Environmental Law notes · Topic 2 of 8

The Right to a Clean Environment and Environmental Litigation

The right to a clean, safe and healthy environment under section 4 of the Environmental Management Act, the right of any person to bring proceedings under section 5 without proving personal harm, its link to the constitutional right to life, standing in environmental cases, and the leading Tanzanian cases: Kessy, Balegele and Mavika.

  • Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLPBy Isack Kimaro, LL.B, PDLP
  • Reviewed
  • 10 min read

In short

Section 4 of the Environmental Management Act, Cap. 191 declares that every person living in Tanzania has a right to a clean, safe and healthy environment, together with a duty to protect it. Section 5 lets any person bring proceedings to stop or prevent environmental harm without having to show personal loss or injury. Before the EMA, courts already protected communities by linking pollution to the constitutional right to life and using nuisance and judicial review, as in Joseph D. Kessy v Dar es Salaam City Council, Festo Balegele v Dar es Salaam City Council and Felix Mavika v Dar es Salaam City Commission.

On this page 8 sections
  1. What does section 4 of the EMA provide?
  2. Who can sue under section 5?
  3. How is the environment linked to the right to life?
  4. What did the leading cases decide?
  5. What causes of action are available?
  6. Exam focus
  7. Practice question: the tannery and the river
  8. Key takeaways

What does section 4 of the EMA provide?

  • Every person living in Tanzania has a right to a clean, safe and healthy environment.
  • The right includes the right of access to environmental resources for recreational, educational, health, spiritual, cultural and economic purposes, as the Act provides.
  • It is matched by a duty on every person to protect, conserve and enhance the environment and to report activities likely to harm it.

Who can sue under section 5?

  • Any person whose right under s. 4 is threatened, or any person acting in the public interest, may bring an action against a person whose act or omission is causing or likely to cause harm to the environment.
  • The claimant does not need to prove personal loss or injury. This removes the old barrier of locus standi that blocked many public interest environmental cases.
  • The court may order measures to prevent or stop the harm, require restoration, compel a public officer to act, or award compensation to victims.
  • This standing is wider than under the amended Basic Rights and Duties Enforcement Act, so environmental claims are often better framed under the EMA; see Enforcing Basic Rights in Tanzania.

How is the environment linked to the right to life?

  • Courts have treated a polluted environment that endangers health as a threat to the right to life under Article 14.
  • Article 27 places a duty on everyone to protect natural resources.
  • Article 26(2) supports public interest litigation to protect the Constitution and the laws.

What did the leading cases decide?

  1. Joseph D. Kessy v Dar es Salaam City Council (Civil Case No. 299 of 1988): residents of Tabata sued because the Council’s refuse dumping posed a danger to life. The High Court ordered the Council to stop dumping there and to find a suitable site. When the Council kept asking for more time to relocate, the court eventually refused further extension.
  2. Festo Balegele v Dar es Salaam City Council (Misc. Civil Cause No. 90 of 1991): after Kessy, the Council began dumping at Kunduchi Mtongani, a residential area in the Master Plan. The residents obtained orders of certiorari and prohibition: the decision was unlawful and unreasonable, a statutory duty to collect refuse must be performed lawfully, and a public authority may not pollute and endanger people’s lives.
  3. Felix Joseph Mavika v Dar es Salaam City Commission (Civil Case No. 316 of 2000): residents of Vingunguti sought interim orders against dumping that polluted their water. The Commission argued that only the Attorney General could sue for public nuisance. The High Court held the residents had standing, relying on the public interest litigation approach under Article 26 and the earlier cases.

What causes of action are available?

  • EMA s. 5 environmental action.
  • Nuisance (private and public), negligence, and the rule in Rylands v Fletcher for escapes of dangerous things; see Law of Torts.
  • Judicial review of unlawful decisions by authorities, such as permits issued without EIA.
  • Constitutional petitions on the right to life, subject to standing rules.
  • Complaints to NEMC and the Environmental Appeals Tribunal; see Environmental Enforcement, Offences and the Environmental Appeals Tribunal.

Exam focus

  • Content of EMA ss. 4 and 5.
  • The link to Articles 14, 26 and 27.
  • Facts and holdings of Kessy, Balegele and Mavika.

Practice question: the tannery and the river

Question: A tannery in Moshi discharges untreated waste into a river used by downstream villages. A university student who lives in Dar es Salaam wants to sue to stop it. Advise on standing and remedies.

  1. Under EMA s. 5, any person may sue in the public interest without proving personal loss, so the student has standing.
  2. Remedies: orders to stop discharges, restoration of the river, and directions to NEMC to act.
  3. Villagers may add claims in nuisance and for compensation; a complaint to NEMC can trigger compliance orders.

Key takeaways

  • EMA s. 4 gives a right to a clean, safe and healthy environment.
  • EMA s. 5 removes the need to prove personal injury to sue.
  • Courts link environmental harm to the right to life.
  • Kessy, Balegele and Mavika are the foundational cases.

Key Statutes and Cases on The Right to a Clean Environment and Environmental Litigation

Statutes

  • Environmental Management Act, Cap. 191s. 4 right to a clean, safe and healthy environment and the corresponding duty; s. 5 right of any person to bring an action without proving personal loss or injury, for orders to prevent, stop or remedy environmental harm
  • Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, 1977Art. 14 right to life; Art. 26(2) action to protect the Constitution and laws; Art. 27 duty to protect natural resources
  • Civil Procedure Code, Cap. 33Representative suits and public nuisance

Cases

  • Joseph D. Kessy and Others v Dar es Salaam City Council, Civil Case No. 299 of 1988 (HC, 1991)Dumping refuse endangered life; extensions refused
  • Festo Balegele and 794 Others v Dar es Salaam City Council, Misc. Civil Cause No. 90 of 1991 (HC, 1992)Decision to dump in a residential area quashed by certiorari
  • Felix Joseph Mavika and 4 Others v Dar es Salaam City Commission, Civil Case No. 316 of 2000 (HC, 2001)Residents had standing to seek interim relief against dumping at Vingunguti

Test yourself

The Right to a Clean Environment and Environmental Litigation Quiz

10 questions · instant feedback

Take the quiz

Get the Full Environmental Law Notes, Quizzes and Templates

Read every topic in full, take every quiz and download court-ready templates. Plans start at TSh 5,000 a week with M-Pesa, Airtel Money, Mixx by Yas or Halotel.

Jiunge leo, usome bila kikomo.

Test yourselfThe Right to a Clean Environment and Environmental LitigationTake the quiz