Civil Procedure notes · Topic 14 of 20

Judgment, Decree, and Costs

The end of the trial — what a judgment is, what a decree is, the kinds of judgment, the rule that costs follow the event, and the taxation of costs in Tanzania.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 13 min read

When the trial ends and the court has heard everything, it goes away to consider its decision. On a reserved date, it returns to deliver its judgment. The judgment becomes a decree. The decree is what’s enforced. Costs are awarded. The case, at first instance, is complete.

This topic is heavily definitional and easy to score in exams if you know the precise distinctions. Many students confuse judgment with decree; many lose marks on costs because they don’t know the three working principles. Master the definitions and the principles, and you’ll do well.

The governing provisions are Order XX of the CPC (judgment and decree), section 36 CPC (costs), section 3 CPC (definitions), and the Advocates Remuneration Order under the Advocates Act, Cap. 341 R.E. 2023 (taxation).

Definitions in Section 3 CPC

Three terms are defined in section 3 of the CPC:

A judgment is a statement given by a judge or magistrate of the grounds for a decree or order. Put differently, judgment is the reasoned decision of the court on the main question in the proceeding. Judgment includes both the decision and the reasons.

A decree is the formal expression of an adjudication that conclusively determines the rights of the parties on any of the matters in controversy in the suit. A decree may be preliminary, final, or partly preliminary and partly final.

A ruling (sometimes called an order) is a decision of the court on a preliminary or interlocutory matter — anything that is not a decree.

An order is the formal expression of any decision of the court that is not a decree.

These are different things. A judgment is the reasoning; a decree is the formal expression that gives effect to the operative part. Every decree is preceded by a judgment; not every judicial decision is a decree.

Distinguishing Judgment, Decree, Order, and Ruling

This is a question examiners ask regularly. Here is the working summary:

A judgment is the reasoned decision of the court — it contains the reasoning.

A decree is the formal expression of an adjudication that conclusively determines the rights of the parties on a matter in controversy. A decree follows a judgment and reduces its operative part to an enforceable form.

An order is every other formal decision of the court — it is anything that is not a decree. Most interlocutory decisions are orders.

A ruling is, in practice, often used synonymously with an order on a preliminary or interlocutory point.

The practical importance of the distinction:

A decree is appealable as of right (subject to statute). An order is appealable only where the statute specifically allows.

A judgment without a decree is not enforceable on its own — the decree must be drawn up to enable execution.

The judgment contains the reasoning that may be relied on for review or revision; the decree contains the operative formal terms.

A useful one-liner: “Reasons in the judgment, rights in the decree, everything else is an order.”

Form and Contents of a Judgment — Order XX

Order XX of the CPC governs the form, contents, and pronouncement of judgments.

Pronouncement

The court is required to deliver judgment within a reasonable time after the close of the hearing. The judgment is pronounced in open court. It is dated, signed, and sealed by the judge or magistrate.

Contents

A judgment must contain:

A summary of the case (a concise narrative of the facts).

The points for determination (the issues framed).

The court’s decision on each issue.

The reasons for that decision.

The court must state its finding on each issue raised, unless the finding on any one issue is sufficient to dispose of the suit (in which case the court may decline to address the remaining issues).

The judgment can be written and typed, or in some cases dictated to a stenographer and later signed.

Types of Judgment

Several classifications of judgment are recognised:

Judgment in rem versus judgment in personam

Judgment in rem is a judgment on the status of a particular subject matter. It is conclusive against the whole world. Examples: a divorce decree; a declaration of legitimacy; a declaration of the validity of a marriage; the seizure of goods in admiralty. Anyone affected by the matter is bound by the judgment, whether or not they were parties.

Judgment in personam (or judgment inter partes) is a judgment that binds only the parties or their privies. It does not affect strangers. Most civil judgments are in personam — judgments in contract, in tort, in defamation.

Final versus interlocutory judgment

A final judgment puts an end to the action by declaring one party entitled to a remedy. It can be executed.

An interlocutory judgment does not determine the matter to finality. It is not complete and definitive. (Examples: a judgment on a preliminary issue of jurisdiction that leaves the substantive issues for trial; a judgment on liability with damages to be assessed later.)

Decree nisi and decree absolute

Decree nisi: a provisional decree which, on the proper steps being taken, will be made absolute. Most commonly seen in matrimonial proceedings — every decree for dissolution or nullity of marriage is in the first instance a decree nisi, and cannot be made absolute until the expiration of a certain period. During that period, a person is at liberty to show cause to the court why the decree should not be made absolute.

Key Statutes and Cases on Judgment, Decree, and Costs

Statutes

  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33 R.E. 2023s. 3 definitions; s. 35 interest; s. 36 costs; Order XX judgment and decree
  • Advocates Remuneration Order, 2015 (GN No. 264 of 2015)Taxation of costs

Test yourself

Judgment, Decree, and Costs Practice Quiz Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free

Take the quiz

Get the Full Civil Procedure Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Keep reading this topicFrom TSh 5,000 a weekJoin Now