In short
A marriage with a foreign element raises two separate questions: was the ceremony formally valid, and did each party have capacity to marry? At common law, form is governed by the law of the place of celebration (lex loci celebrationis) and capacity by the law of each party’s domicile. In Mainland Tanzania these rules are now largely written into the Law of Marriage Act, Cap. 29: section 36 recognises a marriage contracted abroad if it complied with the formalities of the place of celebration, each party had capacity under the law of his or her domicile, both consented freely, and, where a party is a Tanzanian citizen or domiciled in Mainland Tanzania, both also had capacity under the Act.
On this page 10 sections
- Why are formal validity and essential validity treated separately?
- Which law governs the formal validity of a marriage?
- Which law governs capacity to marry?
- How does Tanzanian law treat polygamous marriages from abroad?
- How can Tanzanians marry abroad, and foreigners marry in Tanzania?
- What happens if a foreign marriage fails the section 36 conditions?
- How did the Court of Appeal deal with a marriage abroad in Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga?
- Exam focus: what do examiners test on marriage in private international law?
- Practice question: the Dubai wedding
- Key takeaways
Why are formal validity and essential validity treated separately?
Characterisation decides the outcome in marriage cases, as Characterisation (Classification) in Private International Law showed with Ogden v Ogden. The two categories use different connecting factors:
- Formal validity covers the ceremony itself: notice, banns, the officiant, witnesses, registration, proxies, and the form of consent. It is governed by the law of the place of celebration.
- Essential validity (capacity) covers whether these particular people may marry each other: age, prohibited degrees of relationship, an existing marriage, and the capacity to contract a polygamous marriage. It is governed by the law of each party’s domicile.
Which law governs the formal validity of a marriage?
The law of the place where the marriage is celebrated. In Berthiaume v Dastous [1930] AC 79, a Catholic couple domiciled in Quebec married in a church in Paris without the civil ceremony required by French law. The Privy Council held the marriage void for want of form, even though it would have been valid in Quebec. In Apt v Apt [1948] P 83, a proxy marriage valid where celebrated (Argentina) was upheld because the use of a proxy concerns form.
The Law of Marriage Act adopts this rule. For a marriage contracted outside Tanzania, section 36 requires that it was contracted in a form required or permitted by the law of the country where it was contracted. For marriages in Tanzania, the Act’s own forms apply: civil, religious and customary forms, with the presumptions in section 10 about whether a marriage is monogamous or potentially polygamous.
Which law governs capacity to marry?
At common law, capacity is governed by the law of each party’s antenuptial domicile (the dual domicile test). In Brook v Brook (1861) 9 HLC 193, a man domiciled in England married his deceased wife’s sister in Denmark, where the marriage was allowed. Because English law, the law of both parties’ domicile, prohibited the marriage, it was void. In Sottomayor v De Barros (No 1) (1877) 3 PD 1, a marriage between first cousins domiciled in Portugal, where they needed a papal dispensation, was held void though celebrated in England. A rival “intended matrimonial home” test was applied in Radwan v Radwan (No 2) [1973] Fam 35 to capacity to enter a polygamous marriage.
Key Statutes and Cases on Marriage in Private International Law: Formal and Essential Validity
Statutes
- Law of Marriage Act, Cap. 29 R.E. 2019s. 10 kinds of marriage; s. 11 conversion; s. 13 age; s. 14 prohibited relationships; s. 34 embassy marriages; s. 35 certificate of no impediment; s. 36 recognition of marriages abroad; s. 37; s. 38 void ceremonies; s. 41; s. 45; s. 96(2)
Cases
- Berthiaume v Dastous [1930] AC 79Form governed by the place of celebration
- Brook v Brook (1861) 9 HLC 193Capacity governed by the law of domicile
- Sottomayor v De Barros (No 1) (1877) 3 PD 1Cousins domiciled in Portugal lacked capacity
- Radwan v Radwan (No 2) [1973] Fam 35Intended matrimonial home test for polygamous capacity
- Hyde v Hyde and Woodmansee (1866) LR 1 P & D 130Classic definition of monogamous marriage
- Gharib Abdallah Juma v Kay Mlinga, [2002] TZCA 10Danish marriage settlement and Zanzibar property
- Rebeca Z. Gyumi v Attorney General (HC 2016; upheld CAT 2019)Provisions on girls' marriage age declared unconstitutional
Test yourself
Marriage in Private International Law: Formal and Essential Validity Quiz
10 questions · instant feedback · 5 free
