Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
