In short
A trust exists where a person (the trustee) holds property, legal title to which is vested in him, for the benefit of another person (the beneficiary) or for a purpose the law allows, so that the benefit belongs to the beneficiary and not the trustee. An express trust is valid only if the three certainties are present (Knight v Knight (1840) 3 Beav 148): certainty of intention to create a trust, certainty of the property subject to it, and certainty of the beneficiaries (objects).
On this page 10 sections
- Who are the parties to a trust?
- How is a trust different from similar relationships?
- How are trusts classified?
- What is certainty of intention?
- What is certainty of subject matter?
- What is certainty of objects?
- What happens if a certainty is missing?
- Exam focus
- Practice question: the farmer's will
- Key takeaways
Who are the parties to a trust?
- Settlor: the person who creates the trust by transferring property to trustees or declaring himself trustee. In a will trust, the testator.
- Trustee: holds legal title and manages the property. Trustees owe strict fiduciary duties.
- Beneficiary (cestui que trust): holds the equitable or beneficial interest and can enforce the trust.
- One person can hold more than one role, but a sole trustee cannot also be the sole beneficiary: legal and equitable title would merge.
How is a trust different from similar relationships?
| Relationship | Key difference from a trust |
|---|---|
| Contract | Based on agreement and consideration; a beneficiary need not be a party or give value |
| Agency | An agent acts for a principal; ownership does not usually pass to the agent |
| Bailment | Only possession passes; the bailor keeps ownership |
| Debt | A debtor owes money but the creditor has no proprietary right in the debtor’s assets; a beneficiary has a proprietary interest that survives the trustee’s insolvency |
| Power | A power may be exercised but need not be; a trust must be carried out |
How are trusts classified?
- By creation: express trusts (created intentionally), resulting trusts (arising by implication when the beneficial interest returns to the settlor) and constructive trusts (imposed by law to prevent unconscionability). See Resulting and Constructive Trusts.
- By object: private trusts (for individuals) and charitable or public trusts (for purposes benefiting the public). See Charitable Trusts and the Incorporation of Trustees in Tanzania.
- By the trustee’s discretion: fixed trusts (shares fixed by the settlor) and discretionary trusts (trustees choose who benefits and how much).
- By duties: bare (simple) trusts, where the trustee simply holds for an adult beneficiary, and special (active) trusts.
- Completely and incompletely constituted trusts.
What is certainty of intention?
- The settlor must intend to impose a binding obligation on the trustee. No special words are needed; the court looks at substance.
- Precatory words such as “in full confidence that” or “I hope” do not usually create a trust. In Re Adams and the Kensington Vestry (1884) 27 Ch D 394 a gift to a wife “in full confidence that she will do what is right” for the children was an absolute gift.
- Conduct and informal words can suffice. In Paul v Constance [1977] 1 WLR 527 a man who repeatedly told his partner that money in an account in his sole name was “as much yours as mine” was held to have declared a trust.
- If there is no intention, the recipient usually takes absolutely.
What is certainty of subject matter?
- The property must be identified, and so must each beneficiary’s share.
- Vague descriptions fail: “the bulk of my residuary estate” was uncertain in Palmer v Simmonds (1854) 2 Drew 221.
- Tangible goods must usually be segregated: a trust of unidentified bottles of wine in a larger stock failed (Re London Wine [1986] PCC 121).
- Intangibles such as identical shares may not need segregation: a trust of 50 out of 950 shares in one company was upheld (Hunter v Moss [1994] 1 WLR 452). The point is debated.
- If the property is certain but the shares are not, a trust may still survive if the trustees have discretion or the court can apply “equality is equity”.
What is certainty of objects?
- Fixed trusts: the complete list test. It must be possible to draw up a full list of beneficiaries.
- Discretionary trusts: the “is or is not” test from McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424. It must be possible to say of any given person whether he is or is not within the class. The class must also not be so wide as to be administratively unworkable.
- Conceptual certainty (is the class clearly defined?) is essential; evidential uncertainty (can we prove who fits?) can usually be resolved.
- Purpose trusts: a private trust for an abstract purpose generally fails because there is no beneficiary to enforce it, unless it is charitable or falls within anomalous exceptions.
What happens if a certainty is missing?
- No intention: the recipient takes the property absolutely.
- No certain subject matter: there is nothing for the trust to bite on; the gift fails.
- No certain objects: the trustee holds on resulting trust for the settlor or his estate.
Exam focus
- Always test all three certainties in order.
- Distinguish fixed and discretionary trusts for the objects test.
- Know Paul v Constance, Hunter v Moss and McPhail v Doulton.
Practice question: the farmer’s will
Question: Mzee Lukas’s will leaves “my cattle to my son Peter, hoping he will look after his sisters”, “most of my shares in CRDB to my good friends” and “TSh 20 million to be divided equally among my grandchildren”. Advise on validity.
- “Hoping” is precatory: Peter probably takes the cattle absolutely.
- “Most of my shares” lacks certainty of subject matter; “good friends” is conceptually uncertain. That gift fails.
- The grandchildren gift is a fixed trust with certain property; a complete list of grandchildren can be drawn, so it is valid.
Key takeaways
- A trust separates legal and beneficial ownership.
- Trusts are express, resulting or constructive; private or charitable; fixed or discretionary.
- All three certainties are needed for an express trust.
- Fixed trusts need a complete list; discretionary trusts use the is or is not test.
Key Statutes and Cases on The Trust: Definition, Classification and the Three Certainties
Statutes
- Judicature and Application of Laws Act, Cap. 358s. 2(3) receives the law of trusts as part of equity
- Trustees' Incorporation Act, Cap. 318Incorporation of trustees of bodies and associations
Cases
- Knight v Knight (1840) 3 Beav 148The three certainties
- Re Adams and the Kensington Vestry (1884) 27 Ch D 394Precatory words do not create a trust
- Paul v Constance [1977] 1 WLR 527'This money is as much yours as mine' showed intention to create a trust
- Palmer v Simmonds (1854) 2 Drew 221'The bulk of my estate' was uncertain
- Hunter v Moss [1994] 1 WLR 452Trust of 50 of 950 identical shares upheld
- Re London Wine Co (Shippers) Ltd [1986] PCC 121No trust of unsegregated tangible goods
- McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424Is or is not test for discretionary trusts
Test yourself
The Trust: Definition, Classification and the Three Certainties Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback
